Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Why don't people die anymore?

(129 Posts)
FlicketyB Sat 24-Jan-15 17:43:27

When I was a child anybody using a euphemism for death; 'passed away', 'passed over' etc was considered prissy. Now everybody 'passes away'.

The BBC announce on the news that some famous person has 'passed away'. I heard a doctor on 24 hours in A&E this week tell a patient's family that there family member had 'passed away'.

Why do we no longer say that people have died? What is wrong with the word that describes what has happened? Why are we so enamoured of a euphemism that it is becoming the standard way of saying someone has died.

absent Sat 24-Jan-15 21:45:30

Pedants'. Grr.

yogagran Sat 24-Jan-15 21:57:39

Oh dear merlot - I can feel your embarrassment but that did make me smile!

Katek Sat 24-Jan-15 22:00:19

I must admit that that was my first thought as well Granjura. Speaking from recent experiences with my mother in law I do believe that life is sometimes prolonged beyond the point where it's tolerable. My mil suffered a dialysis crash and effectively died. She was shocked and resuscitated and spent the following 7 days in an agony of confusion as the hospital persisted In dialysing her. Her kidney function was in single figures. Dialysis was finally withdrawn and she spent a further 5 days drugged into unconsciousness as she was by then suffering from agitated terminal delirium. Hell for her and hell for the family. Why didn't they let her go when she collapsed? She was terminally ill.

Jane10 Sat 24-Jan-15 22:17:12

I quite agree re all this"passed on, away, over" etc. Makes me think (very irreverently of pass the parcel. I was always very impressed by the old Salvation army lady who when she died was announced as having been 'promoted to glory'! If you're going to use a euphemism then use a BIG one!

Ana Sat 24-Jan-15 22:23:35

'Passed over to the other side' is another one. Sounds as though they've been tossed over a hedge or something.

Juliette Sat 24-Jan-15 22:27:55

vegasmags Have heard older people say buried when referring to cremation. Think it's just a general term, certainly round here.

vegasmags Sat 24-Jan-15 22:40:39

So burial is a euphemism for cremation then? confused

Ana Sat 24-Jan-15 22:45:57

No, just another way of saying someone's died/dead in certain areas.

vampirequeen Sat 24-Jan-15 22:59:37

I don't want to be blunt about my son. It's hard enough to bear at times even though I lost him 30 years ago.

Euphemisms help me cope and I'm sure that's why some other people use them too.

I don't know if it's a local thing but when the hearse arrives at the house with the coffin we talk about the person arriving not the hearse or the funeral director We also keep our curtains closed until after the funeral. If it's a close neighbour we keep our curtains closed until after the cortege has left.

Anya Sat 24-Jan-15 23:17:18

What does it matter? Everyone knows what euphemisms like 'passed away' mean so where's the problem? hmm

Juliette Sat 24-Jan-15 23:30:16

vegasmags this is how a typical conversation goes.....
Neighbour...'did you know they've buried Peggy?
Me.....'Oh no, sorry about that'
Neighbour....They didn't take her Church, we went straight the Crem'
It isn't a euphemism it's just a general description covering every aspect of disposing of the body. If a flight of Angels had picked Peggy up and carried her away she would still have been buried. It's a regional thing. Think Amy Turtle from Crossroads saying it.

absent Sat 24-Jan-15 23:53:15

Out of idle curiosity, do people use "passed on", "gone to heaven", "gone to a better place", etc. just about other people who have died or do they also use such euphemisms for goldfish, cats and guinea pigs too?

Anya Sun 25-Jan-15 00:04:08

Mammalian pets are usually 'put to sleep', I don't know if that phrase is used for goldfish though, or birds or tortoises.

absent Sun 25-Jan-15 00:17:05

I thought "put to sleep" applied only in instances of euthanasia.

vampirequeen Sun 25-Jan-15 00:19:30

My goldfish were put to sleep by a vet when they started to rot alive. He said he'd never had to put fish to sleep before but he did it for me anyway because I couldn't bear to watch them literally breaking into pieces as they swam not could I simply flush them down the toilet whilst they were still alive.

Juliette Sun 25-Jan-15 00:27:57

Pets cross the 'Rainbow Bridge' after death. Google it for more information. That really is a euphemism but very comforting for lots of bereaved pet owners and who are we to judge what others take comfort from.

Jane10 Sun 25-Jan-15 08:13:42

Our vet told that old Fluffy was now "chasing mice over the fields of Ayrshire". We were mystified until she explained that there's a pet crematorium there. We were also mystified as he'd never to our certain knowledge chased a mouse in his life! Oh well she was being kind. We weren't heartbroken in his case as he wasn't exactly scythed down in his prime (unlike other ones we've had sadly)

Anya Sun 25-Jan-15 08:19:04

Absent I give up on you grin

janeainsworth Sun 25-Jan-15 08:32:50

DH and I usually use the term 'pop our clogs' to refer to our own deaths, hopefully some years hence.
But if I was talking about someone's death that had actually happened, I'd just use the d-word.

janeainsworth Sun 25-Jan-15 08:42:22

"For in that sleep of death what dreams may come,
When we have shuffled off this mortal coil,
Must give us pause"

Of course Shakespeare's euphemisms are quite acceptable smile

Jane10 Sun 25-Jan-15 09:01:56

My mums solicitor used to talk about when she became an estate. She now has. Alexander McCall Smiths characters talk about when people "become late". Very discreet!

Marmight Sun 25-Jan-15 09:03:54

An acquaintance announced her husband's death in the paper. " * * * * finally ran out of puff .........' . I quite liked that wink

Anniebach Sun 25-Jan-15 09:38:41

If passed away. Departed this life, Passed . Popped cloggs. Fell of perch etc is the choice then so be it, surely nothing to get knickers in a knot over

suzied Sun 25-Jan-15 09:57:32

Pop your clogs is a good one, what is the origins of that I wonder? Same as not putting shoes on the table I suppose. I wonder if all those pedants out there who always use the correct terms also use them for other bodily functions. Do you always ask your GC if they want to urinate? Or would you say do you want a wee/ pee/ use the toilet?

Jane10 Sun 25-Jan-15 10:33:30

Spend a penny of course!!