Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

Grr................. Anne Atkins

(168 Posts)
Greatnan Tue 24-Jul-12 07:50:14

Why is this woman allowed to lecture us on Thought for the Day? She is so damned patronising and her only qualifications appears to be that she is married to a vicar. Her voice makes me want to scream.

glammanana Tue 24-Jul-12 10:00:59

I think greatnan meant "Anne Atkins" has "got religion".

Bags Tue 24-Jul-12 10:01:06

The grin was for when's space launch.

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 10:01:19

Newsflash Greatnan. Wars are very damaging to family relationships.

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 10:02:18

See. I still haven't chilled!

I'm off to the flippin' sunshine, while we've got it! grin

Anagram Tue 24-Jul-12 10:06:09

Anne Atkins also pontificates a lot on the subject of child-rearing. Of course, her family is perfect....

Nonu Tue 24-Jul-12 10:12:16

Haven"t heard of this woman at all , don"t even what station she is on , doesn"t seem too popular though

FlicketyB Tue 24-Jul-12 11:14:48

She was reporting some research which studied the relationship of babies of both sexes with their fathers during the first six months of life. This showed that boys who had loving and involved fathers during this short period at the start of their lives grew up to be less violent than boys whose fathers were less involved with them at this early stage.

I cannot remember all the details but the research was undertaken by a deparment of psychology at auniversity, I think, in the Netherlands and sample sizes and length of study seemed reasonable.

The research was not undertaken under any kind of religious auspices and as I said dealt only with the father's interaction with his son in the first six months.

whenim64 Tue 24-Jul-12 11:40:11

....so it was about both boys and girls who spent their first few months with 'detached' biological fathers, as opposed to 'attached' fathers who undertook meaningful care? Hmmmm...!

Who's first with all the 'buts?' After you..... grin

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 13:21:22

I do thank the Lord for my son-in-law (grandsons' dad). smile

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 13:22:51

Thoug, DGS1 did whack that football very hard at my head. confused grin

Greatnan Tue 24-Jul-12 13:56:13

Well, I suppose it is one more way to villify mothers who are deserted by the biological father.

AlisonMA Tue 24-Jul-12 16:27:34

jo4 I read it that way too!

AlisonMA Tue 24-Jul-12 16:33:17

Jingle, you appear to be spoiling for a fight - chill out, woman! - Isn't that a bit patronising?

I think you might need to refine your sense of humour a bit. - Just because someone doesn't see things the way you do surely doesn't mean you need to criticise their sense of humour.

Seems to me it's the religiacs who protest too much and the rest of us just take the piss. - I think it is cruel to 'take the piss' out of people who have different beliefs from you.

Now I realise that I will be open to attack here but i still don't understand why people feel it necessary to be so unpleasant.

whenim64 Tue 24-Jul-12 16:42:12

Bit of stirring going on, eh?

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 16:46:00

Anyway, I don't want to be chilled.

Sounds really boring.

soop Tue 24-Jul-12 16:46:15

Rather than submit my opinion on the matter [such as it is] I shall turn around and go elsewhere. The vibes are threatening to give me a migrane. hmm

whenim64 Tue 24-Jul-12 16:49:25

Same here. It gets too much when the bickering starts.

soop Tue 24-Jul-12 16:49:54

when wink

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 17:00:33

Am I being told off here? confused

Alison the first line of your post was a quote from someone else's previous post, wasn't it?

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 17:02:06

Oh I'm leaving this one. Shall we just have cosy little group hugs all round? confused

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 17:06:00

Just to make my position quite clear on the actual subject though, I really do believe a child's biological father is always going to be an extremely important person in his or her life. I think it is a disaster when this does not or cannot come about. I believe also that the genetic pool comes into play inasmuch as it helps to provide an empathetic relationship.

I am not stirring there. Just putting my honestly held opinion.

Anagram Tue 24-Jul-12 17:06:40

I blame that Anne Atkins! hmm

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 17:07:04

And I can't stand these silly winkings at each other!

Pathetic!

Anagram Tue 24-Jul-12 17:08:12

I wasn't winking at anyone - just hmm-ing!

JO4 Tue 24-Jul-12 17:08:15

I think AlisonMA's post could have been misunderstood.