Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

Religion can be good for your mental health

(210 Posts)
Lilygran Thu 23-Aug-12 20:38:28

The Daily Telegraph reports today on research carried out by Prof Dan Cohen at the University of Missouri. They have found that the mental health of people recovering from different medical conditions 'appears to be related to positive spiritual beliefs and especially congregational support and spiritual interventions (prayer)'. It doesn't seem to matter which religion people believe in since they got similar results with Buddhists, Muslims, Jews, Catholics and Protestants.

Anagram Sat 25-Aug-12 16:53:50

Rather that than have my choice of words mocked. I made an observation, that's all. I'll leave you to it.

Greatnan Sat 25-Aug-12 16:53:58

Not me, jingle, I have no jobs waiting to be done - well, except all the books that are waiting to be read!

JO4 Sat 25-Aug-12 16:59:40

The jobs are of my own making. For example, I have to make a madeira cake as I want to eat madeira cake! grin

Greatnan Sat 25-Aug-12 17:00:40

That doesn't count as a job - just foreplay.

JO4 Sat 25-Aug-12 17:03:54

grin

I would get DD to make it for me but she is at the moment travelling on a train from Paris to Milan via Switzerland. (slightly worried although she is a very grown up DD now!)

JessM Sat 25-Aug-12 17:45:56

I've met more than a few people over the years that felt their early experiences with the likes of the Christian Brothers had a detrimental effect on their mental health...

AlisonMA Sun 26-Aug-12 10:29:31

It seems a lot of people who went to RC schools rebelled against their religion. Perhaps the way they were treated when young has put them off for life.

Greatnan Sun 26-Aug-12 11:19:36

It wasn't the cruelty, snobbery and hypocrisy that I witnessed that made me an atheist - it was thinking, reading and studying and coming to the conclusion that there was absolutely no proof of the existence of any supernatural being.

Lilygran Sun 26-Aug-12 11:23:02

No, of course there isn't any proof! That's why it's called faith!

Greatnan Sun 26-Aug-12 11:47:35

Er....yes, I did realise that, Lily! And I have none. However, I was reading The Catholic Herald this morning and one catholic was insisting that atheists were stupid because there is so much evidence for the existence of his particular god, so not everybody realises it.

JO4 Sun 26-Aug-12 11:49:16

I was going to say the same thing lilygran, but I aint sticking my neck out anymore! grin

JO4 Sun 26-Aug-12 11:50:03

(Sorry God)

Greatnan Sun 26-Aug-12 11:52:49

Jingle, what on earth do you mean? I am only stating my beliefs and you are quite free to state yours. You are usually more than capable of doing just that.

JO4 Sun 26-Aug-12 12:00:45

Only joking Greatnan grin

love you x

Greatnan Sun 26-Aug-12 12:06:35

That's OK then - I wouldn't like to upset you.

JO4 Sun 26-Aug-12 12:14:40

You haven't. smile

Mishap Sun 26-Aug-12 12:41:30

I am entirely at peace with the "not knowing" and with my absence of faith in the supernatural. I am free to concentrate on trying to lead as honest and helpful life as I am able without having to listen to the dictates of hierarchical archaic pronouncements.

I am entirely happy with the fact that many of my friends have a religious faith - no problem there - we get on fine and respect each others' views.

Religions deal in fundamentals and have a natural tendency towards fundamentalism and control - no religion is exempt from this, either now or historically. Better in my view to concentrate on trying to lead a good life.

And after life? - I guess our atoms just return to the cosmic soup whence they came. Who knows?

Charlotta Sun 26-Aug-12 22:17:43

Religion is a comfort to a lot of people but really I wonder how can it be a comfort to know your soul whatever or wherever that is, will go on for ever. It fills me with unease.
Athiest or humanist? Most of them contribute a lot to society.

I once helped at a second hand cum jumble sale and the vicar first thanked God that no one had fallen off a ladder. I wondered that in this time of world crisis, starvation, wars and persicutions, how God had time to watch that Joe Bloggs didn't fall off a ladder. I was the only one of course that thought his prayers were over simple but then that is what these religious people want.
If it makes then happy......

gramps Sun 26-Aug-12 23:26:29

The comfort of a hug given to a person who is unwell or upset is well recognised. We all need to know that we are "loved", whether by a Group or ln a one to one situation.

Pain is something which needs plenty of loving support, plus physical contact, such as hand holding, or a gentle hug! Just by being close is often enough. Knowing that somebody cares!

If somebody has a positive attitude this will reinforce the healing process, whether given by medical or any other form of treatment.

Everybody comes to the end of their journey of life. Positivity will not cure, but does help the process of "passing" from this existence!

I have not mentioned Religion, as we all have our own ideas on that, and we all have freewill on that subject! hmm

Bags Mon 27-Aug-12 06:27:52

gramps smile

Greatnan Mon 27-Aug-12 06:56:00

Thank you , Gramps, what a nice, sensible, post. It seems we are all in agreement that being part of any supportive network is beneficial for our physical as well as our emotional wellbeing.

NfkDumpling Mon 27-Aug-12 07:54:57

Lovely post Gramps. In other words 'love is all you need'! You could apply for a research grant to expand and prove this!

Littlenellie Mon 27-Aug-12 09:54:24

gramps that is a really special post xxxxxlove nellie

AlisonMA Mon 27-Aug-12 10:09:12

gramps lovely post especially as there was only one 'I' in there. You are thinking of us all and not yourself.

Lilygran Mon 27-Aug-12 10:42:39

Gramps sunshine