Gransnet forums

News & politics

The Guardian reports that Trump says all Palestinians should move out of Gaza

(1001 Posts)
Claremont Sun 26-Jan-25 18:31:18

as he agrees to deliver a massive number of bombs for the IDF- so they can clear the country.

Are they planning the Ben Gurrion Canal yet- was it was this is all about, as some suspected a long time ago.

Call me cynical andpessimistic. Where on earth are they supposed to go?

JaneJudge Fri 21-Feb-25 11:50:14

wtf is wrong with him

Oreo Fri 21-Feb-25 11:54:56

Who?

Claremont Fri 21-Feb-25 12:05:48

Them.

Allira Fri 21-Feb-25 13:45:10

Nobody, but NOBODY, sill defend this

But

There is no But.

pascal30 Fri 21-Feb-25 14:17:47

Galaxy

Western liberal values are what I believe in. Presumably if we stand with Europe against Russia that will be what we are defending. If you continually tell people how terrible these values are dont be at all surprised when they refuse to join you to fight for them.

I agree with you Galaxy.. We should defend Democracy and Free Speech.. I'm so grateful to live in the UK

Claremont Fri 21-Feb-25 15:12:39

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Anniebach Fri 21-Feb-25 15:20:47

Claims ‘Israeli Jew’ ! No thanks, I pass

GrannyGravy13 Fri 21-Feb-25 15:25:02

Claremont you seem to have omitted that it is Hamas who substituted ^an unidentified body of a Gaza women*

It is Hamas who are playing games, and hiding amongst its civilians instead of protecting them.

Anniebach Fri 21-Feb-25 15:37:51

Sickening, I didn’t read the ‘Israeli Jew’ story , came on now and saw the last paragraph, a Jew calls the alleged dead mother
of her two murdered babies. the miserable Shiri Bibas ,

I do not believe this ,

Boz Fri 21-Feb-25 15:50:29

This is obviously a fake news story.

Anniebach Fri 21-Feb-25 15:57:10

Yes, there has been several the same

GrannyGravy13 Fri 21-Feb-25 15:57:40

Boz

This is obviously a fake news story.

Unfortunately Shiri Bibas body was not the one returned.

Hamas returned an unidentified female’s body in her place.

Not a fake story at all

Boz Fri 21-Feb-25 16:02:34

GrannyGravy13

Boz

This is obviously a fake news story.

Unfortunately Shiri Bibas body was not the one returned.

Hamas returned an unidentified female’s body in her place.

Not a fake story at all

You are quite right. The febrile nature of this article threw me.
Hamas probably did make a mistake which will, we hope, be rectified.

Anniebach Fri 21-Feb-25 17:07:38

Perhaps they knew they were returning the wrong body, they released a hostage, knew the wife and two daughters were dead. They burned them alive in their own home, they let him speak on a stage saying how he was so looking forward to seeing them ,

Oreo Fri 21-Feb-25 21:12:47

Who knows if it was a mistake by hamas or deliberate but the result is the same, shockingly for the family who hoped for a loving burial service for mother and toddler and baby.It would have given them some sort of comfort.

Anniebach Fri 21-Feb-25 21:53:02

No one knows, Hamas are capable of such brutality

Aveline Sun 23-Feb-25 14:01:28

It goes both ways. Israeli killing of Palestinians grossly outnumbers the Israelis killed.

Elegran Sun 23-Feb-25 21:16:50

Multiples more than an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.

Anniebach Sun 23-Feb-25 22:00:04

Sorry why eye for an eye etc ?

Aveline Mon 24-Feb-25 07:06:46

Think about it

Elegran Mon 24-Feb-25 09:22:30

Read this, Annie, or anyone else who thinks that Israel has the right to kill as punishment many times as many Palestinians as were directly involved in the savage attack in October.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eye_for_an_eye

Anniebach Mon 24-Feb-25 10:14:01

Thank you Elegran. I cannot think of one religious law which has caused more calls for definition, in Christian faith
‘Thou Shall Not Kill’ , exceptions capital punishment, assisted
dying., self defence.
Reading you link same applies to other faiths, so Israel and Palestine at war as oppose to seeking revenge ?

Elegran Mon 24-Feb-25 13:22:32

If they were at war with another country, they should be adhering to the standards of international warfare. They are not doing so.

If they are destroying land and killing people who are not in a separate country, but part of their own, they are doing it to punish the whole area and the community living in it for the crimes of a part. I think that would be classed as "cruel and unnatural punishment"

Anniebach Mon 24-Feb-25 13:39:30

Can any country be at war with terrorists ?

Aveline Mon 24-Feb-25 21:03:33

The Israelis are behaving like terrorists - indeed, worse than terrorists.

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion