Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

Grr................. Anne Atkins

(168 Posts)
Greatnan Tue 24-Jul-12 07:50:14

Why is this woman allowed to lecture us on Thought for the Day? She is so damned patronising and her only qualifications appears to be that she is married to a vicar. Her voice makes me want to scream.

nightowl Tue 24-Jul-12 19:44:53

That's Ann Leslie merlotgran not you! Well not so early in the evening anyway wink

Anagram Tue 24-Jul-12 19:54:50

I'll never forget watching her on election night - I think she really was drunk! She was decidedly dishevelled and almost incoherent by the time I stopped watching...(not you, Merlot!)

merlotgran Tue 24-Jul-12 20:00:38

I'm usually dishevelled and inoherent by the end of election night, Anagram. Jeremy Vine often has me losing the will to live hmm

JessM Tue 24-Jul-12 20:15:20

Ann Atkins on Radio 4 Thought for the Day slot.
I agree. Pompous.
Sad that the sweet rabbi Blue has pretty much retired. I remember where I was when he "came out" on Thought for the Day. Sigh. They have failed to find anyone else to come even close.

jeni Tue 24-Jul-12 20:41:07

He was great!

Greatnan Tue 24-Jul-12 22:03:36

Yes, I always enjoyed his little chuckles! He has been quite ill for some time.

kittylester Wed 25-Jul-12 09:34:34

I really dislike watching Ann Leslie, she seems so self important nowadays.

I have followed Ann Atkins for ages, I think she used to write a column in a woman's magazine, and have always felt quite an affinity with her. She has lots of children, dogs and admits to enjoying a drink (she could be my twin grin!!) and I have always found her to be honest about her family problems, some of them.

Did we ever get a [ducksbehindthesofa] emoticon?

Anagram Wed 25-Jul-12 10:43:51

No we didn't, kittlester, but bravo for giving your honest opinion!
Some of her articles contain a lot of common sense; I think it's just her slightly old-fashioned and dare I say smug attitude that irritates me sometimes.

JO4 Wed 25-Jul-12 11:27:41

If anyone is still interested in listening to it, here is the item

It's actually about a lot more than biological fathers! (I was half asleep when I heard it grin)

Greatnan Wed 25-Jul-12 13:18:10

Kittylester - no need to duck, all shades of opinion are welcomed (even those with which we don't agree) and we will defend to the death your right to hold them. smile

kittylester Wed 25-Jul-12 14:32:35

Thank you Greatnan smile!

JessM Wed 25-Jul-12 16:33:38

It is perhaps as much her tone of voice as what she says?

Greatnan Wed 25-Jul-12 16:36:20

It is both for me, Jess. She always sounds like a headmistress giving the whole school a good telling-off and I don't like her brand of Christianity.

Greatnan Wed 25-Jul-12 16:42:49

Having read the text (Thank you, jingle) I do agree with much of what she says, apart from 'Not God’s punishment for sin, but the inevitable consequence of it'- why should the woman be subjugated by the man because they had both sinned?

Bags Wed 25-Jul-12 16:50:54

I read it too. Thanks for the link, jings. She says at one point: " Judeo-Christian Scripture is full of God’s bias to the vulnerable: the poor, the dispossessed, the underclass" which may well be true, but she omits to mention that the same scripture is also full of stories which suggest the same God's bias towards the powerful, namely himself. Not to mention all the cruelty, primitive tribalism and misogyny hmm

However, some of what she says is worthy (used that word because 'interesting' didn't seem quite right; substitutions welcome).

JO4 Wed 25-Jul-12 17:22:44

Give me one story from the bible which shows God as having a bias towards powerful people.

He's not powerful himself either. If he ever thought he was he must have given that one up long ago.

jeni Wed 25-Jul-12 17:31:48

Render unto Caesar?

Anagram Wed 25-Jul-12 17:33:34

Wasn't that just 'Pay your taxes'?

Nonu Wed 25-Jul-12 17:34:39

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO !

Bags Wed 25-Jul-12 17:46:19

Well, start with the Story of the ten commandments. The first four (if I remember rightly without looking them up) are about himself and how you must honour and love him above all others. If that's not a power freak talking, what is? Then, who was it who turned Job's wife to salt for some minor misdemeanour? I can check out some more if you like.

Bags Wed 25-Jul-12 17:46:49

smiling at your post nonu.

Nonu Wed 25-Jul-12 17:51:49

I KNOW in a nice way , chuck

Anagram Wed 25-Jul-12 17:52:41

I don't understand all those Os....confused

Nonu Wed 25-Jul-12 18:04:48

OOOOO , less now grin

Anagram Wed 25-Jul-12 18:13:07

Still don't get it (if it's supposed to be Oooh! - why?). But as long as it means something to someone.....
[huffy emoticon]