Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

The weather forecast

(29 Posts)
AlieOxon Sun 04-Nov-12 20:35:01

The forecaster today said 'there is some real eclectic weather out there'.
It keeps bugging me. Is it right?

Elegran Mon 05-Nov-12 22:25:26

on·o·mat·o·poe·ia (n-mt-p, -mät-) n.
The formation or use of words such as buzz or murmur that imitate the sounds associated with the objects or actions they refer to.

e·clec·tic (-klktk)adj.
Made up of or combining elements from a variety of sources.

So you reckon that when combining elements from a variety of sources you make a kind of clicking sound?

OK. If you say so.

Good night. hmm moon

Nonu Mon 05-Nov-12 20:46:34

Ellie , honey have u actually looked up the word "onomatopoeic" in your dictionary ? grin

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 20:40:23

Yawwwwn! hmm

Nonu Mon 05-Nov-12 20:32:34

It does mean what it means Eleg. Can"t be more consice then that . duh !

Elegran Mon 05-Nov-12 20:22:32

Not muddying the water, jings I am trying to make the water clear enough to see through. Yes eclectic does sound like the word eclairs. That is because they have some of the same letters.

It is just that if you do use a technical word like onomatopoeic then why not use it to mean what it means. That is - sounding like the thing it means! Thinking up examples is fun. Bonfire night has - Splat! Crackle! Murmur. Whoosh!

I don't think nonu meant it to mean that in her post, did you nonu? That is why I was confused confused as to what she did mean.

Lots of means there, but I don't mean to be mean. grin

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 19:30:40

grin

Take no notice. I'm having a turn. hmm grin

Nonu Mon 05-Nov-12 19:06:49

Oh golly gosh i am all at sea here , help !!!! grin

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 18:56:04

btw I haven't really got a twitch.

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 18:55:04

hasty wink

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 18:54:28

I was talking about "eclectic"! Not ono-wotsit! (which I've never heard of of!) hmm

Trust you-know-u to muddy the waters! hmm

Nonu Mon 05-Nov-12 18:31:05

Elegran , <think> I know what u mean . grin

Ana Mon 05-Nov-12 18:27:17

You're right, though, Elegran! grin

Elegran Mon 05-Nov-12 18:13:36

Do the colliding weather fronts go Cl-cl-cl then? That is what I mean by onomatopeoic - sounding like the thing they are describing, like sloshing for rain or pitter-patter for raindrops.

Sorry to be pedantic, nonu and jings - maybe this is the wrong thread ..... you can make words mean what you want them to mean, as in Alice in Wonderland .....

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 17:12:48

an extra 'l' got in there.

it was my twitch that did it.

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 17:12:09

Apart from the obvious, (eclairs), eclectic sounds like a c'lllection of things.

So there were obvioulsy colliding weather fronts.

Simples.

Elegran Mon 05-Nov-12 17:10:09

What is the picture it illustrates aurally for you, nonu? I can't see one.

Nonu Mon 05-Nov-12 16:52:20

eclectic is such an onomatopoeic word to me grin

AlieOxon Mon 05-Nov-12 16:07:15

(2nd try) - actually both of them bugged me. Daft is right.

Anne58 Mon 05-Nov-12 12:56:09

I assume that they meant to say "really", but it is still a daft way to describe weather.

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 10:00:16

sorry! blush

jO5 Mon 05-Nov-12 09:59:31

grin You all missed the point! You went for the long word! grin

AlieOxon Mon 05-Nov-12 09:06:13

Also, what would weather be if it wasn't real?

absentgrana Mon 05-Nov-12 08:55:12

But not organised feetlebaum grin

feetlebaum Mon 05-Nov-12 08:52:35

I think the body of posters here could fairly be described as 'eclectic'!

absentgrana Mon 05-Nov-12 08:35:08

I'm dubious about describing weather as "eclectic", but even more doubtful about describing rain as "organised".