Gransnet forums

News & politics

A general election (democratic eh not like Hamas) is taking place in Israel on Tuesday next week.

(228 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 25-Oct-26 13:04:42

Israel has lost patience after nearly 80 years of terrorism and attacks from neighbouring states.

They are getting nothing but abuse whatever they do and never see fair reporting about the behaviour of their opponents.

They may as well completely absorb Gaza and the West Bank and evict any who don’t like it.

Those Arabs who stay and give up on violence will then have much improved futures compared to that on offer from Hamas.

In my opinion.

AGAA4 Sun 25-Oct-26 15:23:56

Oreo

Only because of extremist actions against them.

Genocide is rather extreme.

Wyllow3 Sun 25-Oct-26 15:25:11

FriedGreenTomatoes2

One question, asked by Golda Meir: why did the Arabs not declare a state of Palestine in the West Bank between 1948 and 1967?

Then Clinton tried and Arafat embarrassed him by walking away.

The Palestinians have form.

You're got your history wrong FGT.

. The whole of Palestine was a British protectorate until the end of WW2, tho both Jewish and Palestinians had terrorist and non terrorist political organisations wanting Statehood.

At the end of WW2 the Allied Powers, tho primarily, it has to be said, the USA - gave Israel Statehood and that followed a promise by Balfour in 1917 but not Palestine.

The possibility of a two state solution could have been given there and then

Palestine didn't have any power to self declare without international recognition during that time.

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 15:26:16

The Israeli government isn’t a corrupt one where elections are rigged , and I can only suppose you are allowing your own Palestinian support to colour your views.
Many do that.

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 15:28:15

AGAA4

Oreo

Only because of extremist actions against them.

Genocide is rather extreme.

So is creeping into a country during the small hours and slaughtering over a thousand innocent people, many in their beds including children.Then taking hostages and murdering most of them.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 25-Oct-26 15:29:38

It’s all so dispiriting how distorted can this get..

Firstly no such place or people Palestinian a name coined by Arafat a terrorist leader of PLO kicked out of Jordan who annexed Judea and Samaria renamed it West Bank

Islamic Jihad exists in the so called West Bank. Arab gangs fight each other there they have also attacked murdered and poisoned Israeli livestock.

Egypt has built a steel wall against Gaza: why!?

Because they like every Arab state don't want these people because of the trouble they cause

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 15:29:56

If anyone thinks that left wing liberal political parties will win this next election they must think again.
It will be a good few years now until that happens.

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 15:31:41

Egypt has been punitive against its own extremist groups and won’t take those from Gaza.You can’t blame them.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 25-Oct-26 15:33:10

This small video helped shape my support for Israel.

Taken from a debate at Oxford union by a Jewish woman who attended Cambridge.

Anyone dispute her account of events? She did her homework that’s for sure.

youtu.be/VtrcRlBWnMk?is=rj-1zG1DIiNdANTe

AGAA4 Sun 25-Oct-26 15:43:04

Oreo so the killing of 70000 men women and children is fair?
What Hamas did was horrific. The killing of Gazans is horrific too.

They are not all Hamas. How can babies and toddlers be a danger to Israel?

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 15:45:22

How could babies and toddlers be a danger to hamas? They still murdered them on purpose.

Samwam Sun 25-Oct-26 15:45:28

NAZA Documentary.

The documentary is not about Palistinians it's about Israel and how Israelis who are direct participants in the Genocide explain and report on their participation. From that point of view it is necessary and terrifying. As a documentary, it is absolutely extraordinary how the film makers got people guilty of mass murder and war crimes to speak to them so frankly. All of those who spoke should be prosecuted and held accountable for their crimes but only one of them really appeared to be reckoning honestly with what he had done. His explanation of how enjoyable it was to be so focused and mission driven and how exhilarating it was to be in a group causing such horrors will terrify most people.
One of the most chilling parts and probably a lesson for everyone who sees it was the man who explained that their unit was seen as the left wing Tel Aviv elite by the rest of the military and political system. Their unit was responsible for remotely planning and executing thousands of attacks which intentionally and deliberately aimed to kill civilians, using the 'Daddys Home' machine learning technology. They explained that they were doing it before their international legitimacy ran out, and that they'd do their day's work and head out to socialize in Tel Aviv's restaurants and night life as the respected and admired elite. There are two key messages there: 1. The Israeli 'left' will not stop this genocide and 2. Anyone with power who is upholding Israel's international legitimacy has blood on their hands.

There were some weaknesses in the doc, even in the closing credits it says for example that 'Israel continues it's killing of civilians' almost making the case that there are some Palestinians that should be killed and after decades of occupation and annihilation by Israel of Palestinians this is not an adequate position. Secondly the documentary provides almost no explanation of anything except the current phase of the genocide other than a few brief frames of the founding of Tel Aviv and a few shots of older buildings being bulldozed. All that said I think we are fortunate this documentary has been made and I really hope it is seen for example in Germany by the government, in the EU Parliament Lynn Boylan and hopefully in our own Dail to make people realize how deliberate, knowing and intentional these horrific Israeli crimes against Palestinians have been.

Also as an aside, in the first part of the documentary it becomes absolutely clear that smart phones are devices of mass surveillance. I'm not sure what do with that information but watch the documentary and you'll see how every single thing on your phone can be accessed and used. The Israelis were using the cameras on people's phones remotely to see what was happening in Palestinian homes.

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 15:49:26

Getting back to the subject of the thread, the forthcoming election, Israelis will choose not us who makes up the next government but highly unlikely to be left wing.
I believe they will prefer Eisenkot to BN as a fresh start but could be wrong.

Whitewavemark2 Sun 25-Oct-26 15:50:18

I think this documentary is essential watching. Be available to all in November on YouTube.

PollyEsther Sun 25-Oct-26 15:53:57

FriedGreenTomatoes2

It’s all so dispiriting how distorted can this get..

Firstly no such place or people Palestinian a name coined by Arafat a terrorist leader of PLO kicked out of Jordan who annexed Judea and Samaria renamed it West Bank

Islamic Jihad exists in the so called West Bank. Arab gangs fight each other there they have also attacked murdered and poisoned Israeli livestock.

Egypt has built a steel wall against Gaza: why!?

Because they like every Arab state don't want these people because of the trouble they cause

Maybe I've misunderstood what you're claiming, but Arafat didn't coin the term "Palestinian".

PollyEsther Sun 25-Oct-26 15:54:51

Oreo

AGAA4

Oreo

Only because of extremist actions against them.

Genocide is rather extreme.

So is creeping into a country during the small hours and slaughtering over a thousand innocent people, many in their beds including children.Then taking hostages and murdering most of them.

No, it's not genocide. It's murder, but It's not genocide.

Cossy Sun 25-Oct-26 15:57:52

Oreo

The Israeli government isn’t a corrupt one where elections are rigged , and I can only suppose you are allowing your own Palestinian support to colour your views.
Many do that.

Tbf I don’t really much about the Israeli government, outside of Netanyahu and I very much feel he himself is corrupt.

The trio of Netanyahu, Trump and Putin, scares me.

So absolutely no offence meant.

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 15:58:26

It’s not Genocide in Gaza either since 2million of them are still there.

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 16:01:46

Cossy no offence taken, I wanted to put the record straight, that Israel’s elections are fair and democratic.

Cossy Sun 25-Oct-26 16:02:46

Genocide is the intentional and systematic destruction, in whole or in part, of a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group.

I feel both sides of this war actually wish for genocide. It’s very clear Israel will not stop until they’ve stolen that remaining land they so dearly want.

What Hamas did was utterly disgusting and appalling but Israel are attempting to destroy every single scrap of Gaza, and all who inhabit it.

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 16:05:03

Two million still inhabit it!

Cossy Sun 25-Oct-26 16:05:45

Oreo

Cossy no offence taken, I wanted to put the record straight, that Israel’s elections are fair and democratic.

No that’s k, as I said, I know nothing about their election process nor their government. That is for correcting me.

All really want is for this war, the “troubles”, the destruction, the murders on both sides to stop, ditto Ukraine ditto Iran.

There are no winners! ☹️😢

Whitewavemark2 Sun 25-Oct-26 16:08:04

Oreo

It’s not Genocide in Gaza either since 2million of them are still there.

Oh dear we established months ago that to be classed as genocide, it does not mean that every living soul of a group has to be murdered.

Oreo Sun 25-Oct-26 16:08:44

Cossy

Oreo

Cossy no offence taken, I wanted to put the record straight, that Israel’s elections are fair and democratic.

No that’s k, as I said, I know nothing about their election process nor their government. That is for correcting me.

All really want is for this war, the “troubles”, the destruction, the murders on both sides to stop, ditto Ukraine ditto Iran.

There are no winners! ☹️😢

You’re right, no winners just hopefully an end to most of it.

Cossy Sun 25-Oct-26 16:15:56

Oreo 16:04 I truly hope so 🙏🙏🫶🫶

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 25-Oct-26 16:29:03

We go round the houses with our preferred bias. Let’s revisit this thread after Tuesday’s election when we will be able to see what the Israeli people voted for.