Gransnet forums

Site stuff

toty's thread

(67 Posts)
j04 Tue 19-Jun-12 17:42:06

Do you think GNHQ, you could possibly tell us why this thread was deleted.

Thanking you very kindly.

smile

j04 Tue 19-Jun-12 22:29:19

I think they panicked. They thought it was going to go racist. grin

j04 Tue 19-Jun-12 22:30:16

Ariadne grin

Anagram Tue 19-Jun-12 22:32:11

Racist? [puzzled]

Anagram Tue 19-Jun-12 22:32:46

Or, rather - Racist? confused

j04 Tue 19-Jun-12 22:34:09

Oh come on! hmm

johanna Tue 19-Jun-12 22:35:26

Well,
fuck me rigid
how exciting.

j04 Tue 19-Jun-12 22:36:18

pardon?

nanaej Tue 19-Jun-12 22:40:08

It read a bit like a Q'ranic 'Watchtower'.

j04 Tue 19-Jun-12 22:42:41

It was harmless enough though.

I think. [shrug]

Anagram Tue 19-Jun-12 22:42:44

Muslims are not a 'race', are they? confused

crimson Tue 19-Jun-12 22:43:19

johanna; that's the best laugh I've had all day!

CariGransnet (GNHQ) Tue 19-Jun-12 22:45:35

Nothing to do with implications of racism anywhere - but sermonising is against our forum rules. As we've said before - we're delighted to have all/any religions discussed and represented as long as the posts stick within our guidelines smile (which - of course - goes for all threads on all subjects)

j04 Tue 19-Jun-12 22:47:01

Anagram sigh

It's a word.

I don't think the word faithist exists.

night night.

johanna Tue 19-Jun-12 22:47:42

No ana you are quite right. Muslims are not a race. It is a religion.
Same for the Jews. They are not a race either. Also a religion.

j04 Tue 19-Jun-12 22:47:53

And goodnight Cari.

Yawn

Anagram Tue 19-Jun-12 23:03:24

It may be a word, jingl, but it gives the wrong impression. And the wrong meaning. You can't always just shrug off what you post.

j04 Wed 20-Jun-12 09:47:11

What on earth do you mean by that?! shock

I'm not shrugging anything off!

I meant what I said. I thought perhaps GNHQ were worried it might turn into something racist. I was wrong, as Cari's explanation shows.

I appreciate there are muslims in many races, as there are jews, Christians, etc. etc. I don't need anyone here to tell me basic facts thank you.

j04 Wed 20-Jun-12 09:48:40

and if you can't get your head round that, well............... ! hmm

absentgrana Wed 20-Jun-12 11:53:57

johanna The word Jew refers to a race as well as to someone who follows a religion.

j04 You can't just use words willy nilly to mean whatever you like in the manner of Humpty Dumpty. Or at least not if you expect other people to follow what you're talking about. grin

nanaej Wed 20-Jun-12 12:03:59

Is Judaism is considered a race as well as a religion?

j04 Wed 20-Jun-12 12:37:53

I thought it was obvious what I meant. I still think it was. The word I used - "racist" - was the word I meant to use.

Don't jewish people consider themselves to be one race as well as one religion, wherever they are in the world. Dating back to when they had no homeland?

I didn't know Humpty Dumpty talked. What did he say?

Bags Wed 20-Jun-12 12:44:34

ej, I know few people who call themselves Jewish but are not followers of Judaism. Some even happy to eat bacon, etc.

j04 Wed 20-Jun-12 12:55:35

this lot don't include any speech by him

j04 Wed 20-Jun-12 12:58:08

I suppose he said, "Bang!".

j04 Wed 20-Jun-12 12:59:48

Oops! Missed the post out! hmm

he was a cannon originally