Gransnet forums

News & politics

Trump has attacked Iran

(736 Posts)
Bea65 Sun 22-Jun-25 02:03:09

Oh Lordy, what now …this is scary news and now what happens..

AGAA4 Thu 26-Jun-25 17:03:54

Allira

Although -
^President Donald Trump will not be invited to stay at Balmoral during his full 'bells and whistles' state visit to ensure the King can have a short period of "downtime", a royal expert has claimed.^

I think you could get a bit too much of Mr Trump. How diplomatic our king is.

Allira Thu 26-Jun-25 17:01:34

Although -
President Donald Trump will not be invited to stay at Balmoral during his full 'bells and whistles' state visit to ensure the King can have a short period of "downtime", a royal expert has claimed.

Allira Thu 26-Jun-25 16:58:49

Maremia

Allira? has something happened?

Ah, no!

Just thanking God for our King instead of some of these leaders who seem to get re-elected 🤔 time and again!

Allira Thu 26-Jun-25 16:56:48

Maremia

Allira? has something happened?

What? 🤔

DH just walked into the closed patio door but apart from that 🤞 I'd better go and see if he's ok.

Maremia Thu 26-Jun-25 16:44:14

Allira? has something happened?

Maremia Thu 26-Jun-25 16:41:28

OOOOOPs, correct thread.

Maremia Thu 26-Jun-25 16:40:29

Sorry Allira and others, wrong thread.

Maremia Thu 26-Jun-25 16:39:53

Same amount of power, AnnieB, so no not confusion, just semantics.

Maremia Thu 26-Jun-25 16:37:50

GN, a constant source of reading materials. Thanks Allira, such a lot of info and perspective in that document. I will have to take much more time to absorb the details. But randomly, two things have grabbed my intention.
Hezbollah apeared in the aftermath of the Israel invasion of the country in 1882. So, not at the creation of the state of Israel, as I took to be the case from some posts upthread.
Most ordinary Iranians would be happy to accept a two state solution.
There is hope.

Allira Thu 26-Jun-25 16:36:11

God Save Our Gracious King.

Anniebach Thu 26-Jun-25 16:32:12

Quote Maremia Thu 26-Jun-25 16:08:40
AnnieB, your opinion is that Netanyahu must be fine as he has been in charge for a long time.
Putin has been in charge for possibly the same length of time.
Sorry, but I don't see length of rule as being the best indicator of moral fitness to rule.

You seem confused, Putin is President, Netanyahu is Prime
Minister ,

Allira Thu 26-Jun-25 16:25:15

www.arab-reform.net/publication/ari-sadly-announces-the-death-of-bassma-kodmani/
2/3/2023

Allira Thu 26-Jun-25 16:22:47

Maremia

Gosh what a torrent of discussion since last I joined in.
Point of Information request, at what point in Iran's political history did the Leaders threaten to destroy Israel?
Was it before, during or after Mosaddegh's time. Fyi, he was democratically elected, but overthrown in 1953 by the good old US of A.

www.institutmontaigne.org/en/expressions/what-does-iran-really-want
Author Dr Bassma Kodmani, who was a Syrian political scientist.
10/8/2021

Maremia Thu 26-Jun-25 16:08:40

AnnieB, your opinion is that Netanyahu must be fine as he has been in charge for a long time.
Putin has been in charge for possibly the same length of time.
Sorry, but I don't see length of rule as being the best indicator of moral fitness to rule.

Maremia Thu 26-Jun-25 16:05:02

Gosh what a torrent of discussion since last I joined in.
Point of Information request, at what point in Iran's political history did the Leaders threaten to destroy Israel?
Was it before, during or after Mosaddegh's time. Fyi, he was democratically elected, but overthrown in 1953 by the good old US of A.

AGAA4 Thu 26-Jun-25 16:01:22

The US language on the efficacy of the bombs has changed from 'obliteration' to 'damage'. They aren't really sure despite the bluster.
Pete Hesgeth is attacking the press for doubting the success. He was very angry but the US will be afraid they have made a terrible mistake and Iran are even now working on more nuclear weapons.
I am afraid too.

David49 Thu 26-Jun-25 15:46:28

AGAA4

Taking sides can be likened to
what Trump said about Israel and Iran being like kids in a playground fighting.
I don't want Iran to become powerful but the only "side" I am on is the UKs
The safety of our own people is what's most important and we need to be able to defend ourselves from Iran and others who wish us harm.

Rational nations recognize the Armageddon of mutual destruction, I think Iran believes there will be enough survivors to populate their kind of world.

The US “Bunker Buster” bomb is only capable of penetrating
10m (30ft) of concrete, Iran’s bomb factory is under Thousands of feet of rock. The US probably collapsed the entrance but little else.
E

Anniebach Thu 26-Jun-25 15:34:54

Whitewave Netanyahu and Christmas ?

Allira Thu 26-Jun-25 15:31:46

Nor with Hamas or the Iranian regime either, presumably?

Whitewavemark2 Thu 26-Jun-25 15:27:12

And as someone said upthread.

My loyalties lie with the U.K. not the USA and certainly not Netanyahu!

Whitewavemark2 Thu 26-Jun-25 15:24:23

What I am not interested in in the tribalism and hysteria surrounding this issue, however I am interested in the international legality of the what is happening. So, we know that an attack on another country is only deemed legal when an armed attack is imminent (art. 51). It isn’t enough to say that someone is an enemy, and it isn’t enough to say that my enemy might attack me sometime in the future. To date, neither Israel nor the USA have been able to show concrete evidence that Iran was about to attack Israel. Indeed the nuclear agency have categorically stated that Iran was nowhere near manufacturing a nuclear war head, let alone the capability of delivering it.

What we do know however, is that Netanyahu has made it one of his life’s ambitions to rid Iran of the capability, and the fact that the USA has now joined him in this fight must make him think that all his christmases have come at once. But I still go back to the law, and the apparent illegality of their actions.

If we ignore this law, then we might as well all pack up and go home.

With regard to Iran. It seems to me that this is a case of being careful what you wish for. So the Revolution, which toppled the Shah, whose continuance had been supported by western powers, was hoped to bring an out a democracy, but unfortunately instead heralded in the dictatorship we see today. The result many think of the backlash to western interference.

So imo the aim to bring about regime change is neither desirable nor sensible given the past history, Irans ethnic profile and the strong possibility that Iranians will work together to resist outside interference from the west particularly Israel.

With regard to ability of nuclear capability. I don’t for one minute think that Iran has been neutralised regarding nuclear weapons, and my fear now is that Khamenei, who has always done enough in various assaults on his perceived enemy but never too much, will reckon that he has nothing to lose by secretly developing this weapon and threatening to use it if pushed by Israel, either directly or indirected by his sleeper cells spread throughout the world.

That is why diplomacy and talks always top violence, and why I see what is happening as nothing but bad news for the world. Perhaps not immediately but certainly for the near future.

Claremont Thu 26-Jun-25 15:15:59

Oreo

silverlining48

Sometimes sitting on a fence allows one to see both sides and many on here seem to see only one direction, that of Israel, which completely controls and denies Palestine with the same rights as almost everywhere else. The right of food, water medical aid, a life, plus the right to freedom of movement and freedom from fear.
Hamas has said it wants to go, if there were elections in both Israel , where Netanyahu would without doubt lose and Palestine where a new government were elected, this might then be possible for a two state solution to come about.

Surely most people whoever they are, want to live in peace ?

Wrong thread?
This one is about Iran and nuclear weapons. How can anyone take their side or even fence sit?

And some are replying why Israel and nuclear weapons. How can anyone take their side or even fence sit' They are currently the aggressors.

AGAA4 Thu 26-Jun-25 14:39:50

Taking sides can be likened to
what Trump said about Israel and Iran being like kids in a playground fighting.
I don't want Iran to become powerful but the only "side" I am on is the UKs
The safety of our own people is what's most important and we need to be able to defend ourselves from Iran and others who wish us harm.

Oreo Thu 26-Jun-25 14:29:51

silverlining48

Sometimes sitting on a fence allows one to see both sides and many on here seem to see only one direction, that of Israel, which completely controls and denies Palestine with the same rights as almost everywhere else. The right of food, water medical aid, a life, plus the right to freedom of movement and freedom from fear.
Hamas has said it wants to go, if there were elections in both Israel , where Netanyahu would without doubt lose and Palestine where a new government were elected, this might then be possible for a two state solution to come about.

Surely most people whoever they are, want to live in peace ?

Wrong thread?
This one is about Iran and nuclear weapons. How can anyone take their side or even fence sit?

Claremont Thu 26-Jun-25 14:19:52

GrannyGravy13

Claremont that piece is 47 years old.

I expect many politicians of all colours had different ideas and views when they were young and living life have changed them.

I am not a fan of Benjamin Netanyahu, but he was elected and is I believe up there with Israel’s longest serving PM’s.

I cannot imagine what it must be like to be Jewish and have your race/religion persecuted over 1,000’s of years. Is it any wonder they want to protect themselves, living in the midst of countries who want to not only see the end of Israel, but the demise of all Jews on the planet.

47 years olf. and that was my point entirely. I have posted other videos of him expressing his wish to attack Palestinians very hard, to the point of non recovery, about 20 years later. Some leopards change their spots, his have just becoe bigger and more numerous with time.