Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Agiler?

(34 Posts)
Luckygirl Mon 02-Jan-17 10:54:59

I am playing online scrabble with my DD and wanted to send the word agiler - as in more agile. The programme will not let me send it (which is a pity as it carries loads-a-points!) as it says it is an invalid word. Wiktionary says it is valid.

Over to you!

grandtanteJE65 Sat 22-Jul-17 14:04:42

No, you did not make it up, Anya. That is the rule, except for some very ordinary words like "common" which grammarians still say can be commoner in the comparative and commonest in the superlative.

I never use these forms myself, and have suggested to all my students that they should not do so either, as most examiners, bosses etc. probably don't know that modern English grammar books still include them.

You are right too about adjectives ending on -y, which deals nicely with livelier, tidier, etc.

phoenix Tue 03-Jan-17 12:38:13

I play Words With Friends on line and am often surprised both by words that ARE allowed, as well as those that aren't!

Anya Tue 03-Jan-17 11:24:37

grin

Anya Tue 03-Jan-17 11:24:19

I concede defeat!

Anya Tue 03-Jan-17 11:24:00

Good point trisher

trisher Tue 03-Jan-17 11:20:45

Soory Anya missed that, but we also have quiet, quieter and quietest

Christinefrance Tue 03-Jan-17 09:16:25

Why do different word games allow or disallow certain words. No two games have the same rules.

Anya Mon 02-Jan-17 22:54:16

Indeed trisher I explained that words ending in 'y'' were the exception to the rule.

Jalima Mon 02-Jan-17 19:49:32

differenter?

Ana Mon 02-Jan-17 18:46:42

'differently'

Ana Mon 02-Jan-17 18:46:17

If you read Anya's post properly, trisher, you'll see that words ending in 'y' are treated differntly.

trisher Mon 02-Jan-17 18:41:22

The one syllable thing is a complete fallacy - what about lively, livelier liveliest ?

Untidy, untidier, untidiest? Must be loads more.

Ana Mon 02-Jan-17 18:09:52

Actually, that sentence sounds better if you say 'more agiler'...grin

Jalima Mon 02-Jan-17 18:08:16

ps - every day in every way I am going to become agiler

Jalima Mon 02-Jan-17 18:07:56

I don't think it is right, but it is going to be my new buzz word grin

rosesarered Mon 02-Jan-17 17:29:10

Not sure Lucky but it just doesn't sound right does it, agiler?

Luckygirl Mon 02-Jan-17 17:14:09

You and me both!

Jalima Mon 02-Jan-17 16:56:18

sorry, I could mean more agile

Whatever, I want to be it.

Jalima Mon 02-Jan-17 16:55:38

I want to be agiler so it must be correct

Luckygirl Mon 02-Jan-17 16:38:16

How do you get into that hilda? It is telling me I can only do it on my smartphone.

hildajenniJ Mon 02-Jan-17 16:09:26

I play Classic Words free against the computer. It has a dictionary option. You can choose fromm a selection, I chose the English/USA option so I can spell words either way eg color, colour. Have a look I your game settings and see if you have a dictionary selection .

Luckygirl Mon 02-Jan-17 15:59:29

And they let me have obit, but not obits -??? confused

I have conceded agiler - but won the game anyway!!

Anya Mon 02-Jan-17 14:31:07

That was the missing whatsit!

Anya Mon 02-Jan-17 14:30:06

'

Anya Mon 02-Jan-17 14:29:30

This is Pedants Corner not Soop's Kitchen, so if you can't stand the heat.....grin