Gransnet forums

Relationships

Only son syndrome?

(67 Posts)
Synonymous Sun 08-Apr-18 22:53:48

What is this so called "Only son syndrome" for goodness sake? People are people with all the character flaws entailed in being human in a fallen world. Those flaws will show in a myriad of ways depending on the circumstances. Perhaps one of those flaws could well be never seeing the good in anyone.

Only one of my children is a son and he is married to the most wonderful young woman who is a good and loyal wife, a super mum and a fabulous DDIL. We are blessed to have her and love her to bits and our son is one of the most fortunate of men.

MissAdventure Sun 08-Apr-18 22:33:58

My Nan used to come round once a week, and sit with her coat on, clutching her handbag like a shield.
The only good she could find to say about my mum was that she "had a good pair of legs".
grin

sparkly1000 Sun 08-Apr-18 22:29:57

Oh my goodness Hm999, but I know the feeling. I too was the bees knees for 22 years. When my youngest of 3 children was 14, I told MIL that I had decided to return to University to do a degree in nursing.
DH had just purchased and was running his own printing company,
I was told that I was a disloyal wife and "who was going to clean his factory's toilets every day"?
Fast forward 22 years, I completed my course,, met a wonderful man 17 years my junior. We are still very happily together.

Hm999 Sun 08-Apr-18 21:00:12

I adore my DIL.
My MIL (mother of 1 son and 1 daughter) liked me at first, then didn't like me once we got married, liked me once I produced grandchildren, adored me when she was widowed 'You're like a daughter to me', and when I was divorced had no contact with me or the children.
I have no idea if she knows she is a great-grandma.

Eglantine21 Sun 08-Apr-18 17:35:22

From my observations many of those who complain of a controlling SIL or DIL are themselves controlling people who resent that they have lost control of their children to another person.

As far as the daughter or son is concerned they have simply swapped one controlling relationship for another. It's what they're used to and often feel comfortable with.

M0nica Sun 08-Apr-18 17:30:05

At the end of the day, people are people. Some are inherently nice and pleasant and others are unpleasant. This will apply whether they are DMs, MiLs or neither.

paddyann Sun 08-Apr-18 17:01:53

maybe some of those MIL should think that THEY raised these sons who married the "awful" DIL.Maybe they didn't do as good a job as they thought if their sons hudgement is so bad .

TwiceAsNice Sun 08-Apr-18 16:53:06

My MIL was a pain to me although she was nice to the grandchildren when they were small but nasty tongued to them when they were teenagers/older when she thought they didn't see her enough . Her son was an only child and although I tried hard with my marriage I divorced her son eventually because he was abusive. My FIL however was always wonderful to me saying when we got married he'd always wanted a daughter and now he had one.

M0nica Sun 08-Apr-18 16:08:46

Well, I married an only child and got the gentlest, kindest and most loving of MiL's as a result.

I believe if DH had told her when he was 16 that he was emigrating to Australia she would have helped him achieve his ambition and only cried when he had gone.

She was a lovely, lovely lady and I consider myself very fortunate to have had her as my MiL

annodomini Sun 08-Apr-18 16:06:54

I'm not the mother of an only son - I have two - but the daughter of an only son. I know that my poor mum was never good enough for my GM, her MiL. He was a graduate and very clever; she was 'only' a qualified hairdresser. They were a happy and devoted couple for 43 years, until my mum died at 73. I don't think granny ever really forgave her for having 3 daughters and no sons, though her own daughter was in the same boat!

midgey Sun 08-Apr-18 15:43:00

My mother in law, who could be evil or lovely, once told me that nobody was good enough for her boys. I rather admired her honesty!

Grannyknot Sun 08-Apr-18 15:40:53

Er sometimes an only son marries the youngest princess in a family of all daughters and discovers that no one has ever said "no" to her...

lemongrove Sun 08-Apr-18 15:32:58

I think that if you only have one child, then you probably invest a lot more sentimental feelings in them ( I understand why) but even if you have more than one, a lot of mothers do seem to favour sons more than daughters when it comes to marriage.

jenpax Sun 08-Apr-18 15:30:48

I was married to the eldest of 3 DS and not my Mil’s favourite even? but she hated me from day one. I can honestly say that I tried hard to please her (at first) but she constantly sniped and made disparaging comments even going so far as to ring my own parents to try and run me down? Her issue was essentially that she disapproved of me continuing my degree, subsequent law qualifications and finally my career. Her stated view was that a wife’s place was in the home and that a wife should “obey” her husband! Her other objection was that I wore make up (thereby making me a floozy) and that I prepared spicy food and exotic cuisine?
In her opinion my DH should divorce me and find a nice homely girl she approved of (something she actually said) fortunately my DH was a modern man and not stuck in a previous generation so he supported me. Her venom though was boundless she tried getting me dismissed from my first firm by calling and saying I was of bad character and would bring them into disrepute and later called our health visitor to say I was an unfit parent and that she wanted to apply to have the children live with her! None of this obviously worked and in the end I had nothing to do with her and did not see her for over 20 years before she died
I believe she had a poor relationship with son number 2’s wife during their short lived marriage but got on OK with DIL of 3rd son who married quite late. Maybe she had learned her lesson by then?

Granny23 Sun 08-Apr-18 15:11:42

Parents should also warn their daughters about the pitfalls of marrying only sons. I did and got the MIL from Hell, although I must say he was worth it.

Only joking grin I know many wives to only sons who get on extremely well with their MILs (or should that be MsIL?)

Situpstraight Sun 08-Apr-18 14:59:12

The poor boys, the minute their mothers turn their backs, off they go and find the most spiteful, controlling and jealous girlfriend they can find.

And then they marry her!

I’m surprised the mothers let the boys out after reading some of the threads on GN.

My mother was the same with my brother though and his wife seemed fine to me, but according to DM no one could look after him the way she did!

sparkly1000 Sun 08-Apr-18 14:55:12

Having been a member for many years ( just changed user name) I am struck by the amount of mothers whose precious only sons are married to mentally unbalanced, selfish, controlling and terrible women.
I know the majority of members seem to jog along no problems with their DILs but there is a hard core of those who appear to accuse DILs of "kidnapping" and " brainwashing" their innocent little boys.
What do others think?