Gransnet forums

Site stuff

Absolute codswallop

(63 Posts)
jinglbellsfrocks Tue 03-Feb-15 17:19:08

where's the science please

Links to some research papers would be greatly appreciated.

hmm

And quite angry actually. Bloody insulting.

Ana Tue 03-Feb-15 17:22:46

Number 8.

'People with larger brains or who took more education are protected against dementia. Big heads often have bigger brains in them, but even if your hat size is small, you can develop on the inside. The important thing is to have some spare capacity if part of your brain starts to fade.'

What??? Are they serious? confused

FarNorth Tue 03-Feb-15 17:24:22

Twaddle. I used to work with people with dementia - it could strike anyone.

merlotgran Tue 03-Feb-15 17:31:03

Don't you just love the way these people talk absolute twaddle then put, 'Don't worry about it' at the bottom?

hmm

Riverwalk Tue 03-Feb-15 17:49:35

Why is GN promoting this obvious shite? shock

Riverwalk Tue 03-Feb-15 17:51:32

"or who took more education" confused

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 03-Feb-15 17:52:00

"The most common causes of dementia are called neurodegenerative diseases, and include Alzheimer's disease, frontotemporal dementia, and dementia with Lewy bodies. With these diseases, the brain cells degenerate and die more quickly than is part of the normal ageing process."

No, of course the NHS is wrong. The old people up and down the country in care homes, suffering from dementia, did actually bring it on themselves because they didn't spend their pensions on vitamins, fish oils, and red wine.

How silly of them.

rosequartz Tue 03-Feb-15 17:55:47

Although it does recommend a glass of wine a day so it can't all be codswallop surely? wink

Riverwalk Tue 03-Feb-15 18:00:28

"Ballroom dancing ....... is very good for postponing dementia"

Now you're really taking the piss!

(sorry for the foul language but I'm really 'effin cross at all this rubbish)

And, I can't believe this bit, it appears to be written by the Director of the Dementia Services Development Centre (DSDC) at the University of Stirling!!!

hildajenniJ Tue 03-Feb-15 18:01:45

I looked after dementia sufferers for many years. They came from all walks of life. I looked after one of Winston Churchill's wartime secretaries, several ward sisters, one gentleman had been instrumental in setting up regional radio (Radio Newcastle). All had been active and well read. My Dad has vascular dementia, it has nothing to do with lifestyle choices. Dad walked for miles with his brothers, he ate healthily and looked after himself well. He has lived until 91 and is the life and soul of the care home. Where do they get this rubbish from?

soontobe Tue 03-Feb-15 18:02:05

I dont know much about it, but I thought no. 8 was particular rubbish too.
There seem to be a lot of brainy people who get it.

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 03-Feb-15 18:03:07

No more research necessary then?

All down to lifestyle. hmm

Kiora Tue 03-Feb-15 18:03:35

I've got a large head and I'm as thick as two short planks. Mine must be full of shite air

harrigran Tue 03-Feb-15 18:05:29

Gifted musicians and academics get dementia, it does not discriminate.

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 03-Feb-15 19:44:55

"10 things you can do today to stop dementia tomorrow"

You have made a statement there Gransnet. Can we have your word that you can guarantee that it is true. Please.

Riverwalk Tue 03-Feb-15 19:57:00

Can I report a GN article to GN?

pompa Tue 03-Feb-15 20:03:49

The moral here is - Take anything you see on the internet as rubbish, until you can prove otherwise, whoever posts it.

soontobe Tue 03-Feb-15 20:05:39

The second and third sentences in number 10 are hmm too.
If you eat well, drink well, and ballroom dance you are definitely having a good time! hmm. And if you get dementia you can carry on partying.

rosesarered Tue 03-Feb-15 20:20:16

One of my Grandmothers, who lived to be about 95, never developed any kind of dementia and ; she took no excercise [ever] was overweight, didn't read and never had an intelligent thought in her life.

rosesarered Tue 03-Feb-15 20:21:30

It's a random thing, striking the intelligent as well as anyone who, shall we say, is not?

Ana Tue 03-Feb-15 20:36:10

I don't think they bother about what they put on here any more - GN is even more of an afterthought now than it ever was! hmm

Riverwalk Tue 03-Feb-15 20:46:23

I've reported myself - in the absence of knowing what else to do - to elicit some sort of response from GN to justify publishing such claptrap.

annodomini Tue 03-Feb-15 21:01:27

Harold Wilson was, as one of his opponents memorably opined, 'too clever by half'. But he had Dementia.

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Tue 03-Feb-15 21:38:03

Hello everyone, I'm sorry to see the post has caused such a stir - this absolutely wasn't our intention and, as the introduction indicates, it was written by an expert in the field so we put our trust in a published academic's research.

As the introduction states, these are tips as to what could make a difference later in life - none are harmful, but might well make a difference later down the line. In terms of the ballroom dancing point, from what I gather it's thought that the act of remembering the steps and responding to a partner's movements can help to postpone some dementia symptoms. I believe this is all based on research done at the University of Stirling by June and her colleagues.

loopylou Tue 03-Feb-15 21:48:25

The first person I ever nursed who had dementia had been the first female barrister in England (I'm told), spoke 6 languages fluently and had been a mountaineer until well in to her 60's........
I don't stand a chance against her.....!