Gransnet forums

News & politics

Donald Trump claims "Our God Saves"......

(202 Posts)
mae13 Tue 16-Jul-24 12:13:30

........but it would have been more impressive if "Our God" had prevented the assassination attempt in the first place.

Just where was he when the would-be assassin pulled the trigger?

MayBee70 Thu 18-Jul-24 10:33:36

Speaking to Democrat voters in America on Facebook who are horrified at the thought of Trump being president again, especially when it comes to women’s rights, even they ask the UK to ‘pray for them’.Americans seem to be so dominated by the church.

Dickens Thu 18-Jul-24 08:59:07

Greta

JD Vance is obviously part of God's plan. The working class boy who grew up in poverty in Ohio but had a damascene conversion and is now Trump's running mate. What a formidable duo.

Batman and Robin.

Greta Thu 18-Jul-24 07:51:05

JD Vance is obviously part of God's plan. The working class boy who grew up in poverty in Ohio but had a damascene conversion and is now Trump's running mate. What a formidable duo.

Dickens Thu 18-Jul-24 06:49:57

maddyone

Yes Maybee that’s exactly what frightens me. I feel so sorry for the poor, heroic people of Ukraine.
The possibility of war in Europe looms large in my mind too. Ukraine is fighting for Europe.

The possibility of war in Europe looms large in my mind too.

If JD Vance continues his ridiculous rhetoric about Britain now being an Islamist state, then it's quite likely those stupid (and I make no apology for using the word) Republicans who actually believe it to be true, will clamour for more of the same oratory. And that will spur Trump along his "America First" worldview, and two fingers up to Ukraine.

Fortunately, I'm sure there are Republicans - sans MAGA baseball and cowboy hats - who realise this is hard-right scaremongering.

As Edward Lucas, writing for the Daily Mail says of Vance, "It seems scarcely plausible that this bright graduate of Yale Law School actually believes that Sir Keir Starmer's victory this month puts us on a par with Iran, Afghanistan or Pakistan."

... but this is a man who once suggested that Trump might be America's Hitler and also described him as an idiot. Clearly, he's done a remarkable volte-face so might change his mind about Britain, who knows - if he's advised to tone-it-down a bit.

People were worried about what type of trade deal we might get under Biden, goodness only knows what type of deal we might now get as an 'Islamist state'!

My worry is that Vance is projecting himself as a simple working-class boy from the Rust Belt, and all those disaffected Rust-Belters will believe everything he says.

It's all very ominous. I think Europe has got to get its defence act together. And soon.

nanna8 Thu 18-Jul-24 06:43:32

As friends with the US traditionally you wonder where the UK and Australia and New Zealand will stand if Trump is President. Quite concerning in so many ways.

westendgirl Wed 17-Jul-24 17:33:15

I think the whole of that area could be under threat, especially that Putin's buddy from Belarus is happy to join in .

maddyone Wed 17-Jul-24 17:21:00

Yes Maybee that’s exactly what frightens me. I feel so sorry for the poor, heroic people of Ukraine.
The possibility of war in Europe looms large in my mind too. Ukraine is fighting for Europe.

Wyllow3 Wed 17-Jul-24 14:55:44

Normally there is a strong reaction from the anti-gun lobbies after an incident, but less so atm. Speculations are that they are wary because its so highly party politicised this time.

MayBee70 Wed 17-Jul-24 14:53:49

maddyone

We can voice our opinions of course, but our opinions don’t affect anything that happens in America. What I’m very concerned about (and can do nothing about) is that if Trump is elected, that he will not give military aid to Ukraine, who are fighting this terrible war against Putin. I’m so afraid of Ukraine being defeated and destroyed by Russia. I’m also afraid of what Putin might do next.

My gut feeling is that Russia will be given the Ukraine territory that they want and that Ukraine will then join NATO. Then heaven help us all if Russia then decide they want to take more land. In that I think that Trumps new running mate is right. Ukraine will never defeat Russia sad. I’m terrified of the links between Trump, Putin, Bannon etc. And I’m sure Putin is pulling a lot of strings.

LizzieDrip Wed 17-Jul-24 14:49:15

Needless to say, the reaction to the shooting is "get more guns to protect yourself

Yes, frightening isn’t it Wyllow. Rather like, after terrible school shootings in America, the reaction was … ‘arm the teachers’!!!sad

MayBee70 Wed 17-Jul-24 14:48:11

What terrified me immediately after the shooting was the look on peoples faces and their aggressive hand gestures. It makes me think of something out of The Hunger Games.

Wyllow3 Wed 17-Jul-24 14:47:30

maddyone

We can voice our opinions of course, but our opinions don’t affect anything that happens in America. What I’m very concerned about (and can do nothing about) is that if Trump is elected, that he will not give military aid to Ukraine, who are fighting this terrible war against Putin. I’m so afraid of Ukraine being defeated and destroyed by Russia. I’m also afraid of what Putin might do next.

Yes. The new choice of Vance doesn't look good for Ukraine.

www.vance.senate.gov/press-releases/senator-vance-slams-u-s-foreign-policy-establishment-for-decades-of-failure/

It looks like their focus will be the Middle East insofar as any involvement outside an isolationist policy.

Wyllow3 Wed 17-Jul-24 14:35:41

Needless to say, the reaction to the shooting is "get more guns to protect yourself" (been googling to check reactions). ...and it suits their narrative to have the "lone shooter" responsible as opposed to a political plot or a society wide problem.

maddyone Wed 17-Jul-24 14:29:03

We can voice our opinions of course, but our opinions don’t affect anything that happens in America. What I’m very concerned about (and can do nothing about) is that if Trump is elected, that he will not give military aid to Ukraine, who are fighting this terrible war against Putin. I’m so afraid of Ukraine being defeated and destroyed by Russia. I’m also afraid of what Putin might do next.

westendgirl Wed 17-Jul-24 13:57:02

The possibility of that dreadful man becoming POTUS does not mean that we should have to get used to his abusive ways.
We can still voice our opposition, surely?

nanna8 Wed 17-Jul-24 13:44:15

We must get used to it I think- it looks like Trump will be the next President at this stage unless the Democrats do something pretty quick smart about their leader.

MayBee70 Wed 17-Jul-24 13:30:24

It’s beyond me how someone who has spoken about women the way that Trump has, spoken horribly about what happened to Nancy Pelosi’s husband etc etc seems to think that God is supporting/protecting him in some way. And that people are believing him. I’ve decided that, terrified as I am of another Trump presidency I can do nothing about it and I’m not going to let him ruin the latter years of my life. I really thought I’d seen the back of him. His running mate sounds even worse.

Wyllow3 Wed 17-Jul-24 11:14:02

There are religious people who believe their God can affect events in peoples individuals lives and those that believe that its humans that affects human lives as we were given (if you believe in a god) human choices to make.

From the beginning of time we have seen wars and dictatorships claiming "God's on my side" its hard to see Trump's claiming God has a special interest in him as anything but arrogant and abusive to others (God clearly not being "on their side, they then become lesser beings).

HousePlantQueen Wed 17-Jul-24 11:01:09

Farzanah

nanna8

I believe God did save him. We don’t know God’s plan , no one does. He’s got the overall picture, we haven’t.

Dear me.

well, if this is an indication of 'God's plan', I don't like it

Farzanah Wed 17-Jul-24 09:48:02

nanna8

I believe God did save him. We don’t know God’s plan , no one does. He’s got the overall picture, we haven’t.

Dear me.

maddyone Wed 17-Jul-24 09:44:47

Joseann

I think Trump worded that poorly.
I think the widow wouldn't talk to Biden because her husband was a Republican.
I think Melania is well off put of the picture, as was Victoria Starmer. I wish Mrs. Biden would do the same, as did Mrs. Sunak.

I agree.
I was reading about Melania recently. Apparently she cried when Trump won the Presidency. She’s brought up her son shielding him almost completely from the limelight. Unfortunately Trump seems to be pulling him in now he’s 18. Melania has the good sense to stay out of the limelight, unlike some other First Ladies and PM wives in this country. Mrs Sunak stayed out of the spotlight too.

Rowantree Wed 17-Jul-24 09:17:17

He's dangerous. As is his running mate.

Reminiscent of the failed attempt to kill Hitler.

Dickens Wed 17-Jul-24 09:00:40

NotSpaghetti

Do you believe in free will and individual moral responsibility nanna8 or do you maybe think we have no control over events?

To say that God saved Trump implies that the victims were also part of God's overall plan.

To say that God saved Trump implies that the victims were also part of God's overall plan.

To which of course the answer will be that we shouldn't question 'God's plan'. A rather convenient way to dismiss another's death.

It defies logic and reason. And I believe that is where the danger lies with Trump. For some, he is a cult-figure with a cult following.

When he said he could probably shoot someone on Fifth Avenue and people would still vote for him, he showed an extraordinary understanding of the phenomena. And he's probably right.

NotSpaghetti Wed 17-Jul-24 08:24:01

Do you believe in free will and individual moral responsibility nanna8 or do you maybe think we have no control over events?

To say that God saved Trump implies that the victims were also part of God's overall plan.

nanna8 Wed 17-Jul-24 01:23:26

I believe God did save him. We don’t know God’s plan , no one does. He’s got the overall picture, we haven’t.