Gransnet forums

Travel

P&O Iona cruise getting cold feet!

(38 Posts)
Sago Tue 19-Mar-24 12:24:56

We got an incredibly good offer for an April fjord cruise on Iona, we booked without doing a great deal of research.

I went on a FB forum about the ship and her cruises, I’m now wondering if we have made a big mistake.

We have had many years of dressing up and dining out so this is not a pull for us, more of a turn off, we don’t want to meet people, we just want to see more of Norway.

It seems even during term time the ship is full of children, some people apparently book the cheap cruises and just stay on the ship eating and drinking.

I’m not a misery honestly!
It’s starting to sound like Butlins at sea and that is not my cup of tea.

Can anyone reassure me?

Sago Sun 28-Apr-24 09:45:56

An update for you all!

We arrived home yesterday after a fabulous cruise.
The ship was spotless, staff superb and the cruise itinerary perfect!

We walked an average of 14 Kilometres a day and saw so much, we even managed a hike in deep snow!

The food in the main dining rooms was very good.
We were too tired to attend any entertainment in the evening but we saw “The Holdovers” in the cinema one evening.

There were an awful lot of children but to be fair the deck 16 with the main pool and buffet was where they all congregated.
A lot of people didn’t leave the ship, they just pay for a floating hotel/pub/casino for the week.

We always managed to find a quiet spot on deck or in the lounges to sit, read and relax.

Iona is what you make of it for us using the smaller dining room and avoiding the sports bars, casino etc it was a 4⭐️ experience.
We went for the experience of exploring Norway and we certainly did that!

We paid around £700 each for the cruise including meals and gratuities, it was worth every penny.

Golfergran I would love to hear your thoughts.

Secondwind Sun 24-Mar-24 16:31:04

I know just how you feel!
I’d only ever been on adult ships and that was a while ago, but the family came too on Iona.
The biggest change for me was remembering to book a restaurant! The self-service is fine, but can be busy.
There were about 1,000 other children on the ship, apparently, but I had absolutely no idea.
Old-fashioned cruising it’s not, but we had a great time in Norway!

Sago Sun 24-Mar-24 09:27:00

DrWatson I presume you are a very superior being from your tone.

ginny Sun 24-Mar-24 09:20:50

Just a word of warning about shore trips.
Arranging your own is definitely cheaper but be aware if anything goes wrong or you are late back and miss the ship, it is up to you to sort out rejoining. If on an organised trip I believe the cruise line is obliged to get you safely back.
We had friends who booked a small boat to go along the coast , which broke down. It took three days and a good few pounds before they caught up with the ship.

Pittcity Sun 24-Mar-24 08:44:56

Well said DrWatson
I'd rather experience and embrace life than find excuses to avoid things.

DrWatson Sun 24-Mar-24 03:05:37

For Damask and Nanny, do think again. NOT all cruises are alike, cruise lines and ships are very different!!! But they all have loads to do, and your hotel room travels with you!

If you WANT a huge ship, like a floating city, plenty to choose from.

If you'd like a smaller, quieter ship, also lots of those, and as Madeleine says, Fred Olsen are indeed geared to the more mature Brit passenger. Cunard are too, but the passengers of that line that we've met on other ships could generally be classified as Snobby on Steroids, so we've avoided that line (apols to any Cunarders reading that who are perfectly decent agreeable people, but sadly some other passengers don't spread that word!).

Lots of higher-priced 'smart casual' lines, all have fabulous service, usually much smaller ships, Oceania, Regent, Seabourn, Hapag Lloyd and more, and similar service but hopefully not quite so dear on Azamara.

BE VERY WARY - unless you're a party beast?! - of lines like Carnival, and NCL (a Carnival cruise got famous few years ago for taking a block booking from a Hells Angels group, quite a shock for the other thousand or so 'normal' passengers who had their vacation ruined!).

Oh, and if you like a more 'multi-cultured' trip, try MSC somewhere in the Med, they'll likely have local passengers getting on and off at each port. A disadvantage might be that you'll get ship announcements, and in the cabaret, in about 6 languages, English well down the list?! But MSC was the only ship we've met that had opera on the cabaret one night, appreciated by a rapt audience (best not every night though?!).

What else -- the dressing up thing??? Well, IF you like that, lots of ships do formal nights, maybe 3 on a 2-week trip, and some women take a delight in wonderful outfits, and their gents usually look good in a tux. We DID do that once, IsNibs hired evening dress on the ship (Celebrity I think, they're OK too), but we've now got used to swerving that type of thing, by using the evening buffet, or one of the speciality restaurants most ships have (& NO, Sago, we've never caught any of the germs you're fascinated with!). We're now keen on the 'smart casual' mantra, saves on luggage space!

For new cruisers who take the plunge, do some research before you go, and TRY to avoid the Ship's Tours, the most complained about aspect of cruising, on all forums, for years. They get many moans for being over-priced, and often poor value. IF you're able-bodied, you can usually do better going on your own to where you want, and not in a crowd. Disabled folk usually are obliged to use them, but these days via the i'net you can sometimes liaise with local firms directly? Bear in mind that in Greece (& a few other countries) the signs on buses will be unintelligible, so public transport is tricky?!

Some of the upper-crust lines INCLUDE some tours (possibly Saga too?) but you're paying a higher price up front anyway. 'Tips' (often called Gratuities) MAY be included in the price, but may not, so do some research on that too, as to new passengers the concept may be a surprise?

IF IN DOUBT, seek advice from an expert cruise booker like IGLU, or one of the forums eg Cruise.co.uk. Somebody somewhere has asked your question, or done your trip!

DrWatson Sun 24-Mar-24 02:25:42

For Sago -- IF INDEED you have observed people doing daft things at a buffet, then you should know that a hotel buffet may have similar issues.

AND -- unless your observation was too quick to be representative, YOU SHOULD have seen how to avoid such problems. You can take things from way back in the display, clearly not disturbed by other passengers, and or wait for a new supply delivered from the kitchen.

The evening meal I was suggesting is usually of hot food, so doesn't suffer from the possible afternoon tea syndrome of people using fingers to select a cake then putting it back -- and IF you ever see that, you're quite at liberty to LOUDLY point out to such people (& nearby staff) the error of their ways.

IF you're paranoid about germs in general, then frankly, why go on a cruise at all? Or a bus, train or plane?

And if you have some immune system problem, get one of the many gadgets (a vast range of prices) which can help you breathe sanitised air, have it round your neck in public places, helps a lot.

flappergirl Sat 23-Mar-24 22:35:29

I'd be scared of getting norovirus or similar.

madeleine45 Sat 23-Mar-24 12:42:11

I find Fred Olsen cruises are much better if you plan to go again. They are smaller ships and can get into smaller fiords than the bigger ships, but more importantly I have found they are better in all ways. They have libraries which actually are libraries, games room etc. So you have the swimming pools , interesting talks etc and I found them very good and the food was execellent., and staff very good. I went on one trip on Arvia and never again. No quiet areas, small swimming areas which also had constant loud music or films showing. No decent library or quiet areas. Not for me again but of course each to their own

Maryl9 Sat 23-Mar-24 11:53:15

We are boarding Iona in 7 days time,our second cruise on her,the first being September 2022 term time to Norway,very few children.This time it will be school holidays and the only reason we are doing this cruise is to travel with our grandchildren,.She is a beautiful ship with lots of space to get away from other passengers.The ship was spotlessly clean,and although I am a little paranoid about other people’s hygiene habits I felt fairly relaxed.
I am expecting this trip to Western Europe to be very different to our last one,due to it being school holidays,but hopefully being in the company of our family will still make it special.

Barbadosbelle Sat 23-Mar-24 09:22:26

..

As another Gran has written, Aurora is probably the only ship now in P&O’s fleet to offer anything like the traditional cruise experience. Smaller at 76,000 tonnage compared to Iona’s 185,000. Our very first cruise in 2020 was on her - no-fly Christmas/New Year Eastern Caribbean. Glorious.

Now an Adults Only ship.

When on a cruise we absolutely love dressing up on Formal Nights - as it makes dinner and the evenings rather different from our onland life (but yours could be more glamorous than ours!).

However, we now only use Cunard Princess Grill to get the experience we like and there are often Special Offers that make it affordable.

I would say for you to go with an open mind, go to the parts of the ship and the entertainments that interest you, enjoy the Ports-of-Call, and avoid the buffets!! You will meet some lovely people and will often be disappointed that you haven’t ’bumped into them again’.

.

5553n Sat 23-Mar-24 04:55:14

I was ambivalent about going on P&O Arvia recently to the Caribbean. This is a large ship but hiding away from the hoards was easy. The food was delicious but avoid the mass breakfast buffet at all costs! We found a quiet smaller breakfast area where you could take breakfast outside on deck- wonderful! The entertainment was superb, easily rivaling the West End. No formal dressing up for me even though there was a plethora of sequins tall heels and people embracing the whole thing. I love clothes and looking good but did it my way and looked fab! We've booked Fjords in August on the strength of such a good experience. Go and enjoy yourself it's great on board smile

Sago Fri 22-Mar-24 20:48:16

GolferGrandma

Sago,
I’ll watch out for you, though probably won’t see you as you’ll be hiding! All I am worrying about is the weather. Just hope it won’t be too cold, the usual “layering” will be the order of the day.
It’s only a week so we shouldn’t suffer too much. We will just enjoy the scenery and pottering around the ports of call. We had visited 3 of them some years back and don’t plan booking any tours this time, far too expensive!!

We have booked the Olden Skylift direct with Olden tours, much cheaper than the P&O deal.
We are hopefully meeting our son and his GF in Stavangar, they live in Oslo.
We are keen walkers so weather permitting we will get some steps in.
I hope I don’t come across as sounding miserable, it’s just the FB group really put me off!
It was a bargain price though.

GolferGrandma Fri 22-Mar-24 20:05:34

Sago,
I’ll watch out for you, though probably won’t see you as you’ll be hiding! All I am worrying about is the weather. Just hope it won’t be too cold, the usual “layering” will be the order of the day.
It’s only a week so we shouldn’t suffer too much. We will just enjoy the scenery and pottering around the ports of call. We had visited 3 of them some years back and don’t plan booking any tours this time, far too expensive!!

Sago Fri 22-Mar-24 19:07:15

DrWatson

Sago -- Ginny is exactly correct in her comments, you can avoid the Main Dining Room by using buffet for evening meal, if it's a 'formal' night (just what we do).

However, your sad comment re "buffet = germfest" is a strong suggestion that you're paranoid, and shouldn't be on a ship at all?! There should be some speciality restaurants too, if you want to do a Garbo?!

And for people wondering about cruises generally, Fred Olsen is a line geared to the more mature British passenger, smaller ships too, not the vast floating cities some lines have!

And also a line with great service, smaller ships that can access less obvious ports, that's AZAMARA (generally a 'smart casual' regime too, suits us). You're paying a little more (still not the '6-star' prices!) but we think excellent value.

Not paranoid just sensible, I have watched many a person cough, sneeze and touch their way around a buffet!

Sago Fri 22-Mar-24 19:05:18

GolferGrandma

Sago
We are booked on Iona 20 - 27 April. Easter holidays have passed so should be hardly any children, and as mentioned, Norwegian fjords probably not appealing to that age anyway.
Like you the cruise was a good price and tempted us to book. Normally we prefer smaller ships but for only 7 days are prepared to give her a try. There is only one formal night in the 7 so no need to dress up if you are not comfortable with that. As mentioned in other posts, there are so many options for dining.
We are long time P & O cruisers on smaller ships but prepared to see what Iona has to offer.
Don’t worry, relax and enjoy.

Same cruise!

skate Fri 22-Mar-24 18:22:06

I agree with Daffydilly - people are keen to make assumptions and ill informed comments when sometimes they have no actual experience. Neither a cruise ship itself nor the buffet is a 'germ fest'. They are invariably well run and highly sanitised- much more so than your average hotel.

Sometimes it's good not to bother with too much research! You end up worrying about what might or might not be a problem. Just go with an open mind and enjoy it, as I am sure you will.

mabon1 Fri 22-Mar-24 16:10:36

We went on Iona last April, it was great. Few children and one does not need to "dress up"i.e gowns and dinner suits -nice frocks or trousers and tops for the ladies and suits for the gentlemen was the thing. There was one posh evening but few were dressed to kill. Go and enjoy the cruise.

GolferGrandma Fri 22-Mar-24 15:06:53

Sago
We are booked on Iona 20 - 27 April. Easter holidays have passed so should be hardly any children, and as mentioned, Norwegian fjords probably not appealing to that age anyway.
Like you the cruise was a good price and tempted us to book. Normally we prefer smaller ships but for only 7 days are prepared to give her a try. There is only one formal night in the 7 so no need to dress up if you are not comfortable with that. As mentioned in other posts, there are so many options for dining.
We are long time P & O cruisers on smaller ships but prepared to see what Iona has to offer.
Don’t worry, relax and enjoy.

Nannyknee Fri 22-Mar-24 15:04:49

We went on Iona in September to the fjords. Unfortunately it put us off ever going on a cruise again. The ship is so big and crowded. I think it is geared to younger people. Having said that the ship is beautiful and cabins very spacious. The weather was appalling so perhaps that didn’t help!

DamaskRose Fri 22-Mar-24 14:39:55

I’ve always been very anti-cruises because of the socialising and dressing up etc. This thread has made me think again as Norway is one of the places I’d love to visit.

Daffydilly Fri 22-Mar-24 14:38:58

GrauntyHelen

Regarding your buffet germ fest comment a cruise in itself is a germ fest

Oh give over. No more or less than staying in a nice hotel.

I honestly wonder at all those sweeping statements about cruises and germs, quite likely from people who've never cruised.

The cruise industry is incredibly well regulated and ships are extremely well maintained and cleaned. I've stayed in both hotels and on cruise ships and without exception find the ships to be cleaner and better run.

GrauntyHelen Fri 22-Mar-24 13:59:18

Regarding your buffet germ fest comment a cruise in itself is a germ fest

Cherylrov Fri 22-Mar-24 13:23:56

I have been in Arvia which I believe is the sister ship to Iona. We had a great time as you can do whatever suits you , mix if you want to of keep a lower profile and do your own thing. There were children on our cruise but they were not a problem at all. apart from a bit of crowding near the main pool which we never actually sat by as plenty of other places to sit and relax. I would not say it is not like butlins although have never been there 😂 Enjoy the cruise in your own way you will not be disappointed

Debbi58 Fri 22-Mar-24 13:19:13

We went on the Iona last November, not in school holidays admittedly. There were a few young children on board, but not many . If you download the app, you can book to eat in one of the many restaurants, which we did . Much quieter, there's also an adults only pool/ bar area, on the top deck . We used that, please don't worry too much. It's truly a beautiful ship , the entertainment is really good also