Birthday expense.

Depends on how much you like her!!!

And whether you would go there anyway! Would your wife be upset not to go?

For the weekend ??? hubby and I can go abroad fully inclusive for a week for that,how many sisters are there and are they all taking their partners with them seems unreasonable to me for her to request can't she just have a get to-gether at her home or a local restaurant it seems a very needy request.I have 3 sisters and none of them would expect this.

Gosh, that seems excessive for a birthday! I think your SiL is the one being unreasonable, unless of course you are all laden down with wealth. I only have one sister but there is no way I could afford to do that, nor would she ask me to.

Do you have to travel abroad for this event? As glammanana says you can get a fully inclusive holiday for that price.

Is she expecting a present as well?

I'm afraid I'd tell her to 'have a nice time'. Unless as the others have said its something you might do anyway or your wife who thinks you are being unreasonable wants to pay for you both I think she's got a blooming cheek.

Is this the way you normally treat special birthdays in your family?

This seems excessive to me, would you normally spend so much on a present, if not could you find alternative accommodation in your price range and join the party for a birthday meal. When someone invites you to share a birthday, they usually arrange something they can afford and treat the people invited. We have been to some nice hotels for sisters special birthdays in the past, but only stayed one night and the birthday sister paid for a lovely evening meal, so we just paid our own b&b.

I think your sister in law has a bl**dy cheek! Hopefully, only eight people will go and then she'll have to pay for herself.

If she gets a free place, will that mean the reduction in cost is shared with everyone?
I hope so.

Indeed this does seem excessive. Is it a special birthday ? Have you spoken to the others who have been invited and found out how they feel. It's a lot of money for a weekend, must be a very good hotel.
As FarNorth says will the reduction be shared amongst you all ?

caretaker couldn't you just join them for dinner on one of the days or perhaps the hotel has some special offers you could take up- at this time of year they seem to have them especially between Xmas and NY.

I thought all special birthdays were the ones that ended with an "0". It really depends how well you get on and howuch spare cash you have.

Would she also expect a present?

We wouldn't pay that...no way! It's not that special a birthday.Yes, I think it's cheeky.

Money involved, most will not go unless she pays for all invited.

I fine home made, home cooked is the best remembered parties.

No you are not being unreasonable. What a cheek, unless you are all very well heeled, that is! But then, why should she want a freebee? I'm afraid that would seriously ruin a previously good relationship with my relatives. I've heard of bus trips or theatre deals where the organiser gets to go free but this is ridiculous

I think I would have a previous unbreakable engagement!

Also, be careful,as this could set a precedent for future 'special' birthdays in the family. Knock it on the head now

She's bang out of order. She wants you all to pay for an expensive weekend away so that she can have a freebie. What a cheek!

Presumably if you all go, so that she gets a freebie, then none of you need to buy her a present?
Maybe she'd rather have the memories of being surrounded by friends and family than a pile of tat to add to her clutter.

Gobsmacked, though can't help but admire her nerve. Talk about putting yourself first!

What a cheek. When it was my 60th DH took ten of us to the Lakes for the weekend, he paid for eveything, would not expect guests to finance birthday girl's stay.

Unreasonable unless you are all rich. In any case the total cost should be shared equally among everyone inc sister.

Plus Drinks! Will she be paying for the drinks?
Depends on your economic situation and did she discuss it with your wife first.