Gransnet forums

Science/nature/environment

Wind Turbines

(57 Posts)
tanith Sat 19-Feb-22 12:44:53

Apparently during storm Eunice GBs wind turbines were producing nearly 50% of demand at the height and 39% the rest of the time. Some farms had to shut them down to save them from damage. I know some people think they are awful and unsightly but it seems a very successful enterprise or am I wrong. Thoughts?

Katie59 Sun 20-Feb-22 15:06:46

Atomkraft nein danke

That is the slogan that has ended Germany’s nuclear program, the final nuclear is due to be switched off this year, most of their energy is opencast cast coal or Russian gas.

Contrast that with France that is 85% nuclear, btw, the French run most of our nuclear industry too.

M0nica Sun 20-Feb-22 16:43:52

Look at the position the move away from nuclear has forced Germany into when dealing with Russia's flagrant aggression towards the Ukraine, they are ducking and diving over a strong response Russian aggresion because they have got to keep on the right side of the Russians because they are so dependent on Russia for gas and if the Russians cut off the gas, the country would end up with widespread power cuts

Meanwhile the Germans are still using coal to generate power, with 30 coal-fired plant in operation at the moment producing 25% of their power, with more coming on stream. They expect to be using coal-fired power stations until nearly 2040. In the UK we have virtually no coal-fired power stations and it accounts for only 3% of total power production and has been at that level for some years

A lot of German coal is lignite or brown coal, which has been described as the most harmful coal to human health. The combustion of lignite produces less heat for the amount of carbon dioxide and sulfur released than other ranks of coal. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lignite.

Most lignite comes from large scale open cast mines that do enormous damage to the environment when the top layer of the natural landscape, trees, animals insects etc is scraped off and destroyed to get to the lignite just below.

65% of Germany's coal fired power is generated in plants burning lignite.

As far as I am concerned, the proven damage that coal has done to the planet over 4 centuries in almost every country in the world and the millins of deaths it has already caused and will continue to cause until it is eliminated far outways the damage nuclear power and its waste could cause.

volver Fri 04-Mar-22 10:48:34

Anybody this morning thinking nuclear power is the way forward?

Kim19 Fri 04-Mar-22 11:14:13

I've often read that the windmills have to be replaced every 25 years and that the material used to make them is not recyclable. Is this nonsense?

MaizieD Fri 04-Mar-22 11:21:29

volver

Anybody this morning thinking nuclear power is the way forward?

I wish there was a 'like' button grin

There seem to have been breakthroughs in nuclear fusion, which would be a far better way forward. But not in our lifetimes, I'm afraid.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-60312633

Callistemon21 Fri 04-Mar-22 14:52:48

volver

Anybody this morning thinking nuclear power is the way forward?

I never have and even more so now

I wish they'd call a halt to Hinckley Point.