Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

Male infant circumcision is declared illegal in Germany.

(109 Posts)
johanna Fri 29-Jun-12 17:35:32

anagram grin
Here is my take on this news.
Jewish people have lived in Germany since before the Middle Ages.
The Muslims have not.
And maybe this is a stealth attack on the Muslims?

Anyway how do you think our wonderful ethnic neighbourhoods have received this news?.....
From a personal point of view , it does not sit easy with me that Germany, with her WWII history should come up with this.

Greatnan Fri 29-Jun-12 17:24:29

I am all for religious freedom, but the infants do not have the choice - it is simply assault and abuse. The claim that circumcised men have less risk of contracting HIV/Aids has now been disputed, because so many circumcised men think they do not need to use a condom.

absentgrana Fri 29-Jun-12 17:17:41

Islam, too, Anagram.

Anagram Fri 29-Jun-12 16:31:11

I dare say a lot of parents will just have it done to their sons illegally - it's a very big thing (unfortunate turn of phrase, perhaps!) in the Jewish religion, especially.

Bags Fri 29-Jun-12 16:28:24

Good news. About time too. Is Germany the first country to do this?

whitewave Fri 29-Jun-12 16:14:54

The human right issue for the parent to be allowed to practise a religion of choice will come head to head with the right for the child to give consent to what amounts to a non-medical procedure. In my book the person who is suffering the precedure wins every time. When the child reaches the age of consent then he/she can decide whether circumcision is right for him/herself.

Mishap Fri 29-Jun-12 14:22:11

Hooray! - well done Germany! Time for UK to follow suit; or better still an EU directive.

This is long overdue.

absentgrana Fri 29-Jun-12 13:56:19

Physical abuse. There will be uproar about religious persecution and the human right to practise a religion of choice.

I hope that so-called female circumcision is already against the law.

Greatnan Fri 29-Jun-12 13:54:28

Non-medical circumcision of minors has been declared to be against the law in Germany.