Gransnet forums

News & politics

Let’s hear it for Sir Keir Starmer

(248 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Mon 03-Mar-25 16:24:56

Who has scored a blinder during the last week.

The whole house (apart from Farage I think although he didn’t make a lot of sense) has praised his efforts.

People like Starmer known for what people say is a boring personality etc, come into their own in times of crises. He is a man without ego, a man of integrity and honesty. A man of intelligence and dependability.

M0nica Mon 03-Mar-25 21:30:20

Proving to be very good at one aspect of a job, while meritous, can not be used to justify just how badly he is doing in other aspects of it.

The problem with both Trump and Vance is that neither of them could be honest and truthful, even if their lives depended on them being so. Trump is simply self-deluded to a level only otherwise found in insane monarchs like Ludwig of Bavaria while Vance is up their with the little tinpot dictator in North Korea or Nicolas Maduro in Venezuela.

Actually anintersting point, both those named above have driven the inhabitants of their country to flee their home country if they can (North Koreans find it very difficult). Do you think that a couple of years of Trump/Vance will lead to a large scale fleeing of US citizens to Mexico and Canada, to get out of the total basketcase the US will have become?

nanna8 Mon 03-Mar-25 21:57:13

Strange times. Starmer, for the first time , is commanding respect and thank goodness for that. I hope it continues. I also hope he continues to stay reasonably friendly with the US otherwise I hate to think of the future. So far so good.

MayBee70 Mon 03-Mar-25 22:06:52

Only ‘for the first time’ with people that have never seen him for what he is. Maybe those people now see why many of us have supported him for years.

Doodledog Mon 03-Mar-25 22:10:44

I was thinking the same, Maybee 😎

Primrose53 Mon 03-Mar-25 22:23:04

eazybee

Let us wait and see what the outcome is and what concessions there are or have to be made.

Quite.

It’s very easy to give away 1.6 billion to Ukraine. Where did that come from? What are other countries giving? It’s always down to us.

Rula Mon 03-Mar-25 22:36:41

Quite easy to find, Primrose53

The new £2.26 billion is the UK’s contribution to the G7 Extraordinary Revenue Acceleration (ERA) Loans to Ukraine scheme, in which $50 billion from G7 countries will be delivered to Ukraine for its military, budget and reconstruction needs. The loan will be repaid using the extraordinary profits on immobilised Russian sovereign assets

Lots of info and explanation online to be found

LizzieDrip Mon 03-Mar-25 22:51:37

MayBee70

Only ‘for the first time’ with people that have never seen him for what he is. Maybe those people now see why many of us have supported him for years.

Absolutely MayBee.

I’m so pleased and proud we have a PM with integrity, calmness and intelligence.

Of course, many of us have always seen this in him, so it comes as no surprise that he is handling this very difficult situation with great aplomb.

MaizieD Mon 03-Mar-25 23:30:34

Proving to be very good at one aspect of a job, while meritous, can not be used to justify just how badly he is doing in other aspects of it

I have to say that I agree with MOnica here. Perhaps he would have been a better Foreign Secretary than PM. But I can’t deny that he’s doing well with this tricky situation.

Dickens Tue 04-Mar-25 07:19:11

MaizieD

^Proving to be very good at one aspect of a job, while meritous, can not be used to justify just how badly he is doing in other aspects of it^

I have to say that I agree with MOnica here. Perhaps he would have been a better Foreign Secretary than PM. But I can’t deny that he’s doing well with this tricky situation.

I agree with you - both of you.

... and, nanna8

Strange times. Starmer, for the first time , is commanding respect and thank goodness for that. I hope it continues. I also hope he continues to stay reasonably friendly with the US otherwise I hate to think of the future. So far so good

I think he will attempt a cordial relationship with the US; he isn't a hot-head given to mercurial outbursts, seems pragmatic - understands what's at stake, and has a certain amount of integrity. I'm sure he realises that diplomacy when dealing with Trump is essential and will not deliberately antagonise the man. Trump clearly does not like to be challenged though and is well aware that he is centre-stage, all powerful, and will not take kindly to his plans being up ended - and certainly will not relish the thought of a united Europe opposing him, so will throw a spanner or two into the works before long. It's not going to be easy for Starmer that's for sure.

Elegran Tue 04-Mar-25 08:00:40

In different circumstances, Maizie, he might have become Foreign Secretary and progressed to PM later, but what was needed was a Prime Minister with gravitas to follow Boris Johnson. I'd say we were lucky he was there to take over - and I thought so at the time.

Lovetopaint037 Tue 04-Mar-25 08:06:47

Have never found Starmer boring. Was relieved that at last we had a serious PM intent on the job and not intent on playing to the crowd. Rishi Sunak was doing his best and was serious but lacked experience in handling his Party. No way could he have bettered Sir Keir. Think back to the quiet, unassuming Attlee. Not exciting (fed up with exciting).

karmalady Tue 04-Mar-25 08:14:00

Starmer is serious on the world stage but is a joke when it comes to dealing with the UK. UK is crumbling

Churchview Tue 04-Mar-25 08:19:19

Labour are doing good things in the UK too.
eastangliabylines.co.uk/politics/the-first-6-months-what-has-labour-actually-done/

Iam64 Tue 04-Mar-25 08:20:30

Starmer is a serious politician, that’s something that irritates some. He isn’t a joke though not everyone approves of his road of travel for the country. I still believe he’s the best PM we’ve had in years

Elegran Tue 04-Mar-25 08:26:05

Give him time, Karmalady. While you can destroy a country in a few brief weeks of bombing or of dismantling its governing infrastructure, it takes longer to achieve the reverse process. Rome wasn't built in a day.

keepingquiet Tue 04-Mar-25 08:28:18

Heartening to read these posts after months of slagging the man off.
He is the same person- he just deals with things like an adult who takes his responsibilities seriously.
For the first time in years I feel we can now stop talking about Brexit and support the UK together with Europe again!
I hope we can do this together!

Caleo Tue 04-Mar-25 08:32:39

One has to like Starmer's improved image! It shows that lack of charisma does not indicate lack of ability.

Aveline Tue 04-Mar-25 08:58:50

We were just wondering how Boris would have handled Trump!!

Doodledog Tue 04-Mar-25 09:22:05

Caleo

One has to like Starmer's improved image! It shows that lack of charisma does not indicate lack of ability.

I think this is crucial. Far too many people have been taken in by populist politicians who rely on charisma over competence, to the point where not being a performer was seen as weakness.

Since the election we have heard countless comments about KS’s ’rabbit in the headlights’ expression, his measured delivery being boring etc - none of which engaged with the substance of what we has done.

Now all but the die-hard loathers are seeing him for what he is - a competent and statesmanlike leader who has moved the UK from being a post-Brexit pariah/laughing stock to a respected country again.

Casdon Tue 04-Mar-25 09:29:02

Aveline

We were just wondering how Boris would have handled Trump!!

I think that’s an interesting question. I suspect Sunak would have done similar to Starmer, as would Cameron. Johnson’s relationship with Europe would have made that impossible, but he was passionate about supporting Ukraine, which would leave us with no allies if he went against Trump to do that. What is interesting me more than that at the moment is Farage’s response, which seems to be alienating him from the public view.

GrannyGravy13 Tue 04-Mar-25 09:29:56

Whilst I disagree that the U.K. has ever been a

post Brexit pariah/laughing stock

I am pleased with KS and his handling of the current situation, so far.

For the record, I have never been a die hard loather I did and to some extent still do have issues with the hypocrisy which surrounded the Labour government when they came to power after the continued berating of Conservatives for doing similar things.

Being in government as opposed to opposition is not easy, I hope that they have now found their feet.

Hopefully RR will see the error of some of her disastrous policies, I do not expect a total U turn, but some tweaking wouldn’t go amiss.

mum2three Tue 04-Mar-25 09:32:37

On the contrary, I think he is taking advantage of the situation to make himself seem a better person than he actually is.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 04-Mar-25 09:35:20

Some posts give me a lot of merriment😄😄😄

Doodledog Tue 04-Mar-25 09:36:16

mum2three

On the contrary, I think he is taking advantage of the situation to make himself seem a better person than he actually is.

An interesting perspective. Can you tell us more about your reasoning here?

LizzieDrip Tue 04-Mar-25 09:41:42

mum2three

On the contrary, I think he is taking advantage of the situation to make himself seem a better person than he actually is.

Oh dear🤣🤣🤣