Gransnet forums

News & politics

Rachel Gives A Thumbs Up To The Third Runway

(180 Posts)
mae13 Wed 29-Jan-25 12:11:32

How much will it cost, when will it be completed and can we expect it to solve the Social Care crisis, eliminate Fiscal Drag by increasing the personal tax allowance, fix a badly fractured NHS, deal with escalating knife crime,etc, etc.

Well, Rachel from Accounts? Is this your idea of a Magic Bullet? And will it save your career when Keir decides it's time for a Cabinet re-shuffle?

Casdon Thu 30-Jan-25 10:18:53

Reservoirs haven’t been dug before because there wasn’t government intervention to make it happen ronib. It really is that simple.

ronib Thu 30-Jan-25 10:20:08

No Casdon it is not that simple promise.

Casdon Thu 30-Jan-25 10:23:50

It is ronib. Water companies are businesses which are averse to investment because it affects shareholder profits. There hasn’t been enough future planning, governmental leadership or oversight, which is why the water industry is in the state it is now. I’m not Tory bashing when I say that, it applies to all governments.

Allira Thu 30-Jan-25 10:25:46

The infrastructure just has not kept up with a growing population and an increased number of houses.

Labour may claim that not enough housing has been built for years and are promising more on greenfield or even sites of Special Scientific Interest, but wherever I have been in recent years, there has been a massive amount of house building going on around towns and villages but without the infrastructure needed to cope with it all.

Wyllow3 Thu 30-Jan-25 10:31:41

Calendargirl

Don’t know how much Robin Hood Airport contributed to the economy, but it was very useful for anyone who lived in that area and wanted to travel.

Its closure was a shame.

Great if it opens again for that part of the country.

This airport serves a large area not otherwise covered. Useful for business people, freight and tourists it's good for the region. But it will have to work harder to make it pay.

Casdon Thu 30-Jan-25 10:34:41

Allira

The infrastructure just has not kept up with a growing population and an increased number of houses.

Labour may claim that not enough housing has been built for years and are promising more on greenfield or even sites of Special Scientific Interest, but wherever I have been in recent years, there has been a massive amount of house building going on around towns and villages but without the infrastructure needed to cope with it all.

That’s part of it Allora, there’s also a massive long term lack of maintenance and pipework replacement issue, and changes to the climate which affect the east of the UK particularly.

pascal30 Thu 30-Jan-25 10:41:03

She doesn't give a fig about the environment.. oh well let's just chase the money and damn our children.. exactly like Liz Truss

Allira Thu 30-Jan-25 10:44:17

Casdon

Allira

The infrastructure just has not kept up with a growing population and an increased number of houses.

Labour may claim that not enough housing has been built for years and are promising more on greenfield or even sites of Special Scientific Interest, but wherever I have been in recent years, there has been a massive amount of house building going on around towns and villages but without the infrastructure needed to cope with it all.

That’s part of it Allora, there’s also a massive long term lack of maintenance and pipework replacement issue, and changes to the climate which affect the east of the UK particularly.

I can remember DH saying over 30 years ago that there was no planned maintenance happening in this country any more.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 30-Jan-25 10:45:43

They are encouraging (expecting) the general population to buy electric vehicles, swop our boilers for heat pumps (air or ground source).

They are putting extra taxes on flights to deter us from flying, and hey ho they are going to expand and/or reopen airports.

This government is sending mixed messages…

David49 Thu 30-Jan-25 10:57:19

ronib

Remember the population is due to rise significantly and some of us have not understood why reservoirs have not been dug before now. Oh yes, we were all meant to save water and reservoirs were not needed. Now they are. Fascinating.

Our water South Midlands comes directly out of the Severn where there is ample flow year round what is needed is proper water grid to use that water to supply the South East, along with stopping leaks of course.

Mamie Thu 30-Jan-25 10:58:13

GrannyGravy13

Mamie freight goes hand in hand with passengers, apart from the likes of DHL etc who have freight only flights.

DHL and the like are not just an add on. Freight is much bigger than that.
In any case if it takes as long to build as people on here think, it will be electric planes on the tarmac.

MaizieD Thu 30-Jan-25 11:01:36

Heathrow is the one project that is contentious there are many others that are planned, Wind Power, Nuclear, Battery and Tech incentives the jobs that come from them aren’t trickledown.

David, you are absolutely correct, of course they're not 'trickle down'. Forgive me for getting a bit carried away. blush

My main contention is, of course, that promising jam tomorrow is both economically and politically illiterate.

MaizieD Thu 30-Jan-25 11:04:13

Mamie

GrannyGravy13

Mamie freight goes hand in hand with passengers, apart from the likes of DHL etc who have freight only flights.

DHL and the like are not just an add on. Freight is much bigger than that.
In any case if it takes as long to build as people on here think, it will be electric planes on the tarmac.

And in the meantime it's doing nothing for the 14 million plus people currently living in poverty...

Casdon Thu 30-Jan-25 11:07:49

David49

ronib

Remember the population is due to rise significantly and some of us have not understood why reservoirs have not been dug before now. Oh yes, we were all meant to save water and reservoirs were not needed. Now they are. Fascinating.

Our water South Midlands comes directly out of the Severn where there is ample flow year round what is needed is proper water grid to use that water to supply the South East, along with stopping leaks of course.

If you were right David, your water supply would already be serving Birmingham instead of Wales doing so. I know, we could just get rid of Wales and make it one big reservoir.

Barleyfields Thu 30-Jan-25 11:09:40

Totally agree Maizie. It’s all ‘jam tomorrow’. Reeves claimed in her speech yesterday that she had ‘fixed the foundations’ in her Budget. She is completely deluded and, as you said upthread, doing things completely the wrong way round.

Mamie Thu 30-Jan-25 11:15:47

MaizieD

Mamie

GrannyGravy13

Mamie freight goes hand in hand with passengers, apart from the likes of DHL etc who have freight only flights.

DHL and the like are not just an add on. Freight is much bigger than that.
In any case if it takes as long to build as people on here think, it will be electric planes on the tarmac.

And in the meantime it's doing nothing for the 14 million plus people currently living in poverty...

Well no, but as I said upthread I know from people currently involved in major construction projects that some are ready to go as soon as funding is released. Surely good governance involves long term projects to create jobs and boost the economy as well as thise in the medium and short term.

MaizieD Thu 30-Jan-25 11:20:08

I'm fine with a long term strategy, I think we've suffered from short termism in the past, but, I repeat, ignoring what is needed to be done right now is unsound on both the economic and political fronts,

Barleyfields Thu 30-Jan-25 11:20:17

I assume you are talking about construction projects which the government are financing Mamie?

Mamie Thu 30-Jan-25 11:52:38

Barleyfields

I assume you are talking about construction projects which the government are financing Mamie?

Some are, some a mixture, some private finance.

Mamie Thu 30-Jan-25 11:56:09

Mamie

Barleyfields

I assume you are talking about construction projects which the government are financing Mamie?

Some are, some a mixture, some private finance.

Yes, some which have been waiting for the release of the public spending to start.

pipsaucer Thu 30-Jan-25 12:00:57

We need hospitals, clinics and dentists, not making more people homeless therefore moving to hosing stock , I wonder who has their fingers in whose pies?

GrannyGravy13 Thu 30-Jan-25 12:01:21

Mamie the proverbial elephant in the room is of course that the UK is sadly lacking skilled workers.

If all these projects go ahead I assume the companies involved will have to advertise jobs abroad to fill the vacancies.

(A large proportion of our business is construction related, and it is a huge problem, electricians, engineers, brick layers, plumbers etc., all in short supply. The youngsters are not interested in the construction industry)

Calendargirl Thu 30-Jan-25 12:13:29

Robin Hood Airport needed more airlines to use it.

Flybe was one, but think they went bust.

But if more destinations were offered, and more airlines used it, people in that area wouldn’t have to travel to Heathrow or Manchester.

Heathrow would then be less busy.

Calendargirl Thu 30-Jan-25 12:19:14

The youngsters are not interested in the construction industry

It’s about time more emphasis was placed on that type of work.

My GS is an apprentice electrician, he attended the local grammar school and attained A levels, but wasn’t keen on going to university.

Hardly any of his peers went down the job/ apprentice route.

I do wonder what some of them will end up doing after their three years at uni.

Perhaps some of the teachers at GS’s old school will wonder who made the best choice when in a few years time, they need an electrician, and GS turns up at the door.

Casdon Thu 30-Jan-25 12:22:00

I might be completely wrong, but I’d guess that the massive further expansion at East Midlands parkway, which is at the airport/M1/M42 junction announced yesterday has something to do with the reopening of Doncaster. They aren’t far apart, and it would be quite feasible to use Doncaster for more freight, as both airports have only one runway.