Gransnet forums

News & politics

What Will You Do With 10 Million Frozen Pensioners, Rachel?

(315 Posts)
mae13 Mon 23-Sept-24 13:37:45

Well?

Cossy Mon 23-Sept-24 19:27:48

22/25% of pensioners can easily afford to pay all their bill, there will be further percentage in residential care, and a further percentage set to still receive it.

I cannot understand where the 10m figure came from?

M0nica Mon 23-Sept-24 19:24:24

MissAdventure

The cost of a school breakfast club in the UK can vary depending on the length of the club, the food it offers, and other factors:

Average cost: The average cost of a breakfast club session is between £8 and £15.50.

Surrey County Council: The average cost in Surrey is between £2.50 and £6.50 per session.

Bounds Green Primary School: The breakfast club costs £3.50 per day and runs from 8 AM–9 AM, with breakfast served until 8:30 AM.

Woodhall Primary School & Nursery: The breakfast club costs £3 per session and runs until 8:45 AM. Children entitled to Free School Meals do not pay for the breakfast club, but they must still book a place in advance.

Whitefriars School: The breakfast club costs £3 per session.

In which case why are breakfast clubs being provided. The children who need it most will come from families that cannot afford the cost of them.

growstuff Mon 23-Sept-24 18:54:20

Allira

growstuff

Allira

MayBee70

Well, if the money I’m not going to get as a WFP is going to allow the government to give free breakfasts to all primary school children it’s fine by me. But heaven forbid that some people on here can bring themselves to praise anything that Reeves is doing sad.

It shouldn't be a case of either/or

A country which cannot care for its elderly and its children is ethically bankrupt.

In your opinion.

So you don't think a country should care for its elderly and its young?

I am surprised.

I think it should care for all its citizens.

Allira Mon 23-Sept-24 18:40:04

Rekarie

Breakfast clubs most certainly aren't providing help for shiftless parents.

My daughter sends her 3, due to the fact she has to travel to work and the breakfast club is a godsend.

Certainly not shiftless

DGD went to breakfast club at primary school (she didn't like it) for that precise reason.
Leaving a child of primary school age to lock up the house after parents have left for work and get to school on their own is not really responsible.

Breakfast clubs are a godsend for working parents.

Allira Mon 23-Sept-24 18:36:02

growstuff

Allira

MayBee70

Well, if the money I’m not going to get as a WFP is going to allow the government to give free breakfasts to all primary school children it’s fine by me. But heaven forbid that some people on here can bring themselves to praise anything that Reeves is doing sad.

It shouldn't be a case of either/or

A country which cannot care for its elderly and its children is ethically bankrupt.

In your opinion.

So you don't think a country should care for its elderly and its young?

I am surprised.

MissAdventure Mon 23-Sept-24 18:31:26

Me too!!!

Rekarie Mon 23-Sept-24 18:30:30

Breakfast clubs most certainly aren't providing help for shiftless parents.

My daughter sends her 3, due to the fact she has to travel to work and the breakfast club is a godsend.

Certainly not shiftless

growstuff Mon 23-Sept-24 18:27:37

M0nica

MissAdventure

It's the timing of having to be present at work, mostly.

Jobs don't tend to hold their day up until you've given your children breakfast.

Having worked part time and full time, I just planned everything so that I was able to ensure my children had breakfast before they went to school. It isn't rocket science.

I am all for breakfast clubs. Children should not suffer because their parents are shiftless. yes, I know some children live in difficult circumstances - disabled parents or the children of addicts and similar, but they are a minority among those going to breakfast clubs.

We spend too much time making excuses for people who are shiftless, instead of ensuring they do thei parenting job properly.

So how did you cope with the hour or so from when you left for work and the start of school? My children both went to a breakfast club and I bitterly resent being labelled as shiftless.

growstuff Mon 23-Sept-24 18:25:08

MissAdventure

Yes, I'm all for the free breakfast clubs.

That doesn't mean I feel entitled to have a go at pensioners who will find it difficult to manage; although, of course, I could, by applying the same kind of judgements as are being put onto parents, who, as yet, are paying for a service which enables them to hold down jobs.

Some judgemental comments make me cringe. It really is no wonder that some struggling young families don't have much sympathy for the elderly.

growstuff Mon 23-Sept-24 18:23:14

Allira

MayBee70

Well, if the money I’m not going to get as a WFP is going to allow the government to give free breakfasts to all primary school children it’s fine by me. But heaven forbid that some people on here can bring themselves to praise anything that Reeves is doing sad.

It shouldn't be a case of either/or

A country which cannot care for its elderly and its children is ethically bankrupt.

In your opinion.

Oreo Mon 23-Sept-24 18:20:16

Yeah, she did look rather thrilled with herself.😠

Allira Mon 23-Sept-24 18:17:00

Well, Rachel is looking extremely pleased with herself at the Labour Party Conference.
Like the cat that got the cream.

(And before the comments - that is in the Guardian)

Allira Mon 23-Sept-24 18:11:50

MayBee70

Well, if the money I’m not going to get as a WFP is going to allow the government to give free breakfasts to all primary school children it’s fine by me. But heaven forbid that some people on here can bring themselves to praise anything that Reeves is doing sad.

It shouldn't be a case of either/or

A country which cannot care for its elderly and its children is ethically bankrupt.

MissAdventure Mon 23-Sept-24 18:10:38

I presume they have thought of that, seeing as they are the people in charge of it all. (Well, at least I'd like to think so)

Oreo Mon 23-Sept-24 18:10:20

MissAdventure

Yes, I'm all for the free breakfast clubs.

That doesn't mean I feel entitled to have a go at pensioners who will find it difficult to manage; although, of course, I could, by applying the same kind of judgements as are being put onto parents, who, as yet, are paying for a service which enables them to hold down jobs.

Having given this some thought🤔I think free breakfasts for all primary school children who want one is a good idea.
It takes away the stigma of having the state pay and even those from middleclass families may not always get a breakfast, we can’t know that they do or don’t.It’s not as if all children are suddenly going to turn up at school early wanting cereal/ toast in any case is it?This and WFA shouldn’t be mixed up, and that benefit should have stayed tho witheld from wealthy pensioners.

V3ra Mon 23-Sept-24 18:04:18

Yes, I'm all for the free breakfast clubs.

It sounds like a good idea. I'm just wondering if the government has given any thought to who will staff these clubs if lots of extra children want to go?
We have a breakfast club at our local schools. The schools promote them in their prospectus but the reality is they have no spare places at all for this academic year.

Cabbie21 Mon 23-Sept-24 18:02:10

Again, it may be worth seeing if they are entitled to Housing Benefit, via the Local Authority.

Allira Mon 23-Sept-24 17:58:02

Not every pensioner is an owner occupier, some are paying rent which can make a significant hole in a retirement income which may be above the limit for Pension Credit and eligibility for the WFA.

Some of the rents in this area, for even a modest property, would amount to about £15,000 pa apparently, and we are not in the South-East.

petra Mon 23-Sept-24 17:54:10

If this applies to anyone here or you know someone who needs help with energy bills your local council has a Household Support Fund for people in need.
It’s worth a call or can be done on line.

MissAdventure Mon 23-Sept-24 17:43:49

Yes, I'm all for the free breakfast clubs.

That doesn't mean I feel entitled to have a go at pensioners who will find it difficult to manage; although, of course, I could, by applying the same kind of judgements as are being put onto parents, who, as yet, are paying for a service which enables them to hold down jobs.

Cabbie21 Mon 23-Sept-24 17:42:06

As has been mentioned above, but worth repeating, local authorities have the Household Support Fund, with money direct from government. I would guess that for the next tranche they might prioritise claims from pensioners who don’t qualify for Pension Credit. It is certainly worth enquiring.

The LA is also responsible for Housing Benefit to help with rent, and Council Tax Reduction. Worth looking into.

Some energy companies are also going to help vulnerable customers, and people on the various disabilities should qualify for the Warm Home Discount, which enables energy suppliers to reduce their bills.

There IS help out there. I only hope those who need it will claim.

Rosie51 Mon 23-Sept-24 17:30:08

MissAdventure Reeves is going to trial free breakfast clubs in 750 primary schools before a national rollout. All children, no matter how rich their parents will be entitled to a free breakfast. I'm in favour of breakfast clubs but am having trouble reconciling pensioners just above pension credit level losing heating allowance with this sudden largesse available to children from well to do families.

maddyfour Mon 23-Sept-24 17:28:45

Wyllow3

I think quite a lot of groups will feel they've been treated unfairly in terms of need. Or unmet needs. an obvious group is long term disability.

I still question that 10 million pensioners will freeze to death as the result of changes to WFA.

If we are discussing pension levels overall and heating, that may be another matter

I think the figure being mooted is actually 4,000 pensioners may die as a result of the WFA being cut.
We will have to wait until next year to know how many, if any, excess pensioner deaths there maybe.

TerriBull Mon 23-Sept-24 17:25:10

I had a devil of a job with one of mine trying to get him to eat breakfast, it wasn't neglect, he's a bit like me though, I'm not an early morning eater. Sometimes, if he wouldn't eat anything, I sent him to school with a mid morning sandwich to have at break, Although, that wasn't unusual there were others like him who skipped breakfast. I knew they also came from homes where they could have had a choice of several cereals, eggs, toast whatever for breakfast. It was all too easy for them to go to this breakfast club where something akin to an Egg McMuffin was on offer and which they could roll up to without question

Having said that I'm all for Breakfast Clubs to be provided free for those that need that. .

maddyfour Mon 23-Sept-24 17:23:30

growstuff

Yes maddyfour I claim Teachers Pension plus state pension, but I also have to pay £850 a month rent. I am £13 a week over the threshold for Pension Credit.

I’m sorry to hear that. That is indeed a big nuisance. I guess it’s the rent causing the biggest problem. You are one of the people we are all concerned about and we’re so cross that people just above pension credit level will be suffering this winter.