Gransnet forums

Relationships

He needs to ask his adult children before proposal!

(57 Posts)
Ffoxglove Mon 14-Mar-22 23:46:26

We are going away soon, he said he needed to see his daughter before. I asked why as he doesn't see her that often he said well we are going a long way and you never know what might happen! Then I said so you are going all the way there I'm just wondering why you need to do that, are you giving her money? He said no then as he walked away said I might even be asking her if it's ok to ask you to marry me. Now I know he plans to do this and I guess a moment in a nice place makes sense but ...I don't like the idea he needs their approval and permission before. What if they said no would be change his plans? Seems odd to me, what do you think?

Esspee Fri 20-May-22 18:38:52

It’s two months since the OP went on holiday and she never let us know if he did propose so there’s really no point in continuing to give advice.

Katie59 Fri 20-May-22 19:22:04

It can be a serious issue involving second relationships including mine.

OH is a widower with 3 daughters, a large extended family, and considerable property, within a few weeks of us dating he made it clear that marriage was not an option. Everyone knows what the relationship is and have accepted me without reservation, not as his wife’s replacement but as dads companion. With no worries about me stealing their inheritance.

The main attraction is that I am valued as a partner and we have many joint interests and similar values. Every relationship different and in many cases it is the woman who has the wealth, whatever it is make sure you are getting a good deal out of living together.

Katie59 Fri 20-May-22 19:26:13

Disregard above it’s been so long I forgot I responded.

Thistlelass Sun 05-Jun-22 00:57:47

In the event I were likely to remarry in the future, my choice would be for my 'intended' to quietly make one of my children aware he was going to propose. I see nothing strange in it.

Redhead56 Sun 05-Jun-22 10:30:58

You have the property which you want to protect for your grown children. Your partner has debts and no property to speak of by the sounds of it. He is going to basically ask his daughters opinion of you uniting in marriage. Have you asked your GC their opinion of marriage to your partner just curious.
I would have had my will sorted out and personally I would leave the marriage idea for now. I would see how your relationship progresses as there appears to be trust issues which would make me wary.

NotSpaghetti Sun 05-Jun-22 11:11:20

I assumed the same as Yoga:
I would not have taken that to him going to ask permission but rather to let his daughter know in person, particularly if her mother is deceased.
I thought that he was just trying to keep the daughter in the loop.