Gransnet forums

Travel

Crochet hooks on planes - rant alert!

(52 Posts)
Rosiebee Tue 29-Oct-24 19:53:46

In March we'll be going to Australia / New Zealand with Singapore Airlines. It's a big trip for us and we've booked to go Business class. We've done quite a few long haul flights and I've always taken my crochet with me to pass the time and keep me relaxed. However I've just been in touch with SA and it seems crochet hooks are not allowed. We'll be served drinks in glasses, meals on china and we'll be eating with proper knives and forks. I'm sure I could do more damage with a broken glass or a fork than I could with a crochet hook. I know it's no big deal in the scheme of things but I'm so disappointed and a bit cross because there is no logic to it. I pointed out that I wouldn't be taking scissors but it was still a "No". I could maybe understand if it was knitting needles but I don't know what they think my hook is capable of, especially as I've used it on lots of other airlines. Sorry, just needed a bit of a rant. I would love to know the reasons why.

Smileless2012 Tue 29-Oct-24 19:56:38

Does seem odd Rosiebee but Business class is great and I'm sure you'll be able to relax even without your crochet hook. Have a great trip.

Allira Tue 29-Oct-24 20:06:56

Do they know what a crochet hook looks like?

Could you try taking a wooden one? Of course, if you get it taken off you and you use a pin to stop your crochet unravelling they might take the pin off you too in case you run amok with a safety pin.

Knitting needles, perhaps but crochet hooks?

Thank you for letting us know. It's a long flight.

Harris27 Tue 29-Oct-24 20:08:13

Can’t understand it I thought my sister took hers long haul to Australia?

Allira Tue 29-Oct-24 20:09:53

Singapore Airlines' baggage restrictions state that sharp or bladed objects, such as crochet hooks, are illegal.

Crochet hooks are not sharp!

lixy Tue 29-Oct-24 20:12:06

Agree that it sounds odd as I have crocheted on aeroplanes all over the world. I take a thin hook in a small bag with the yarn as a work in progress and no one has ever batted an eyelid.

Perhaps wear a plastic one as a hairpin and style it out?!😇

Chardy Tue 29-Oct-24 20:14:22

I'm assuming it's metal crochet hooks they're thinking off. But plastic ones shouldn't be a problem.
I've done London to Auckland, and would want my crochet with me too.

Allira Tue 29-Oct-24 20:15:24

lixy 😁

I remember the woman who had her knitting taken off her on a flight, I think she was knitting a shawl for a new grandchild. The crew didn't give her the chance to thread the stitches on to yarn, just took the lot.

Primrose53 Tue 29-Oct-24 20:16:25

I always take a crochet hook and never had a problem.

Allira Tue 29-Oct-24 20:21:19

It's not against TSA rules, this is Singapore Airlines's own rule.

Esmay Tue 29-Oct-24 20:32:15

This is an old rule .
I've seen knitting needles bring confiscated .
I got through with my embroidery needles .
Another passenger had her chilli powder taken .
Anything which poses a danger to staff risks being taken at the airport .
I save up good books and magazines , which I long to read for a flight .

SueDonim Tue 29-Oct-24 20:34:58

That’s annoying. I’d get a plastic or a bamboo/wood hook instead.

Patsy70 Tue 29-Oct-24 21:17:58

Someone sitting in our row on an EasyJet flight recently was crocheting.

travelsafar Tue 29-Oct-24 21:52:52

When I went to India with Virgin I used a bamboo crochet hook. Maybe check if that will be acceptable on your flight.

Allira Tue 29-Oct-24 21:54:53

Singapore Airlines' baggage restrictions state that sharp or bladed objects, such as crochet hooks, are illegal

nanna8 Tue 29-Oct-24 22:14:40

Singapore Airlines are quite fussy. What used to make me laugh is they used to sell ornamental knives at the airport there ! Australia, as you will know, is super fussy about what is taken in. Once I had an orange which had been given to me towards the end of the flight and I just forgot that I had put it into my backpack to eat later. I got told off!

Allira Tue 29-Oct-24 22:16:43

I'm surprised you didn't get fined 😯

At least they clean your shoes for you when you enter Australia if they have a bit of dirt on the soles!

BlueBelle Tue 29-Oct-24 22:25:35

Nana8 I did the same on my way to NZ I hadn’t eaten all my banana so tucked the peel in, and popped it in my bag for on the onward car journey I got pulled aside and given a harsh lecture before they threw my half banana away They were quite harsh how they spoke to me and I was ages my son wondered where I d got to

Whethertomorrow Wed 30-Oct-24 08:58:44

I’d just stay home!

I’d go mad if I couldn’t crochet on a long trip.

Tell them it’s your emotional support work and it will damage your mental health if you can’t crochet.

Good luck.

😵‍💫🤣

Lovetopaint037 Wed 30-Oct-24 09:38:20

BlueBelle

Nana8 I did the same on my way to NZ I hadn’t eaten all my banana so tucked the peel in, and popped it in my bag for on the onward car journey I got pulled aside and given a harsh lecture before they threw my half banana away They were quite harsh how they spoke to me and I was ages my son wondered where I d got to

They can be very officious at the New Zealand airport (Auckland) but when they asked for the purpose of my visit I answered “to visit the most beautiful country in the world”. Everything changed and became really relaxed asking where we were going in a chatty manner.

Rosiebee Wed 30-Oct-24 09:39:22

Wondering about a bamboo hook????? Might be worth a try, with my real hook packed in hold luggage. There are two 13 hr flights and two 9 hr flights to get through. Had no problem with Virgin, KLM, Air France, BA etc. I'll accept anything if I know the reason, but this just seems so petty. Would they actually take my crochet away, not just the hook?

Allira Wed 30-Oct-24 10:41:42

Rosiebee

Wondering about a bamboo hook????? Might be worth a try, with my real hook packed in hold luggage. There are two 13 hr flights and two 9 hr flights to get through. Had no problem with Virgin, KLM, Air France, BA etc. I'll accept anything if I know the reason, but this just seems so petty. Would they actually take my crochet away, not just the hook?

You could try it.

At least you could rescue the item even if they confiscate the hook, it's only one stitch unlike knitting.

Otherwise take a couple of books or a Kindle to while the time away.
We've tried to fly at night to try to get some sleep so the cabin lights dim anyway.

kazziecookie Wed 30-Oct-24 13:23:11

I am going to Australia in March with Singapore Airlines too, but unfortunately I can only afford economy class. I haven’t done any crocheting for years so that won’t be a problem for me but as I am going on my own, I am looking forward to watching the films I like without my husband being in charge of the remote control.
It will be lovely to see my daughter and grandson who I haven’t seen in person for over two years and also my new grandchild (she doesn’t know yet what she is having) that is due that month.

ordinarygirl Wed 30-Oct-24 14:54:21

I think plastic or bamboo hooks would be allowed but not metal ones.

sandelf Wed 30-Oct-24 14:54:58

Oh dear the world really has gone mad. Sorry, I did laugh - can't imagine the terrorist selecting a crochet hook as weapon of choice! I hope you find it is a misunderstanding.