Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Grammar

(34 Posts)
Bellanonna Thu 23-Apr-15 12:09:39

A pedant posted somewhere, though I can't now find it, that she cringed when she saw " he texted me". I have always used this when referring to the past tense. It is very common, I know, to abbreviate it to " text" especially by younger people. I am now wondering whether it's "he texed" me? I have always been confident that I was right and other people wrong but have been slightly shaken by pedant's making her observation. Or is this an accepted form given the brief nature of text(ing) in general? I know it doesn't matter over much. I shall continue to say texted and cringe at "he text".

Bellanonna Wed 06-May-15 10:03:01

Surely there are nouns that are unarguably verbs too? I'm sure I remember being taught this at school over 60 ( gulp) years ago? What about walk, talk etc. we wouldn't say "I took a walk to school". And the Google verb is an example of where it would be clumsy to avoid "verbing" it ?

AshTree Wed 06-May-15 08:40:01

NotTooOld since the verb part of the compound word breakfast is 'break', we should be saying 'brokefast', but it does sound so terribly quaint to our modern ears, as to be almost laughable gringrin

Bellanonna Tue 05-May-15 21:05:34

And we probably all say googled...?

Wurzelernie Tue 05-May-15 17:58:10

Not the best ''texter'' in the world, am inclined to put wrong letters in and take too long, and as for predictive spelling, it drives me mad!

NotTooOld Tue 05-May-15 17:40:52

It's texted. Must be.

On the subject of using nouns as verbs, what about 'breakfasted'? Perhaps we should not be too pedantic about the habit as it has been around for a while - using nouns as verbs, that is, not eating breakfast. grin

Wheniwasyourage Mon 04-May-15 18:29:32

Another vote for "texted" here. DDIL uses "text" as the past tense and it always grates on me.

MamaCaz Mon 04-May-15 18:23:23

I also cringe at 'He text me'.

Several years ago, there was a discussion about this on the WordReference forum, and opinion was divided. I do remember reading one so-called academic link that promoted the use of 'text', but justifying it in a way that I didn't agree with - something about verbs that end in 't' forming their past tense with a 'd', (things like bend, lend, sent) if I remember rightly. I remember shouting at the screen, something along the lines of 'but text doesn't end in 'd'! angry

At the very least, I would have to insist on spelling it 'texed' (or something like that) in an attempt to make my brain accept it as a (remote) possibility!

I'm too old to change now anyway, so no matter what others say, I will continue to use 'texted' grin

AshTree Fri 24-Apr-15 10:08:49

Another pet hate of mine is using 'action' as a verb. It's very common in the business world, but it really grates with me. Why not use 'deal with', 'carry out', 'act on/upon' etc.

Juliette Fri 24-Apr-15 10:00:04

Also people who can't spell very well. blush

Juliette Fri 24-Apr-15 09:58:03

'Authoured' is another one that drives me mad.
When did people stop writing!

annodomini Fri 24-Apr-15 09:48:53

The other example of 'verbing' that I dislike but which seems to have become acceptable since 2012 is 'medal' used as a verb - 'x medalled twice at the Olymics'. It's just a lazy way of saying 'won a medal'.

Teetime Fri 24-Apr-15 08:44:20

Yes - I don't like ' he gifted me' either - 'a gift' is a noun. This 'verbing' sounds so clunky on the ear- yes I know clunky is probably not a word but it describes what I mean- awkward and just wrong.

AshTree Thu 23-Apr-15 19:02:02

When we use 'text' as a verb we are, according to this grammarian, 'verbing'.

Teetime Thu 23-Apr-15 16:44:31

I say 'I sent a text' or 'he sent me a text' never texted its sounds all wrong- is there a verb to text? or is a text a noun?

Tegan Thu 23-Apr-15 16:15:38

I don't know how to text [have never sent one]...

TriciaF Thu 23-Apr-15 16:06:36

Well I must be in a minority on here because I never text. We haven't got a gadget like that.

Ana Thu 23-Apr-15 15:49:38

I do that too, Ash Tree - I wish I didn't have such a compulsion to do so as it's so time-consuming! confused

Galen Thu 23-Apr-15 14:42:29

He sent me a text, surely?

Bellanonna Thu 23-Apr-15 14:28:21

Oh that's all very reassuring.
Tricia F we do make verbs from nouns, as in comb, brush etc, so there needs to be a word for texting methinks
And Ash Tree - yes, I tend to punctuate in texts too. If that makes us pedants, then so be it!
Thanks for all the comments

AshTree Thu 23-Apr-15 14:04:41

DD says 'he text me', but always agrees with me that it's grammatically incorrect. Difficult habit to break, I imagine, especially when you hear everyone else using that form. But I'm a pedant, so I always say 'he texted me'. For that matter, when I'm texting someone, I always use proper grammar and punctuation, including capital letters where needed. Plenty of people don't hmm

TriciaF Thu 23-Apr-15 13:56:21

To be really pedantic, text is a noun not a verb. That's why it's so difficult to conjugate.
Having said that it will probably get into the Oxford dictionary as a verb soon - just googled and it's already there!

Katek Thu 23-Apr-15 13:07:15

I get round it by saying 'I sent a text' as both text and texted sound wrong to me!

shysal Thu 23-Apr-15 13:06:07

'Texted' here too!

ninathenana Thu 23-Apr-15 13:02:04

Guilty of using text rather than texted even though I accept that texted is grammatically correct.
As it's not a word I would use in an important letter I don't care !

Juliette Thu 23-Apr-15 12:46:48

'I say 'texted' DD Insists it's 'text'. A minor disagreement often ensues.

I carry on in my own sweet way, just to annoy her really. grin