How Tiresome, Silly Young Woman Protests At King Charles

And her facts were wrong!

She most certainly does not represent Aboriginal people. I’m talking about the real ones.

David49

“But why deny that part of her heritage?
Which her English father says she does?”

There no denying there has been appalling treatment in the past but they are free to take advantage of their heritage now if they wish. Or they can integrate with the rest of the population, the problem is that countless millions is spent on support, yet the problem gets progressively worse. Much of the money meant for education and healthcare is spent on drink and drugs, with much of the younger generation much worse off.

Alice Spring used to be a thriving tourist destination, now it’s on its knees with riot police being called in to keep order, it’s not surprising that the recent vote to increase representation was lost

Good to know the aboriginal community are now free to take advantage of their heritage or can integrate with the rest of the population.
How kind of the European settlers to allow this.
Sounds a little bit patronising to me.

I think David49 simply means that it’s the 21st Century now and the Aboriginal population can choose to celebrate their ancestry and still fit in with modern life in Australia, whereas in the past it was a different story.

Undoubtedly that's what David meant. But if that is patronising, what do you do expect the 'European Settlers' to do? Keep things as they were? Pack up and move out of Australia? Somehow put the clock back? or? what?

LauraNorderr

David49

“But why deny that part of her heritage?
Which her English father says she does?”

There no denying there has been appalling treatment in the past but they are free to take advantage of their heritage now if they wish. Or they can integrate with the rest of the population, the problem is that countless millions is spent on support, yet the problem gets progressively worse. Much of the money meant for education and healthcare is spent on drink and drugs, with much of the younger generation much worse off.

Alice Spring used to be a thriving tourist destination, now it’s on its knees with riot police being called in to keep order, it’s not surprising that the recent vote to increase representation was lost

Good to know the aboriginal community are now free to take advantage of their heritage or can integrate with the rest of the population.
How kind of the European settlers to allow this.
Sounds a little bit patronising to me.

Really, it's the truth.

nanna8

She most certainly does not represent Aboriginal people. I’m talking about the real ones.

She has insulted leading Aboriginal activists over the years, including one who has worked hard for indigenous rights, Noel Pearson. Whether you agree with his views or not, why would you use insulting terms to describe them?

Patronizing or not billions of dollars each year is being spent to help aboriginal communities but it seems to get worse, you may draw a parallel with inner city youth and the gang culture in the UK that feels disenfranchised and hopeless.

Sorry I have no solutions but I don’t think throwing money at the problem will help.

I would like to ask her about the poor dead possum\ possum's on her back!!!!
They have land &living rights too. 🤔

David, to answer your objections to actual social enrichment for former dispossessed aboriginanlpeoples I quote Wyllow:

"It is important to ask why many indigenous peoples especially living in mainly indigenous communities have high rates of alcohol and drug use. Googled a lot as well as my own suspicions
- basically the points made settle around the combination of having been stripped of an originally meaningful and purposeful way of life (land, a nomadic rural lifestyle, belief systems) and being treated for 100+ years as second class citizens meant that only some have adapted to a western white lifestyle."

meant that only some have adapted to a western white lifestyle.

Some still live in the traditional way on the lands of their ancestors.

School is compulsory for all children from the ages of 5 or 6 to 15 but I think it is right that the children must be given a chance of education as they may decide they don't want to continue living in the traditional ways of their ancestors.

Like Ms Thorpe and many others, they may want to pursue careers.

The "gifting back" of land so people can choose to live in traditional ways is far from simple.

They are getting, by and large, the areas not profitable for farming or indeed survival. Areas where the indigenous populations were smaller.

It is very difficult, I agree, and throwing money without purpose won't serve anyone well. There has to be real opportunity for real choices, which means education includes knowledge and experiences of the traditional ways as well as support to go and do it.

The Elders can teach the traditional ways; it's not really something that should be on the school curriculum except just enough so that all children learn respect for the ways of others.

After all, there are children from dozens of different backgrounds living in Australia.

Good for her.

I think it could be on the curriculum with pride and understanding - balancing the years school policy was designed to push out the cultures of thousands of years of indigenous life in Australia as backward. I say "could" as I dont know the current situation.

I actually think she was very brave to protest as she did (preferably without the gang of dead possums on her back though!) It takes a lot of guts to to what she did on the world stage. 🌎

SueEH

Good for her.

Yes, hear, hear for the brave, bold lady. 👏 💫👌

Not a good move psychologically as it will turn a lot of people against her and not do her cause any good.

He was a guest in her country, and whatever her views she shouldn’t have expressed them in such an uncouth manner.

Sadly for this lady, she has done her cause a lot of harm. The Monachists are delighted, according to my Australian cousins.

The king was greeted with a welcome by aboriginal elders

I think the King was very appreciative of all the good will he and the Queen encountered on this trip. The Australians of all colours and creeds were overwhelmingly in favour of him and gave him a wonderful welcome, as they have in Samoa. I think it's done him a lot of good, hopefully.

Ah but were they taken out to “welcome the king and queen” as happens even here when young school children are escorted onto the streets with union jacks to wave…..indoctrination from an early age .Thank goodness more people every year can see past this relic of the Middle Ages and realise they are nothing but parasites on a publicity tour to keep the cash flowing into their coffers! I have to laugh when there’s this reverence towards a woman who many hated with a. Vengeance when she was plain Camilla Parker Bowles ..titles mean nothing except to the deluded ,or those fed propaganda with their mothers milk

taken out to welcome the king and queen

Who were? All those Australians out on the streets greeting Charles and Camilla? If you've ever met any, you'll know they have minds of their own and that really makes it a very funny remark!
😂😂😂

taken out 😂

paddyann54

Ah but were they taken out to “welcome the king and queen” as happens even here when young school children are escorted onto the streets with union jacks to wave…..indoctrination from an early age .Thank goodness more people every year can see past this relic of the Middle Ages and realise they are nothing but parasites on a publicity tour to keep the cash flowing into their coffers! I have to laugh when there’s this reverence towards a woman who many hated with a. Vengeance when she was plain Camilla Parker Bowles ..titles mean nothing except to the deluded ,or those fed propaganda with their mothers milk

As I said in an earlier post, DD saw the Royals in Canberra. Couldn’t get near the front, but managed to see them. Crowds of people of different ages and cultures, but all thrilled to see them.

All Aussies aren’t keen on a republic, despite what you hear.