Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Perfect for pedants' corner

(113 Posts)
CariGransnet (GNHQ) Wed 06-Feb-13 09:15:03

Saw this and thought of you (and us!)

www.guardian.co.uk/teacher-network/teacher-blog/quiz/2013/feb/04/grammar-punctuation-quiz-test?CMP=twt_gu

Greatnan Thu 07-Feb-13 11:55:26

Gerundives don't really figure in English grammar, I think, and I always explained gerunds by saying they were verbal nouns, using 'I enjoy running' as an example. 'A dripping tap' is a verbal adjective.
I grew up in the era of parsing and analysing and I loved it. I think I can still remember all the different types of adverbial clauses - no, I have never needed the knowledge, but I just enjoy it.

Anne58 Thu 07-Feb-13 12:08:34

The school that I attended had compulsory Latin for the first year! At the time I couldn't see the point, but it's surprising how some of it can relate to other languages.

Although as our Latin teacher was Welsh, there are probably still a few of us around who quote Latin phrases with an accent that is pure Swansea!

j08 Thu 07-Feb-13 12:19:35

I'm only saying that's how it came across when emails first started. Like most things, usage has evolved.

It wasn't' t used so much in a social context back then.

Horses for courses I guess.

annodomini Thu 07-Feb-13 12:39:45

I also enjoyed analysis of sentences at school. I like to see a pattern - so it's a bit puzzling that I had little use for maths.

feetlebaum Thu 07-Feb-13 13:23:58

Oh anno - I hated grammatical analysis. Fortunately, my English master (who had co-authored the text book 'An English Grammar of Function') recognised this, and told me that as I used the language well enough, I could write, while the others fiddled about with their seven columns of analysis!

Ana Thu 07-Feb-13 13:32:13

Shocking favouritism, feetlebaum! wink

Greatnan Thu 07-Feb-13 18:35:26

Anno - I am a bit unusual in that I love both maths and English, so I am equally happy doing a maths/logic puzzle or a crossword. I was told at college that I was a convergent/divergent thinker - I think the wires in my brain are crossed!

MamaCaz Thu 14-Feb-13 18:05:02

One wrong here - I knew that 'pride' was an abstract noun, but forgot its collective meaning!

MamaCaz Thu 14-Feb-13 18:06:27

I forgot to add that I wasn't taught any of that stuff in school English lessons - it has all come from learning French and Spanish.

annodomini Thu 14-Feb-13 19:11:12

MamaCaz - I'll come clean - I used to be an English teacher and I made the same mistake - just doing it too fast to think about it!

GrannyGear Thu 28-Mar-13 14:34:56

I got 13 out of 14 - hadn't spotted that "pride" can be a collective - as in a pride of lions.
But I object to the question that asked which sentence was grammatically correct. My contention is that they were*all*grammatically correct but some had spelling mistakes. Grammar is not the same as orthography.

GrannyGear Thu 28-Mar-13 14:36:15

I got 13 out of 14 - hadn't spotted that "pride" can be a collective - as in a pride of lions. But I objected to the question that asked which sentence was grammatically correct. My contention is that they were*all*grammatically correct but some had spelling mistakes. Grammar is not the same as orthography.