Gransnet forums

News & politics

A general election (democratic eh not like Hamas) is taking place in Israel on Tuesday next week.

(228 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 25-Oct-26 13:04:42

Israel has lost patience after nearly 80 years of terrorism and attacks from neighbouring states.

They are getting nothing but abuse whatever they do and never see fair reporting about the behaviour of their opponents.

They may as well completely absorb Gaza and the West Bank and evict any who don’t like it.

Those Arabs who stay and give up on violence will then have much improved futures compared to that on offer from Hamas.

In my opinion.

Whitewavemark2 Sun 25-Oct-26 16:54:11

It matters little, although if Netanyahu is voted out, we shall be shall to judge how strong the judiciary is, which Netanyahu has done his best to emasculate.

Frenchgalinspain Sun 25-Oct-26 17:03:52

LemonJam

2 sides to the story- equally Palestinians would have a better life and chance of survival in Gaza without Natanyu.

100% Truer than true ..

The Israeli people do not want Netanyu nor do they want torturing of children, starving children and women and living in such disasterous conditions ..

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 25-Oct-26 17:15:38

Well let’s wait & see shall we? I’m not so certain.

Wyllow3 Sun 25-Oct-26 17:28:28

No, let's carry on talking if we want to!

Whitewavemark2 Sun 25-Oct-26 19:32:45

I think it is highly likely that the Israelis will want to continue with Netanyahu, or at the very least a premier who has every intention of getting rid of the Palestinians and take their land.

MaizieD Mon 26-Oct-26 12:54:34

Oreo

It’s not Genocide in Gaza either since 2million of them are still there.

So, what Hitler did wasn't genocide either because millions of Jews still exist?

(At least 15 million of them according to AI, of which about 7 million live in Israel)

Oh dear...

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 12:59:14

The Jews in Germany had done nothing wrong at all, they were German, Austrian and Polish citizens .
A quite different scenario.

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 12:59:56

Over 6 million were murdered.

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 13:01:43

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Well let’s wait & see shall we? I’m not so certain.

Nobody can be certain, but attitudes have hardened since the 7th October so it’s reasonable to think it will be a right wing coalition.

Chocolatelovinggran Mon 26-Oct-26 13:08:18

As I have posted before, those of us who are familiar with the Old Testament might point out, respectfully, that the nation who recorded their history in these books list a long, long, history of fighting with their neighbours.

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 13:10:41

That sounds very antisemitic to me chocolate

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 13:12:23

Have Christian nations never had a history of fighting with each other? Ireland and Eastern Europe amongst others.

PollyEsther Mon 26-Oct-26 13:13:22

Oreo

That sounds very antisemitic to me chocolate

I don't really understand why you think that. Most of the tribes fighting each other were Semites.

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 13:23:17

It’s antisemitic to bring up the Old Testament in relation to the situation in Israel by saying that Jews have always been fighting with neighbours. Thousands of years ago has no relevance here and is just yet another dig at Jewish people and Israel.
Christians have been fighting each other and so have Muslim countries.

David49 Mon 26-Oct-26 13:32:00

We will find out this week if Israelis support Netenyahu policies, although if he or someone similar does win Im sure there will be many who say the election was fixed.

Isnt it about time Gaza had a free and far election

AGAA4 Mon 26-Oct-26 13:35:17

Not going back thousands of years but Israel has been fighting with its neighbours on and off since its start.

I am not blaming Israel but the situation that has arisen there where Jews and Arabs don't live in peace.

The blame for this lies elsewhere.

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 13:37:43

No David49 as hamas are still active there, there would be too much intimidation and corruption.

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 13:40:30

Yes AGAA4 the State of Israel is surrounded by enemies who would like to see the destruction of it.
They have no choice but to fight back.

AGAA4 Mon 26-Oct-26 13:49:16

Oreo

Yes AGAA4 the State of Israel is surrounded by enemies who would like to see the destruction of it.
They have no choice but to fight back.

The whole thing was badly managed by Britain and the US.
That area was always going to be hostile to setting up a state of Israel then walking away and telling them all to play nicely.

I can't see the middle east ever being peaceful.

Samwam Mon 26-Oct-26 13:51:42

Israeli Reserve Major Avdar Shailovski wrote an article, which he published on his Facebook page, recounting his flight from the Israeli military and his emigration from Israel to Poland—the land of his ancestors.
The article is titled: "I Can No Longer Remain Silent."

Here is the full text of the article:

I am Avdar Shailovski, a major who deserted the Israeli military. I declare, while of sound mind, that I left the Israeli military because I could no longer bear to remain a silent witness—betraying my own humanity—to all the crimes I witnessed during my five years of service.
The events I witnessed will suffocate me if I do not share them with you.
I could die at any moment from the sheer weight of my grief; therefore, I must contribute to revealing the truth—perhaps it will alleviate my sense of guilt, and perhaps God will lessen the torment that awaits me for the horrific acts I committed simply by virtue of being a member of the Israel Defense Forces.
Then, I received a sign: "Leave everything behind and go your own way."
Thank You, God, for guiding me.

As soon as the El Al flight landed at Warsaw Airport, I felt safe—far away from the land of Israel, which no longer holds any meaning for me.
They taught us about the land that God promised us, but it is the greatest lie ever used to deceive the Jewish people. It is a persistent, ongoing lie—one that has continued around the clock for eighty years—which has resulted in the displacement of an unarmed Palestinian people from their own land. Furthermore, to this very day, these people continue to suffer immensely. Who invented this lie? And what kind of "foolish" people believed it?

What I witnessed during my five-year service in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) is difficult to put into words.
What words could possibly describe the cruelty, the vileness, and the atrocities committed by the IDF against the Palestinians?
Do not believe a word from that wretched man—that scoundrel, son of a scoundrel. He is a despicable liar, especially when he claims the Israeli army is "the most moral army in the world"—what utter nonsense! The truth is, it is the most depraved, cruel, and brutal army in the world.
Yes, ladies and gentlemen, I can no longer bear to witness the ruin and destruction in Gaza.
I was a witness to what took place on the night of October 7, 2023. Israeli intelligence, that wretched man, and his gang knew it was coming; they waited for it to happen so they could justify the destruction of Gaza and attempt to displace its population.
I served in Gaza, and I saw with my own eyes how a tank commander would toy with his tank’s cannon, firing shells at Palestinians huddled inside their tents, or at groups of people standing in lines—whether in front of bakeries, or by vehicles distributing food and aid. With my own eyes, I witnessed aircraft firing projectiles at inhabited residential buildings, reducing them to rubble atop the people living inside.
With my own eyes, I saw snipers from the occupation army amusing themselves by picking off children, adults, and women as they stood in line to receive aid.
This is madness.
Crimes such as these—which I witnessed—could not happen anywhere else in the world; they occur only on the land of Palestine.
With my own eyes, I saw a child clutching a piece of stale, blood-soaked bread, weeping over his mother’s body—while the soldiers laughed, as if they were watching a comedy video.
They claim that these people are not human beings, not equals to us—to us Jews.
I would summon my courage and say to my colleagues, "Brother, even if they were a group of monkeys, could we possibly kill them in this manner?"
They would reply, "You are a coward; you are weak—you are not fit to be a Jew."
I saw settlers in the West Bank uprooting olive trees and assaulting farmers in their own fields.
I saw them destroy homes—issuing an immediate evacuation order to the owners, only to demolish the structures while the residents were still inside.
With my own eyes, I saw a soldier send a text message to a Palestinian, telling him: "Go up to the roof, or we will destroy the house—with your family inside—because of you." When the man climbed to the roof and began waving a white rag, the soldier shot him dead on the spot.
Can anyone believe this? I can find no explanation for all this Israeli cruelty other than the upbringing we Jews were subjected to. We were told that Arabs are filthy, savage, and extremist Muslim killers—and that if we were kind to them, they would throw us into the sea. Just imagine the kind of indoctrination they fed us.
They taught us that the land of Palestine belongs to us, the Jews.
They claimed that the Golan and the entire Levant belong to the children of Zion.
They taught us that "Greater Israel" stretches from the Euphrates to the Nile.
How wicked we Jews must be to believe all these lies. If we were not wicked, foolish, and devoid of morality, we would never have carried out these orders.

Smileless2012 Mon 26-Oct-26 13:56:12

Of course Chocolatelovinggran's post isn't antisemitic Oreo. You make that accusation virtually every time someone says something about Israel that you don't like.

Israel's conflicts with it's neighbours as written in the Old Testament can be analysed as religious and/or historical; it is not antisemitic.

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 14:09:23

It’s antisemitic to throw something from over two thousand years ago into the mix as if it had relevance to Israel today.
It’s the sort of casual ‘well what do you expect as they are all war mongers’ entirely omitting to say that followers of The New Testament and followers of the Quaran have never stopped being at war with other countries.

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 14:20:05

That isn’t the full text Samwan and there is real doubt about the author of it.
The full thing sounds as if it was written by an Arab not a Jew in the fancy imaging and style of writing.
Don’t fall for all you read.

Smileless2012 Mon 26-Oct-26 14:28:22

History is relevant Oreo. You've just said followers of The New Testament and followers of the Quaran have never stopped being at war with other countries which is true as it's true of Israel, so why is your post @ 14.09 acceptable if Chocolatelovinggran's isn't?

Oreo Mon 26-Oct-26 14:32:27

Because I don’t single out Jews as war mongers.The truth is that all races and religions commit to acts of war as do all countries.