Gransnet forums

News & politics

Trump USAID cuts hit Afghan Women

(35 Posts)
Wyllow3 Sat 08-Mar-25 10:32:55

A while ago we had a thread on the Afghan girls who had escaped to continue their education in Oman with their inspirational leader.

Now

More than 80 Afghan women who fled the Taliban to pursue higher education in Oman now face imminent deportation back to Afghanistan, following the Trump administration's sweeping freeze on foreign aid programmes

"Funded by the US Agency for International Development (USAID), their scholarships were abruptly terminated after a funding freeze ordered by President Donald Trump when he returned to office in January

"It was heart-breaking," one student told the BBC, speaking anonymously for fear of reprisals. "Everyone was shocked and crying. We've been told we will be sent back within two weeks"

Its not just them: US aid funding had enabled thousands of Afghan women to study abroad or continue education online, but many of these programmes are now suspended.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cg4k25wlw21o

Yet another example of utter thoughtlessness - not examining what USAID was spent on, being selective.

The BBC has seen emails sent to the 82 students informing them that their scholarships have been "discontinued" due to the termination of the programme and USAID funding

Wyllow3 Mon 24-Mar-25 10:57:23

I think its maybe possible this very particular high profile group may be able to find help elsewhere

however

USAID cuts are going hit many humanitarian projects some which offer humanitarian aid for the desperate, or projects which help countries by giving people skills to help themselves (broadly speaking) or valuable world projects like infectious disease containment research.

There's a sad, regrettable, backward trend in the US cuts which turns away from us being "citizens of the world" - when they are the richest country towards isolation, not caring, and short sightedness.

mum2three Mon 24-Mar-25 06:42:16

Surely there are charities which assist women like these....or sponsorship. I don't see why the education of foreign women should be paid for by Western countries. If people feel strongly about it, they should give to the appropriate charities.
Actionaid helps to educate children in poorer countries through sponsorship. We get enough ads on the tv highlighting these causes, so there's no excuse for not helping if you wish to.

Truffle43 Sun 09-Mar-25 05:40:19

My heart goes out to these woman. They are desperate to do what most women take for granted. I do hope someone steps in and helps them. Life for Afghan woman must be torture every day. It’s like them going back to the the dark ages before education was the norm.

imaround Sun 09-Mar-25 01:11:33

Does Trump know how they live? Probably

The problem is he doesn't care. He is incacapable of caring about anyone other than himself and money.

Esmay Sat 08-Mar-25 20:44:23

I have many Adghani friends .
Has Trump any idea what it's like to be an Afghani woman today ?
I doubt it .
And judging by the sad look of resignation on Melania's face -he isn't exactly a joy to live with .

Syracute Sat 08-Mar-25 20:25:50

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5y071kxwn8o.amp

imaround Sat 08-Mar-25 20:19:54

I agree. There is plenty enough blame to go around, even all the way back to GW Bush.

Norah Sat 08-Mar-25 19:36:26

imaround

It is a bad mark for borh of them Norah. Trump for going rogue in negotiating terms and for removing the bulk of the personnel so quickly and Biden for not listening to his Generals at the time.

Agreed.

Perhaps I poorly stated my thought. I never meant to blame Preisdent Biden, horrible things happen in war situations. I assume the whole Afghanistan debacle stretches back to GWBush.

imaround Sat 08-Mar-25 19:29:07

It is a bad mark for borh of them Norah. Trump for going rogue in negotiating terms and for removing the bulk of the personnel so quickly and Biden for not listening to his Generals at the time.

glasshalffullagain Sat 08-Mar-25 19:21:08

Awful, profoundly depressing. How anybody can call him inspiring is beyond me.

Norah Sat 08-Mar-25 19:16:25

MayBee70

imaround

Trump arranged that withdrawl. He went around Afghans government and negotiated with the Taliban.

Yes the withdrawal was horrible, but Trump had a large hand in it and is not resolved from responsibility just because it happened on Bidens watch.

This is, of course, horrible for these girls. But I can't imagine anyone is surprised? He is a racist misogynistic with a special affinity for hurting Muslims.

What he is doing harm women in the US and around the world is unforgivable.

Thank you. I thought that was the case.

Of course he arranged it, he just failed to finish before his term ended. President Biden quickly (perhaps too quickly) withdrew forces, ISIS Abbey Gate attack, disaster- bad mark for President Biden.

MayBee70 Sat 08-Mar-25 19:09:30

imaround

Trump arranged that withdrawl. He went around Afghans government and negotiated with the Taliban.

Yes the withdrawal was horrible, but Trump had a large hand in it and is not resolved from responsibility just because it happened on Bidens watch.

This is, of course, horrible for these girls. But I can't imagine anyone is surprised? He is a racist misogynistic with a special affinity for hurting Muslims.

What he is doing harm women in the US and around the world is unforgivable.

Thank you. I thought that was the case.

imaround Sat 08-Mar-25 17:59:07

Trump arranged that withdrawl. He went around Afghans government and negotiated with the Taliban.

Yes the withdrawal was horrible, but Trump had a large hand in it and is not resolved from responsibility just because it happened on Bidens watch.

This is, of course, horrible for these girls. But I can't imagine anyone is surprised? He is a racist misogynistic with a special affinity for hurting Muslims.

What he is doing harm women in the US and around the world is unforgivable.

MayBee70 Sat 08-Mar-25 17:52:09

Norah

MayBee70

It’s because of Trump that US and UK forces pulled out of Afghanistan so suddenly and left Afghan women to their fate sad.

Biden's Afghanistan withdrawal was over 2 years ago.

Current POTUS is making USAID cuts, now.

I believe that Biden had to go ahead with promises that had been made by the Trump administration ( I’m happy to be corrected). I was angry with Biden at the time until I read this.

Churchview Sat 08-Mar-25 17:10:24

I've just read a fascinating book on what it is to be a woman in Afghanistan. The Dressmaker of Khair Khana.

Norah Sat 08-Mar-25 14:38:44

Wyllow3

The withdrawal was when these girls made their escape, Norah, and it was to Bidens credit that USAID then picked up the funding.

Agreed.

Much of the support to Afghanistan from USAID would have been food (World food Program). A way for USA farmers to use USAID to "sell" excess food. Of course good for farmers and recipients.

Wyllow3 Sat 08-Mar-25 14:29:52

The withdrawal was when these girls made their escape, Norah, and it was to Bidens credit that USAID then picked up the funding.

Cossy Sat 08-Mar-25 14:27:25

Babs03

Thanks for highlighting this on International Women’s Day.
My heart breaks for these women.
😣

As does mine!

It would do us all good to remember how fortunate we actually are in this country, despite everything,

Norah Sat 08-Mar-25 14:22:52

MayBee70

It’s because of Trump that US and UK forces pulled out of Afghanistan so suddenly and left Afghan women to their fate sad.

Biden's Afghanistan withdrawal was over 2 years ago.

Current POTUS is making USAID cuts, now.

MayBee70 Sat 08-Mar-25 14:08:06

It’s because of Trump that US and UK forces pulled out of Afghanistan so suddenly and left Afghan women to their fate sad.

Ilovecheese Sat 08-Mar-25 14:07:13

Whitewavemark2

As will our cuts to aid - which will affect so many, especially girls education, vaccinations and other medical and food aid.

Yes, our cuts to foreign aid will also hurt vulnerable people like these women

Wyllow3 Sat 08-Mar-25 14:04:59

Allsorts

Does anyone think Trump cares!

No, we just need to hold him to account ...

Wyllow3 Sat 08-Mar-25 14:03:50

(Although women in Oman have made progress, there are still restrictions - just checked it out)

Allsorts Sat 08-Mar-25 14:01:09

Does anyone think Trump cares!

Wyllow3 Sat 08-Mar-25 13:59:49

If I recall correctly from the thread, this particular school were invited under USAID to the USA in the summer to experience different ways of life. The freedom for women in the USA.

Well now they do know!

That may be true GG13 but hardly the point. The point is the brutality of sudden cuts and the lack of compassion. For example, if what you say is true and Oman would take over,

then surely the point would be to negotiate with Oman first then make the cuts?