Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Could of should of would of

(153 Posts)
Lindill49 Sun 18-Sept-16 19:37:22

Doesn't it make you want to weep? Has this generation learned NO grammar at all?? Apostrophes? Don't get me started. Even on printed and laminated literature. And to cap it all in a printed book I'm reading at the moment. Am I a lone pedant?

Teddy123 Mon 19-Sept-16 15:34:52

I thought all three expressions should have (haha) used the word 'have' and not the word 'if'

Would have
Could have
Should have

I didn't read all the comments so apologies if this point has already been mentioned

If it hasn't .... It should HAVE been ?

Daddima Mon 19-Sept-16 15:33:37

The man who invented the cliffhanger has died. He.........

The man who invented anagrams has died. May he create a penis.

grammargran Mon 19-Sept-16 15:32:05

Just love this post and to know I'm not alone. My nom de plume Grammargran is a bit of a clue! Pet hate? 'Me and my friend .......... are doing so-and-so', 'me and my mum are going away .......... '. In fact, 'me and anything'! Complete change of tack, Daddima do you have Indian grandchildren? I do, and I'm a Nannima!

Daddima Mon 19-Sept-16 15:24:20

I trust Crazygrandma made the deliberate mistake to check we were paying attention.

Smurf44 Mon 19-Sept-16 15:19:12

Daddima. I hope you have been into the Newsagents and Cash Machine "shop" and told them about their errors. I find it REALLY annoying when till operators offer me one "pence" change. I have been known to tell them to look at the offending coin and read the "one penny" sign on the back!

Ana Mon 19-Sept-16 15:18:46

I think most of us accept that language evolves and that for some language and even writing is difficult, crazygran, but Pedants' Corner is just that - a place for pedants to gather for a moan and a grumble...wink

Helena1 Mon 19-Sept-16 15:10:04

A friend told me a lovely joke about predictive text: "The man who invented predictive text has died, his funfair's next Monkey..."

crazygranmda Mon 19-Sept-16 15:07:48

Whilst being a pedant, who cringes at all the errors mentioned, I also accept that language is continually developing. Think of all the words that are now in the dictionary which didn't even exist when most of us were young. I particularly hate seeing apostrophe's used incorrectly as it it so simple to teach people how to use them properly (ex teacher). However the true aim of language is to communicate. Having taught adults to read and worked with dyslexic students, I would be very careful about correcting written work, as I have no idea how long and what effort may have gone in to producing it. Grammar and spelling are very easy for some people and very hard for others. For some people, just putting pen to paper is a triumph.

Daddima Mon 19-Sept-16 14:58:56

Some crackers from Glasgow, Brighton, and my granddaughter's pyjamas.

lizzypopbottle Mon 19-Sept-16 14:51:28

The bold stars didn't work. ?

lizzypopbottle Mon 19-Sept-16 14:50:14

In a cafe or restaurant, it irritates me when people ask the waiter or waitress, "*Can I get...?*" No! You can't get it. The kitchen is off limits to you! The waiter/waitress will get it for you! Waiting staff don't ask what you want to get! They might ask what they can get for you or what you would like.

oldgoose Mon 19-Sept-16 14:36:34

makes me want to scrreeeeaaammmm.

Riverwalk Mon 19-Sept-16 14:30:34

Ha, bloody Ha, Peaseblossom that'll learn yah!

Kitspurr Mon 19-Sept-16 14:30:31

Has anyone noticed, that some TV presenters are now saying, for example, two hundred forty five, instead of, two hundred AND forty five?

Very American and very annoying.

Peaseblossom Mon 19-Sept-16 14:25:44

They need not I need! hmm

Peaseblossom Mon 19-Sept-16 14:24:43

I am always correcting people's grammatical and spelling mistakes, but then I get insulted and called the grammar police and told to "get a life". It doesn't stop me, I just tell people I need to go back to school. grin

Anne2108 Mon 19-Sept-16 14:24:13

I hate the habit of saying 'I went' when they mean 'I said' and in reply to 'How are you?, back comes the reply 'Good' instead of well. I won't get started on punctuation, spelling or pronunciation, such as broadcasters that say sikth instead of sixth and the sound t instead of to.

Kitspurr Mon 19-Sept-16 14:22:16

So right. I wanted to comment on this yesterday, but I held back.

I'm not sure that I can take seeing of used instead of 've, anymore. I want to scream every time I see this in print.

hallgreenmiss Mon 19-Sept-16 14:06:07

I agree that there is too much poor grammar especially on official notices, in broadcasting, and in books. To those who say it's a sign that language evolves I would say that is ignorance masquerading as progress.
In addition to those already mentioned my current hates are, confusion of incidences/incidents; diffuse/defuse.

Normanize9 Mon 19-Sept-16 14:02:45

Some pet hates:

1. Women are now referred to as 'Guys'[as are men, correctly]

2. The answer to 'How are you?' is now often 'Good'. Hope they are also 'well'!!

lizzypopbottle Mon 19-Sept-16 13:56:45

Some mistakes are 'typos', especially its and it's. It's easy to overlook that kind of thing when you get used to letting the word bank supply the word for you. Here in the North East, you might as well accept that you'll hear would of, could of and should of and see it written too. One that has always annoyed me is:

Teacher: "Where's Johnny?"
Pupil: "He's went to the toilet, Miss."

It's pointless to react to it up here. You're a lone voice. Correcting people, even in school, is only likely to get you an incredulous look. ?

chrislou Mon 19-Sept-16 13:53:44

I quite agree, grammar and poor speaking seem to be the way of things now but it isn't just the young who are guilty, I often look at the newspapers or listen to the TV and it is often just as bad there. What can we do except correct when we can.

Hattiehelga Mon 19-Sept-16 13:49:38

I get angry and frustrated at the constant misuse of grammar and the use of of instead of have is particularly annoying - where on earth did this come from ? Another pet hate is saying "in the morning" after am and in the afternoon/evening following pm. Grrrrrr !

eGJ Mon 19-Sept-16 13:46:55

And stain glass windows.................and the person who said it was way older than me!grin

gillyknits Mon 19-Sept-16 13:36:48

Oops-go so far !