Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

It's and its

(133 Posts)
Ana Thu 26-Jan-17 17:55:18

It's is short for 'it is'.

Its means belonging to or associated with.

That's all I wanted to say...smile

Esspee Fri 03-Feb-17 23:50:42

Have any of you noticed that according to Tesco there is "a shortage ON iceberg lettuce"? Grrrrrrrrrrr.

hildajenniJ Sat 04-Feb-17 08:45:44

[[https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1546358618712464&id=100000150212213 This is very funny]

hildajenniJ Sat 04-Feb-17 08:47:36

,This is very funny if I've pasted it properly.

Christinefrance Sat 04-Feb-17 08:55:28

Nfkdumpling I did wonder if using double negatives was a regional thing. My husband does it all the time and it drives me mad. He is Norfolk born and bred. smile

NfkDumpling Sat 04-Feb-17 09:02:53

Yes, double negatives is normal in this part of East Anglia rising to treble negative when more emphasis is required! I don't know if it's as bad in Suffolk.

annifrance Sat 04-Feb-17 09:30:21

Can I be uber pedantic about Gransnet please? It has always irritated me that the click on button is labelled Forums. It should be in the neuter third person plural latin. And now I can't remember if it should be fori or fora, but definitely not forums!

FarNorth Sat 04-Feb-17 09:33:02

Fora!
Yes, quick, get on to GNHQ to sort that out!

NfkDumpling Sat 04-Feb-17 09:33:51

It's been Anglacised! (Is that how you spell it? Should it have a capital A?)

FarNorth Sat 04-Feb-17 09:34:23

Another point from my long lost Latin classes - you can only have two alternatives, never three or more.

NickyD47 Sat 04-Feb-17 10:07:33

'Try and' really bothers me. You don't 'try and,' you 'TRY TO,'

seadragon Sat 04-Feb-17 11:48:18

"Show Greg and I" - would you say "Show I"? That's my major irritation.....but it has become the norm so now I must accept it and stop being a grammar snob?!

judypark Sat 04-Feb-17 15:31:48

My bugbear is the use by the media of the word released. Ie. "He has been released from hospital" You are either discharged or have left a hospital. Released indicates that someone has been forcibly restrained and has now been given their freedom. I'm turning into a "like" grumpy old woman - and don't even get me started on the word "Like".

Christinefrance Sat 04-Feb-17 17:10:10

No not grumpy at all Judy, just irritating to see words being so misused. How I hate to hear "like" every second word usually younger people.

sue01 Sat 04-Feb-17 17:31:10

It's adverbs with me.

Everyone kills them these days....

....even the BBC say "Wrap up warm".

AAAAAAAARRRRGH !!!

NannyKasey Sun 05-Feb-17 20:02:29

Oddoneout - I agree with you, the use of 'myself' and 'yourself' instead of 'I' 'me' and 'you' really pushes my buttons, so much so that I have to bite my tongue when my colleagues use it. hmm

Day6 Tue 07-Feb-17 23:40:48

I had an interesting conversation with a friend about the apostrophe to denote possession. Her example was about Janet. Janet had a dog and a ball. The dog also had a ball to play with.

So to write "Janet's ball" is OK. The ball belongs to Janet.

If Fido the dog becomes an IT....why don't we write "It's ball."? The ball belong to it. 'Fido' ball' is fine, but "It's ball" isn't.

Yes, our language is confusing.

She said it was confusing.

acanthus Thu 09-Feb-17 12:10:16

"It's ball" is not used because of possible confusion with the "it is" meaning, e.g. if you were to write "It's back" would you be referring to the back belonging to "It" or the fact that "It" had returned?

As a former teacher of grammar to speakers of other languages, I found that many of my students were better at English grammar than many native speakers who are either too dumb or too lazy to learn to speak or write the language of their birth properly.

Ana Thu 09-Feb-17 12:14:53

Its is the possessive form of it - nothing to do with possible confusion!

Mine
His
Hers
Its
Theirs

acanthus Thu 09-Feb-17 13:38:14

I'm well aware that 'its' is the possessive of 'it', but I was referring to the seeming illogicality as pointed out by Day6 and the underlying reason for the lack of an apostophe.

acanthus Thu 09-Feb-17 13:40:18

Typo (not a misspelt word!) - 'apostrophe'.blush

Ana Thu 09-Feb-17 13:41:20

You said:

"It's ball" is not used because of possible confusion with the "it is" meaning

I was just pointing out that that is not correct.

acanthus Thu 09-Feb-17 14:34:52

OK. In a purely logical language (which thank goodness English isn't), the pronoun 'it' would have an apostrophe 's' to denote the possessive, i.e. something belonging to 'it' as in "It's tail" (and yes, I know this is incorrect). So to avoid confusion, when writing 'it' in all its forms, our wise scribes in days of yore have left out the apostrophe, leaving it in only to show the shortened form of "it is" or "it has".

Greenfinch Thu 09-Feb-17 15:33:00

My DD corrected my use of comparative adverbs yesterday.I said that I could get home quicker by bus.She said don't you mean more quickly ? I realised that I did !

NanKate Thu 09-Feb-17 17:33:24

On the whole my grammar is quite good, however I always get muddled with past/passed.

Clear explanation required please.

Rinouchka Thu 09-Feb-17 18:49:30

Ok Kate, here goes:

passed= the past participle of "to pass" as in "We passed the house/test/salt/time" etc.

past:=
A) a preposition of time/direction etc.: in a past life, past address, past friend/husband/lover, etc.
B) an adverb: to look past/ go past/ work past retirement age, judge past the wrinkles, etc.!!

Hope that helps.