Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

From the Humanist Association - discuss

(435 Posts)
granjura Tue 12-Jan-16 15:25:13

The latest figures show that 98.6% of us don't attend church services.

And yet the Church of England retains established status, legal exemptions from the Equality Act and Human Rights Act, a 26-seat bloc vote in the House of Lords, and control of roughly a third of schools in England.

Despite what some politicians try to tell us, Britain is not a 'Christian country', and it's high time we broke our formal links with the Church and fully embraced the principles of secularism and equality as guarantors of freedom for everyone, regardless of religion or belief.

Justin Welby's quotation in this article is quite something, too. 'The culture has become anti-Christian, whether it is on matters of sexual morality, or the care for people at the beginning or the end of life,' he told the meeting in Canterbury, alluding disdainfully to our tolerant liberal society's progressive attitudes to same-sex relationships, assisted dying, and abortion.

granjura Tue 19-Jan-16 21:19:51

I believe you may have missed this post on Friday 16.46:

Just this week the Church of England has published new figures showing that weekly attendance continues to fall, now representing just 1.5% of the population as a whole – and for the first time ever, fewer people attend church each week than children attend Anglican worship each day in state-funded Church of England schools.

granjura Tue 19-Jan-16 21:33:24

However, the RC in particular should be quite pleased about this:

Mass migration of Christians to Britain from countries such as Poland and Romania is among the factors helping to stem the decline in church attendance, according to new figures.

granjura Tue 19-Jan-16 21:38:25

However (both sources the Gardian- of course ;) ):

In 2013, there were 5.4 million church members in the UK, 10% of the adult population, taken as 15 and over, 300,000 fewer than five years previously in 2008, when it was 12%. It is likely to continue to decline at about the same rate for the next 12 years, reaching 9% by 2020 and 8% by 2025, if present trends continue.

Elegran Tue 19-Jan-16 21:38:35

alea When did the facts keep anyone from indulging in a good rant argument?

Anniebach Tue 19-Jan-16 21:41:46

Granjura, thank you for replying, with respect there is no such thing as a a psalm which is not toooo religious and I am not silly or judging , you did say they asked for no religion now this has become not tooooo religious . I am puzzled by your views on this thread sorry

Penstemmon Tue 19-Jan-16 21:44:04

Alea I agree that arguments that are based on data need to be accurate and up to date.

As you will guess my opinion is not dependent on how many people attend church or self nominate themselves as Christian. Even if the vast majority of citizens were actively rather than nominally Christian I would still argue for separation of church and state. When one denomination, of one religion, is perceived to be favoured and hold more sway in a 'democracy' of what is now a far more diverse society than when Henry VIII created the break from Rome it is divisive and to be fair, unnecessary!

Alea Tue 19-Jan-16 21:49:28

Elegran gringrin

Anyway, back to the point, not merely a diatribe on "faith" schools?
And also, remember we are not talking about the UK, but England.
By "church members" do we know which church? (C of E, Methodist, United Reformed??)
Even the Grauniad projections seem to be at variance with the figures quoted in the original post.
What's that quote about "Lies, damned lies and statistics"???

Anniebach Tue 19-Jan-16 21:52:33

As long as the head of state is also top of the pile in the CofE things will not change , every memorial service , every celebration must be held in an Anglican Church because queenie doesn't do worship in any other church

I suppose it saves the hassle of deciding where a memorial or thanksgiving service will be held, if the Anglican Church were to be disestablished it would mean a lot of coin tossing, I don't care if it is separated from the state , I have no problem with 26 English bishops in the lords, how many English dukes are there ?

Penstemmon Tue 19-Jan-16 22:00:55

Oh Annie don't get me going on who is in the house of Lords grin

Luckygirl Tue 19-Jan-16 22:02:48

Nor me please!

granjura Tue 19-Jan-16 22:04:53

Well Annieb- they could also move to the modern age and move away from the wars of religions ever since henry VIII- ans work together- ecumenically, as they do here- and finally come to the sensible conclusion that Christians still being so divided will hasten their demise.

Isn't it about time?

Anniebach Tue 19-Jan-16 22:04:57

Penstemmon, let's not even think about it , brings on an almost uncontrollable rage and I have not the energy at the moment for almost uncontrollable rage grin

Anniebach Tue 19-Jan-16 22:21:47

Really Granjura, you must be the only country where Jews hold a service in a Christian church . There is no war of religion in this country, stopped ages ago, good Friday's the RC, baptist, Methodists, Anglican carry a cross through town together. It would not be possible for Jews to hold a service in an Anglican Church , the reserved sacrament -blood of Christ - is always there ready should it be needed urgently , not a war , just respect for all faiths , we left the fifties a long time ago, here we hold prayer groups and bible study in homes and several churches are involved

Penstemmon Tue 19-Jan-16 22:33:25

Annie we can at least agree that we are not happy about the HoL and that neither have the energy for explaining exactly why or how annoyed we are! grin

annodomini Tue 19-Jan-16 22:44:07

Anniebach, you are wrong to state that HM doesn't worship in any church other than the C of E. When she is resident at Balmoral, she worships at Crathie Church which is C of S and has many connections with the royal family since the time of Victoria.

annodomini Tue 19-Jan-16 22:49:00

And. incidentally, Princess Anne, as a divorcée couldn't get married in the C of E so she went and got quietly married at Crathie Kirk.

Alea Tue 19-Jan-16 22:57:49

Well Annieb- they could also move to the modern age and move away from the wars of religions ever since henry VIII- ans work together- ecumenically, as they do here- and finally come to the sensible conclusion that Christians still being so divided will hasten their demise
I am trying really hard to resist saying "Don't be silly" but that's been said before.grin

You totally fail to recognise the progress of ecumenism in this country. Oh and hadn't you noticed there are no religious wars these days (and in the bad old days when there were, I would urge you to look at Mainland Europe for how to do a really good religious war) and don't bring NI into it, that has an awful lot more to do with politics and history than religion.
Finally on what do you base "Christians being so so divided will hasten their demise"???

(Quelqu'un exagère, à mon avis.)
You started a thread on the disestablishment of the Church of England, why not stick to it?

Anniebach Wed 20-Jan-16 08:45:09

I know where the windsors worship when in Scotland,

Anniebach Wed 20-Jan-16 08:47:33

We can Penstammon, we certaintly can agree on that grin

practical Sun 29-May-16 17:23:54

When I was at school we had assembly and prayers were included they don't have this now so perhaps that's why there are less Christians if they are not taught it at school or at home.

granjura Sun 29-May-16 19:07:11

Quite a few new posters have 'just appeared' today?

obieone Sun 29-May-16 19:59:07

Cant see the problem. If you think there is one,I dont think you are allowed to do what you are doing granjura?

granjura Sun 29-May-16 20:01:43

Would you be kind enough to re-phrase thise, please

' If you think there is one,I dont think you are allowed to do what you are doing granjura?'

as I truly do not understand what you meant to say. Thanks.

practical Sun 29-May-16 20:16:26

Thank you obieone , we are on the same wavelength

Alea Sun 29-May-16 20:34:59

Looking for contentious issues perhaps?