Um…I’m not a townie. I live in rural Scotland. 
I have had house cats for ten years now. They live happily indoors. My son in the US also has a house cat. They have foxes, raccoons and coyotes to contend with in his area which is why almost all cats are indoor pets.
As for things to try, keep your cat in. Build it a run outside. Call an animal protection agency to come and collect the feral cat. Trap the feral cat and rehome.
Btw, I didn’t call you evil. I said shooting a living being was evil.
Thank you Pipin for everything.



