Gransnet forums

News & politics

Genocide is being committed in Gaza by Israel

(792 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Tue 16-Sept-25 10:16:17

4 of the 5 conditions are fulfilled.

UN report.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:28:04

Annie, those poor families could have told him. Why is he not in touch with them enough to know the numbers?

ronib Tue 07-Oct-25 13:29:21

It’s great you know so much about Netanyahu Maremia. Would you like to reconsider your comment?

AGAA4 Tue 07-Oct-25 13:32:08

The priority for Netanyahu has never been the hostages. I just hope he is not allowed to have all his own way in the peace process.

Anniebach Tue 07-Oct-25 13:36:29

Quote Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:28:04
Annie, those poor families could have told him. Why is he not in touch with them enough to know the numbers?

Hamas contacted families when a hostage dies ? They took hostage the Bibas family, earlier this year they released the father amid the thousands of mocking Palestinians, gave him a speech to read from a stage, his joy being reunited, they forgot they had murdered his wife and two very small sons.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:43:52

We already and all of us know how evil Hamas is.
Netanyahu should have known the number of hostages. The families know.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:47:24

Have I offended you ronib, by speaking out against Netanyahu? Are you a fan of his? Do you admire how he has been 'dealing' with Gaza?

Anniebach Tue 07-Oct-25 13:47:42

Quote Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:43:52
We already and all of us know how evil Hamas is.
Netanyahu should have known the number of hostages. The families know.

Do they ? Why a mother saying she doesn’t know if her son is alive or dead ?
You honestly believe Hamas releases truth ?

Anniebach Tue 07-Oct-25 13:49:24

Quote Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:43:52
We already and all of us know how evil Hamas is.
Netanyahu should have known the number of hostages. The families know.

You criticise the Israeli government, you now criticise the Gaza government!

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:52:30

What I quoted upthread Annie were the comments, not from Hamas, but from the actual Hostage Families, who were critical of Netanyahu for giving out the numbers as they know them.
According to the actual Hostage Families, Netanyahu got the numbers wrong.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:57:56

Which Gaza government? Who is talking about the Gaza Government? You brought up Hamas.
Unless you mean that Netanyahu is the Gaza Government?
As far as I know Netanyahu is still in charge in Israel. Up to the people of Israel if that continues after the next election.
So yes, if you equate Netanyahu and the Government of Israel, then yes, the HHOSTAGE FAMILIES are criticising him and by your definition, the Israeli Government, for getting the numbers, so dear to their hearts, wrong.

Anniebach Tue 07-Oct-25 14:03:12

Hamas is the elected government of Gaza

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 14:04:20

Yes, and?

lixy Wed 08-Oct-25 08:16:52

They’re still talking; we are still hoping.

AGAA4 Wed 08-Oct-25 09:36:07

Trump is joining the talks today.

lixy Wed 08-Oct-25 10:33:59

Not Trump himself I think, but his son in law Jared Kushner is on his way there today along with special envoy Steve Witkoff. Qatar’s prime minister will also be joining today.
I hope this is a sign that momentum is building

Maremia Wed 08-Oct-25 10:45:29

That young man seems to have influence, and calmer than his father in law.
At least they are still talking.