Gransnet forums

News & politics

Oh Mr Starmer … could things be any worse only 4 months in?

(304 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Wed 20-Nov-24 16:52:37

Domestically you’re nowhere to be seen. (I know, COP and saving the world jamboree). Your personal ratings have plummeted at -22. Your Chancellor is trying to defend the ‘change’ that Labour told us we needed - VAT on school fees, IHT changes, Net Zero, WFA stopped, inflation up from 1.7 to 2.4% - in your absence. To be honest I feel a bit sorry for RR. Firefighting for all she’s worth while her boss is halfway around the world. Now Starmer is telling us that he used to work on a farm….

Things just seem to be going from bad to worse for him. Buyer’s remorse anyone? Or is it jot early to tell 4 months in and he just needs more time?

GrannyGravy13 Thu 21-Nov-24 21:13:59

MissAdventure

There's no point in anything.
We're doomed!
Doomed I tell ya!!

MissA I can see you saying that 😘🤣

MissAdventure Thu 21-Nov-24 20:59:07

There's no point in anything.
We're doomed!
Doomed I tell ya!!

Allira Thu 21-Nov-24 20:56:47

MissAdventure

There's no point in a lot of the thread, with all the "if this happens" or "if that happens" really, is there?
As fgt says, we just have to brace ourselves.

She's right 👏👏👏👏👏

There's no point in a lot of threads!

MissAdventure Thu 21-Nov-24 20:50:09

There's no point in a lot of the thread, with all the "if this happens" or "if that happens" really, is there?
As fgt says, we just have to brace ourselves.

She's right 👏👏👏👏👏

RSALLAN2002 Thu 21-Nov-24 20:48:22

The problem is our voting system. After the Tory self-centred pantomime hanging on after losing all credibility and now Labour elected by a minority subjecting us to whatever policies they like, faith in our democracy is in danger.

Allira Thu 21-Nov-24 20:34:44

MissAdventure

Mouse

Where did you read that? In one of those papers owned by rich old men scared they might have to actually pay their fair share of tax?

👏👏👏👏👏

Mouse has still not informed us who she/he was addressing and what that is.

No point in applauding unless we know to what he/she refers.

MissAdventure Thu 21-Nov-24 20:22:04

🙄

MrsMatt Thu 21-Nov-24 19:50:45

They are all as bad and long winded as each other. Cameron spat his dummy when the Brexit vote went in the complete opposite of what he wanted. Liz? Less said the better. Buffoon Johnson was so full of hot air and promises I'm surprised he didn't burst. Sunak was a smarmy puppet who admitted to being poor as a child because he didn't have Sky TV 😳, poor little Sumy. What has Starmer and his chronies done apart from alienate virtually the whole country? Typical of an MP saying in April that no OAP should have to sit at home wearing their coat and gloves because they can't afford the heating. Then what do that load of plebs do. Oh yea, remove the benefit that would keep them warm. Sorry but they are all as ignorant as each other. None of them know what it's like to live without mummy and daddy's bank roll.

To those if those moaning and complaining about yet another political thread, why are you bothering reading it if it doesn't interest you?

Rant over

MayBee70 Thu 21-Nov-24 19:27:08

I assume you are an active member of your local group?

Oreo Thu 21-Nov-24 18:57:40

MayBee70

I think most Labour supporters have far more faith in the party than you have Oreo.

Have you done a nationwide poll? My Labour friends and colleagues range from disappointed to downright disgruntled.
There’s time to improve but they’ll really have to do much better.
My neighbourhood pages (it’s a poor area generally) say of the government ‘All the gear-no idea’.

Wyllow3 Thu 21-Nov-24 18:49:49

Cheerygirl

I don’t recall any negotiation - the doctor were just given the substantial pay rise they wanted

They weren't. They had been asking for much more.

Junior doctors in England wanted a 35% pay rise to make up for 15 years of below-inflation pay awards. They got a 22.3% pay rise over two years

MayBee70 Thu 21-Nov-24 18:48:49

I think most Labour supporters have far more faith in the party than you have Oreo.

Oreo Thu 21-Nov-24 18:44:11

We will see of course, only a few months in to this new government but many of us who voted for them (and those who didn’t ) can see flaws emerging. There’s certainly loads of rhetoric around and promises that just about everything will be fixed but little else.
No government in the last 30 years have been able to modify the NHS it’s like some huge jurassic beast lumbering along and nobody ever fixes social care. The two go hand in hand.
Tinkering with the deckchairs on the Titanic and incurring the wrath of the passengers doesn’t cut it.
I will wait and see what they do by a years time to have a real conversation about it.

LizzieDrip Thu 21-Nov-24 18:26:03

According to a poster on here, this government has ‘upset 90% of the electorate’. Not sure where that figure is from, but I know better than to ask for evidence to support spurious claims made on GN.

This government has 4+ years yet. If the electorate aren’t happy at the next election, they will show that in the ballot box. That’s democracy.

Of course, the electorate may well be happy in 4+ years. We’ll see!

MissAdventure Thu 21-Nov-24 18:20:17

Mouse

Where did you read that? In one of those papers owned by rich old men scared they might have to actually pay their fair share of tax?

👏👏👏👏👏

GrannyGravy13 Thu 21-Nov-24 17:58:47

I didn’t vote for this Government, but it doesn’t mean that I want/ed them to fail.

If this Labour Government fails to deliver on its pre election promises, the electorate will lose confidence as will investors, then the U.K. will fail.

Jeanathome Thu 21-Nov-24 17:54:17

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Reeves budget was a disaster because it damaged the private sector substantially, and picked out certain groups for particularly harsh punishment - ie farmers, small businesses, private schools and pensioners. It was an utterly pointless attack because the public sector will waste the money.

I doubt whether there is any way back for Labour. I suspect they are finished as a political force, but we will all have to brace ourselves for the next 4 years when Britain will undoubtedly become poorer, and Kier Starmer will preach to us incessantly from his pulpit. (He does like the sound of his own voice when he’s lecturing us - he just doesn’t like being questioned - one can sense his discomfort).

Although I didn’t vote Labour, I truly did hope for a fresh input of ideas and galvanising the electorate. This won’t happen now. I fear his image is irrevocably tarnished.

You don't fear though? You are enjoying it I think. It means a space may open up for the far right and Nigel et al.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 21-Nov-24 17:52:34

MayBee70

Cheerygirl

I don’t recall any negotiation - the doctor were just given the substantial pay rise they wanted

The previous government weren’t negotiating at all I believe.

The Conservatives did meet and try to negotiate with the junior doctors, as well as through a mediator

MayBee70 Thu 21-Nov-24 17:48:39

Cheerygirl

I don’t recall any negotiation - the doctor were just given the substantial pay rise they wanted

The previous government weren’t negotiating at all I believe.

silverlining48 Thu 21-Nov-24 17:44:04

You clearly didn’t vote Labour FGT.
No one could solve all the problems left by the previous government in such a short time. Have faith. smile

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 21-Nov-24 17:39:09

Reeves budget was a disaster because it damaged the private sector substantially, and picked out certain groups for particularly harsh punishment - ie farmers, small businesses, private schools and pensioners. It was an utterly pointless attack because the public sector will waste the money.

I doubt whether there is any way back for Labour. I suspect they are finished as a political force, but we will all have to brace ourselves for the next 4 years when Britain will undoubtedly become poorer, and Kier Starmer will preach to us incessantly from his pulpit. (He does like the sound of his own voice when he’s lecturing us - he just doesn’t like being questioned - one can sense his discomfort).

Although I didn’t vote Labour, I truly did hope for a fresh input of ideas and galvanising the electorate. This won’t happen now. I fear his image is irrevocably tarnished.

sazz1 Thu 21-Nov-24 17:35:32

Worst PM in living history. Broke all election promises, has upset 90% of people including farmers, elderly, students, people who use electricity gas petrol, EV owners, private school kids etc etc the list goes on. Biggest liar ever - at least Boris didn't tax everyone while promising to reduce prices.

Cheerygirl Thu 21-Nov-24 17:31:39

I don’t recall any negotiation - the doctor were just given the substantial pay rise they wanted

Realky Thu 21-Nov-24 17:18:34

Actually, I think £2 million exemption from IHT for every farming couple is more than enough.

escaped Thu 21-Nov-24 16:55:07

1) N/A I voted Lib Dem.
2) Looks like a downward spiral to me so far
3) OK, but don't drag those heels