FriedGreenTomatoes2
We rely heavily on intel from Israel and Trump, like it or not has bases here in the UK and IS an ally, no matter what the present UK government are trying to unravel. The USA is a super power. We dismiss our friends with impunity these days it seems.
Which is why Burnham is cosying up to the EU. Yes, the ones who have all had to be cajoled by Trump to up their defence budgets. Which they are very grudgingly doing and it’ll take years (2030 and beyond, to reach 5% of GDP).
Madness Burnham and Milliband, just so reckless. I cannot believe we are being so foolish.
You are correct, but let us put it in context. Are you happy to just allow Israel to do whatever they please in Gaza and in fact Iran, if they so desire, and given Netanyahu’s strong links with Trump, do you actually trust the Israeli government?
“The United Kingdom receives vast, specialized intelligence from Israel—particularly regarding Iran, cyber threats, and Middle Eastern counterterrorism—though it operates on a fundamentally different scale and nature than the UK’s primary institutional alliances like the Five Eyes.
Comparison with UK Allies
• The Five Eyes (US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand):
• Scale & Structure: This is the bedrock of British intelligence. It is a continuous, institutionalized, and automated global sharing network—mostly for signals intelligence (GCHQ and the US NSA) and deep human intelligence (HUMINT) cooperation.
• Comparison to Israel: The volume, global breadth, and legal/technical integration of intelligence shared with the US and Five Eyes far exceed what the UK receives from Israel. Israel is a crucial bilateral partner rather than a member of an integrated multilateral intelligence bloc like the Five Eyes.
• Israel (Mossad, Shin Bet, and Aman):
• Focus & Strength:
Israel's intelligence value to the UK is highly targeted and regional. Former CIA and security officials note that Israel possesses superior human networks and cyber-intelligence capabilities inside the Middle East (specifically concerning Iran, proxy groups, and regional threats) than Western agencies can easily replicate.
• Practical Impact: Israeli intelligence has historically provided high-value, actionable warning tips to British security services (such as alerting MI5 to potential Iranian-backed plots on British soil).
• Limitations: Unlike the deep, two-way structural sharing with Washington or European NATO partners, intelligence ties with Israel are transactional, bilateral, and periodically susceptible to political and diplomatic friction (such as disputes over West Bank settlements or Middle East policy).”


