Gransnet forums

News & politics

Who are we fighting?

(114 Posts)
LR10 Wed 01-Jan-25 14:45:02

I am really fed up with, and to tell the truth feeling a little insulted, by politicians of all and no particular party feeding us rubbish. Talking to us as if we're unable to understand the complexities of a situation. For example Keir Starmer's New Year pronouncements - he is going to "fight for Britain". Fight who? No meaningless sound bites please, just talk plain common sense man, you might be worth listening to then.

Wyllow3 Wed 01-Jan-25 14:55:18

I just take it as a phase they use meaning "concentrating energy/resources on issue X or Y" Has been for years I guess.

Plain common sense?". ...well......

In politics, it often appears to mean the POV of the politician makes "common sense" to themselves and their supporters, and they can all go round claiming "common sense"?

Indigo8 Wed 01-Jan-25 15:06:16

Do you remember the staggeringly meaningless rubbish trotted out during the Covid 19 lockdowns?

For example "Stay home, protect the NHS, save lives."

Protecting the NHS seemed to involve banging saucepans outside your front door every Thursday evening .confused

M0nica Wed 01-Jan-25 16:36:10

These days anything any politician anywhere says something, is all smoke and mirrors and is totally meaningless.

Their every casual remark has been pored over by political aides in the press office for months, to make sure it promises nothing, commits them to nothing and is total anodyne.

Smileless2012 Wed 01-Jan-25 16:39:16

A good explanation of why they say what they do M0nica smile.

AGAA4 Wed 01-Jan-25 17:04:45

At least Starmer hasn't said he will make Britain great again. Not yet anyway.

Smileless2012 Wed 01-Jan-25 17:06:27

Not yet anyway there's still time AGAA4

Notagranyet24 Wed 01-Jan-25 17:22:52

M0nica

These days anything any politician anywhere says something, is all smoke and mirrors and is totally meaningless.

Their every casual remark has been pored over by political aides in the press office for months, to make sure it promises nothing, commits them to nothing and is total anodyne.

You're so right M0nica but they must feel they have to do it, are probably told to by the PR people.
I think British politics has become such a sad, conflict-bound arena, no one listens to anyone else anymore, debate has vanished, it's all about scoring cheap points.

TerriBull Wed 01-Jan-25 17:25:04

Yes! I think you've nailed it Monica

Allira Wed 01-Jan-25 17:54:58

AGAA4

At least Starmer hasn't said he will make Britain great again. Not yet anyway.

😁

So far it seems to be pensioners, farmers and parents of private school pupils.
Oh, and a black hole.

Who next, I wonder?

Allira Wed 01-Jan-25 17:57:15

They're all just meaningless soundbites.

I thought better of Starmer than to fall into that trap.

TerriBull Wed 01-Jan-25 18:03:18

Whoever the invisible forces are he intends to fight on behalf of the nation, I hope he's considered the fact that our armed forces are very depleted.

valdali Wed 01-Jan-25 18:06:51

Most patronising message ever has to be "New Labour New Danger" with a doctored photo of Tony Blair with demonic red eyes.
While ago now.

Allira Wed 01-Jan-25 18:09:42

Oh!!
Is that Starmer on Gladiators?

Allira Wed 01-Jan-25 18:11:28

valdali

Most patronising message ever has to be "New Labour New Danger" with a doctored photo of Tony Blair with demonic red eyes.
While ago now.

Do you remember that huge poster with a long line of people depicted on it:
"Labour Isn't Working"

It must have been many years ago because DS was in a push chair!

Oreo Wed 01-Jan-25 22:15:18

we shall fight them on the beaches!..

First there gets the best deckchairs.

Oreo Wed 01-Jan-25 22:16:22

Boris was a one for meaningless phrases but Keir isn’t far behind so far.🤬

Nonnato2 Wed 01-Jan-25 22:25:30

AGAA4

At least Starmer hasn't said he will make Britain great again. Not yet anyway.

That’s because he won’t and can’t.

Oreo Wed 01-Jan-25 22:27:21

We should all wear Make Britain Great Again hats 🧢😁

Oreo Wed 01-Jan-25 22:28:18

Has Starmer promised to build up Hadrian’s Wall yet?

Allira Wed 01-Jan-25 22:32:22

AGAA4

At least Starmer hasn't said he will make Britain great again. Not yet anyway.

Well, he did say that but using slightly different phraseology

"The prime minister, meanwhile, said in his message that his government would “fight” to rebuild Britain and rediscover “the great nation that we are”."

He's going to find it rather than make it.
Seek and ye shall find 🤞

ronib Wed 01-Jan-25 22:41:28

I think we listened to so much nonsense from past prime ministers that now our first instinct is to either not listen or just laugh. This applies to Kemi Badenoch and Nigel Farage too. I wonder when Starmer will realise that his speeches need to sound as if he at least believes in them?

Mollygo Thu 02-Jan-25 06:23:13

Notagranyet24

M0nica
“These days anything any politician anywhere says something, is all smoke and mirrors and is totally meaningless.”

“Their every casual remark has been pored over by political aides in the press office for months, to make sure it promises nothing, commits them to nothing and is total anodyne.”

You're so right M0nica but they must feel they have to do it, are probably told to by the PR people.
I think British politics has become such a sad, conflict-bound arena, no one listens to anyone else anymore, debate has vanished, it's all about scoring cheap points.

Mollygo Thu 02-Jan-25 06:24:44

Sounds about right M0nica and
Notagranyet24

David49 Thu 02-Jan-25 07:22:29

If polititians told the truth they would never get elected, the changes that need to be made in the UK are very unpalatable, revealing them before an election could be fatal. After the GE we had the begining of changes planned with WFA etc, there will be much more to come.