Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Ts

(62 Posts)
watermeadow Sun 02-Jul-23 13:21:03

Ts seem to be optional on radio. I keep shouting ScoTland or BriTish.
A newer irritation is hearing of sHtudents and other words which start with st having an h inserted. Whyever would anyone do this?

merlotgran Mon 17-Jul-23 11:02:32

Kate1949

Oh yes the 'sh' thing. Carol Vorderman describes things as 'shooj' instead of huge.

A lot of presenters can’t pronounce huge. If it’s not shooge it’s phewje.

Drives me mad

Katek Mon 17-Jul-23 11:07:46

The late, great Sean Connery famously spoke with the additional 'h' as in "shaken not shtirred' ! Bit of a trademark.

Doodledog Mon 17-Jul-23 11:20:36

Speaking of 'T's, I remember a Tongue Twister from my youth :

Betty Botter bought some butter. But, she said, the butter's bitter! If I put it in my batter it will make my batter bitter. But, a bit of better butter will make my batter better. So, she bought a bit of butter better than her bitter butter, And she put it in her batter, so the batter was not bitter.

I was taught a shorter version but couldn't remember it all, and Googled the version above. It was apparently written in 1899, so even then it seems that people were having Trouble with their 'T's grin

(I used to say that my children saved them up as teenagers so they had a good supply of 'tuts')

welbeck Mon 17-Jul-23 11:28:18

i like that bit of butter etc.
but i hadn't realised it was to emphasise the Ts; rather the difficulty of distinguishing correctly butter/bitter/batter/bit of !

Callistemon21 Mon 17-Jul-23 11:46:17

Sparklefizz

Alex Beresford may be from the Bristol area. When I moved here, I noticed everybody said Wells for Wales. Very confusing. They also add an "L" on words that don't have it, such as "Good IdeaL", "diarrhoeaL" etc.

Oh yes, he may be. DD and her friend met him years ago in Bristol.

I've noticed Bristolians say "I was led on the bed" too.

welbeck Mon 17-Jul-23 11:51:38

ie, too much lying around leads to heaviness.
maybe.

Mollygo Mon 17-Jul-23 12:05:58

Thanks for the reminder about Betty Botter. We used to sing it, but those who omit the *ts^ would just say
Be’y Bo’er bought some bu’er😁

Ali08 Mon 17-Jul-23 14:08:31

Somethink, anythink, haitch, dropping letters are all annoying to me.
I keep telling the children and grandchildren but I just get "Oh stop being such a grammar N@zi!"

Silvergirl Mon 17-Jul-23 17:42:42

Yes, where has this extra h come from? i.e. Shtrengh, shtrap,
shtride, etc. Most young people do it now. I absolutely hate it. It reminds me of drunken slurring. Are they being taught this at school?

eddiecat78 Mon 17-Jul-23 17:49:27

My first boyfriend, from Bucks, regularly put pe_rol in his car

MerylStreep Mon 17-Jul-23 17:54:58

Silvergirl

Yes, where has this extra h come from? i.e. Shtrengh, shtrap,
shtride, etc. Most young people do it now. I absolutely hate it. It reminds me of drunken slurring. Are they being taught this at school?

Some answers to your query from my favourite website.

www.quora.com/Why-do-I-pronounce-my-S-sounds-like-SH-sounds-and-what-is-the-cause

Lexisgranny Mon 17-Jul-23 18:07:43

Glottal stops don’t seem to be part of English Lessons today.

MiniMoon Mon 17-Jul-23 21:05:51

Argh! Amol Rajan just called H haitch.
I think I'll write to the BBC.

NanKate Mon 17-Jul-23 21:46:37

MiniMoon when you write to the BBC please could you ask for the weather person not to say ‘The remernants’ of a storm it is remnants! I shout at the tv when slovenly language is used.

Abitbarmy Mon 17-Jul-23 22:12:59

So now I’m laid in bed making all these weird sh sounds and saying words out loud after reading your link Meryl!

Callistemon21 Mon 17-Jul-23 22:17:16

MiniMoon

Argh! Amol Rajan just called H haitch.
I think I'll write to the BBC.

Yes.
I cringed.

It was like watching University Challenge speeded up - I was exhausted at the end of it!

Callistemon21 Mon 17-Jul-23 22:17:58

welbeck

ie, too much lying around leads to heaviness.
maybe.

😀

Romola Mon 17-Jul-23 22:27:12

German pronunciation has sh before t and p
Student, Spass, etc.
Maybe English is going that way.

yggdrasil Tue 18-Jul-23 07:45:29

What really annoys me is Alexander Armstrong talking of Joggraphy.

Athrawes Tue 18-Jul-23 10:34:05

I went to elocution lessons when I was small which I found fun but I don't think many young people attend such groups these days - if they even exist at all. It's helped me a lot though throughout my various careers - including public speaking.

kircubbin2000 Tue 18-Jul-23 13:40:03

Who or what has 'laid ' you in bed Abitbarmy?

Abitbarmy Tue 18-Jul-23 14:44:01

Sorry yes it should have read lying in bed ( I think!)

welbeck Tue 18-Jul-23 16:31:55

kircubbin2000

Who or what has 'laid ' you in bed Abitbarmy?

now this is beginning to sound like MN !
ahem, that's a very personal question.

Romola Tue 18-Jul-23 16:45:16

I can put up with glo-all stops etc better than with sins of syntax.
One that gets to me, and it's so common, is "between you and I" or "he gave it to my husband and I". Prepositions are followed by accusative pronouns in English!

Wyllow3 Tue 18-Jul-23 16:54:10

Blinko

Isn't it all about trying to sound 'down wiv da kids'? Street cred and all that nonsense.

Yes, as in your post and the O/P

It gets called "Mockney" as in mock cockney not just "down wid de yoof" but also "I'm not posh I talk like ordinary people".

That really annoys as its perfectly obvious what they're trying to do.