I am posting this here as I want to get a “view from the other side”.
I nearly posted this on mumsnet but knew I would get very different advice. It seems on there most people side with the children/IL’s and on here most people side with the GP’s.
Please can someone give me some sensible, mature advice about this situation without bias?
Firstly and sadly, my DP are no longer here. They were wonderful, involved GP’s and we all miss them dearly.
Secondly, I have always wanted and tried to include my IL’s in the GC’s lives.
My MIL is alone and was annoyed when her last remaining child got married and left her alone and she has never welcomed their spouse because of this.(She hasn't been welcoming to me either!)
Now the above mentioned sibling is treated like a golden child who can do no wrong. MIL constantly tells us how wonderful this sibling is and appears very uninterested in anything we have to say. If our children tell her some good news or some achievement they have made. The most she will say is “that’s nice” then follow it with a story about how one of her other GC’s has done better than that!
I can’t tell you how much this hurts to see their faces as she brushes them away all the time.
She refuses to do anything for us/visit us herself/put things in the post. She blames us when SHE hasn’t bought our children presents at Easter/Christmas/Birthday,
“As there was no point getting them anything as I wasn’t sure I would see them”!
She always does see them before these occasions as we take the DC's and gifts for her!
She always manages to get her other GC gifts though!
We have stopped phoning her as it has been so one sided for years now. She used to call DW once a week but it dwindled to only when she wanted something. Whenever we call her she talks about her other child and GC’s or herself and her constant "illnesses"-she is never not ‘ill’ and there is always drama that turns out to be nothing. I think she is lonely and craving attention. She doesn’t have anything else to talk about-she doesn’t really see many people and I do feel sorry for her but her attitude lately is changing all that. I cannot be tolerant of someone who is hurting my family so much.
I am grieving for my DP’s and they were so good, it just highlights all her misgivings. She didn’t even try to help us out when we lost them.
My DW has decided she doesn’t want any more to do with her mother. I am really worried about this and would like to sort it out, but I can’t see how and I totally understand why she wants to distance herself. Every contact with MIL makes us unhappy.
The straw that broke the camel’s back was escalation of requests to DW to help her sibling. Initially it was ridiculous stuff that her sib was more than capable of doing for themselves but has increased now to money. Her sibling earns more than her but wastes her money on designer clothes/holidays/drinking/second home.
We do not care how they spend their money. It has nothing to do with us.
We are more sensible (boring, if you like) but are comfortable because of this. We live within our means but do not have extra. Because we appear to have a larger house (but only one!), they believe we have more money and therefore somehow feel entitled to it!
Her sibling TOLD us we would have to help out with repayments on their mortgage on their SECOND home. We refused. We were quite insulted that they would ask us to risk our finances like this but did not say this to them(they also have a bad credit rating and owe other people money).
We tried to be mature and continue a relationship with them but they were very angry and refused to talk to us any more!
So then a rift began.
MIL knew there were problems between the sibs but never asked what was going on. Then she had the cheek to try and persuade my DW to heal the rift, trying to emotionally blackmail her that the golden child was upset and how much it was hurting them!
Yet she didn’t want to know anything about why the rift happened, treating my DW as if it was all her fault and that she needed a telling off as if she were a child!
MIL is siding with her other child and trying to cut us out-she now asks to see our DC’s without us and asks to take them to the other siblings house!
"no need for you to come..."
She has also started ignoring us but sending cards through the post to our DC’s!
At one point she even said to me
”They will have to speak to each other one day”.
Obviously meaning her funeral. Why does she think that? My DW is so hurt that she says she wouldn’t go anyway and never wants to see her again. How sad- emotionally blackmailing her child is really not going to work...she is past caring!
DW said her mother is not acting like a mother to her, only to her sibling.
I do not know what to do. Our DC’s will have no GP’s if this continues but I’m not sure if I agree with my DW now in that having no GP is better than our DC's and us being treated like dirt.
DW wishes she had broken contact with her DM and her sib before the GC’s were born.
What would you do? Why is the MIL being so cruel? She’s not going to change is she? and DW doesn’t want me to tell her DM that she is hurt.
I know a lot of people on these boards have had their DC cut them off. If you knew the reason your DC were unhappy with you and you had done something like this, would you want to know? would you try and put it right or am I just wasting my time?
I want all of us to have a good relationship. I want MIL to act fairly and stop trying to force us to do unacceptable things for her other child (why is she doing this?) Is any of this possible?
Thank you for reading if you got this far...
Does Israel want full scale war in the Middle East?
Well, well. Is it ‘global warming’ or ‘cloud seeding’?
To think that London, or anywhere else for that matter, does not belong to any one demographic