I think a 'warning' is the most appropriate - sometimes posters (especially OPs) may want to come back to say 'this is the outcome / thank you for helping me' or similar.
I would add that the warning could include ' you may get a better response if you start a new thread'
I think some posters google their issue / problem, get led to a thread here, and sign in and post without really checking the site.
Using the Verb Get or variations of Get
