Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Dickensian

(194 Posts)
Gagagran Thu 07-Jan-16 20:47:12

I really think this is so good a series that it deserves a thread of its own despite being mentioned in passing in another thread.

Everything about it is excellent from the costumes, the scenery and dialogue. Above all though is the perfectly cast characters - all of whom seem to look exactly as they should! I think Inspector Bucket is my special favourite but all of them have the faces and bearing and delivery of the lines exactly as they should have.

The clever knitting together of so many Dickens' characters is brilliant and I shall be so sorry when it ends. I think the great man himself would be very pleased if only he could see it.

Pittcity Sun 14-Feb-16 17:26:59

Haven't the "real police" already beaten a confession out of somebody? In that case Bucket need not turn Mrs C in......

Marelli Sun 14-Feb-16 20:17:35

Got it! Thanks, J52. smile

starbird Mon 15-Feb-16 01:44:00

Pittcity you are right, the other police won't want to lose face so they'll tell Bucket he's wrong and whichever Cratchett it was ( or whoever else) will get off Scott free.

nigglynellie Mon 15-Feb-16 10:23:48

OH that is a point! I'd forgotten about the forced confession, that will explain how the Cratchits all appear intact several years along the line only two more episodes for all to be revealed, or not!!!

Imperfect27 Fri 19-Feb-16 09:05:31

If you are keeping up with this - I thought last night's episode was brilliant ... won't give anything away, but so well acted yet again and more story twists and turns to keep us hooked until the last. I've heard there are 18 episodes so that must mean tonight certain things come to a climax ... but I also hope there are sufficient loose ends to warrant another series.

Elrel Fri 19-Feb-16 12:30:31

Imperfect - I just caught up with last night's episode, agree with you! Can't comment for fear of spoilers but looking forward to tonight's!

Marelli Fri 19-Feb-16 13:28:42

According to Radio Times tonight is 19 of 20 episodes, yet on looking at next week's RT, it's not there.... confused

Marelli Fri 19-Feb-16 14:20:30

Oops - it's on tonight, then Sunday for 50 minutes. smile

Gagagran Fri 19-Feb-16 15:21:07

I get so engrossed in each episode that it's a real shock when the credits roll. Looking forward to Compeyson getting his comeuppance now cousin Matthew's back. (Hopefully). Superb series!

WilmaKnickersfit Fri 19-Feb-16 15:41:18

It was brilliant last night! I hope there's another series, but it will be hard to top this one for meshing all the stories.

It feels like all the stories are coming to an end one by one and like any Dickens novel, so far there's been no happy ending - not even last night, not if you think about it.

Marelli Fri 19-Feb-16 21:06:05

Loved the last scenes with the Bumbles -and I was right - the lovely wee boy with the big eyes turned out to be Oliver Twist! smile

starbird Fri 19-Feb-16 23:41:23

I think this program is a masterpiece and was surprised to discover that the writer was Tony Jordan who writes Eastenders (which I don't watch) but I guess human behaviour has not changed much over the years, and if he were alive today Dickens would be writing a tv soap set in London!
As all of our book club members are enjoying Dickensian we have chosen 'The old curiosity shop' as our next book.
Maybe we will get a second series next Christmas!

nigglynellie Sat 20-Feb-16 10:28:56

Oscar Wilde roses!! This quote neve fails to make me laugh!! FHS, Is this wedding going to be like Jane Eyre with, perhaps, Arthur, at last pulling himself together, facing up to Comperson and spilling the beans about his marriage? Why didn't he tell Mathew? Perhaps he did when we were otherwise occupied with the hideous Bumbles, who are acted superbly as they all are. Really looking forward to tomorrow, when all should be revealed!

Badenkate Sat 20-Feb-16 10:54:26

I don't think this counts as a spoiler because it is in the book, but Compeyson is the other convict associated with Magwitch. And I think Magwich kills him in the end. Knowing that I watch it thinking 'you're going to get your just desserts at some point'!!

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 20-Feb-16 11:03:49

I think we can abandon the "no spoilers" thing! Any info welcome. grin

Poor little Oliver Twist. sad

rosesarered Sat 20-Feb-16 11:24:55

Thanks * niggly* Oscar Wilde it was, he said so many brilliant quotes including ' either that wallpaper goes or I do' shortly before he died.
Oliver Twist now out on the street, he will meet Dodger ( or will he, as Sykes told him to run away.)
Yes Moscow obviously agreed with Inspector Bucket, he looked rested and restored.grin
I keep wanting to eat pie, they feature so heavily in the programme.

nigglynellie Sat 20-Feb-16 12:45:47

Yes those pies do look delicious! Mind you, hygiene was probably a bit at a premium!!!and maybe overtones of Sweeny Todd, you can never quite tell with victorian England!!! shock
Thank goodness Inspector Bucket had a good heart! The idea of poor Mrs Crachit going to the gallows was more than we could bear. That other criminal would have hanged anyway, so........ At least it answered how she popped up in Christmas Carol seven years later!!!!

Nelliemoser Sat 20-Feb-16 22:48:20

We will all have to watch tomorrow. This is the cleverest concept for a drama I have seen for a long time. I did not expect Inspector Bucket to do that. The clowning of the Bumbles sits in great contrast to the straight drama between the two Barbary sisters which was so well acted.

WilmaKnickersfit Sun 21-Feb-16 00:56:46

Arthur just has to step in and stop the wedding, even though it will damn him in everyone's eyes. I think when Matthew said to Arthur to remember his father, I think that will be the turning point for Arthur and he will finally grow up. He just can't let Amelia marry Compeyson. It wouldn't surprise me if he ends up with the company and then lives unhappily ever after because of the repercussions of his behaviour.

Am I right in thinking Arthur hasn't actually done anything illegal so far? Unless Compeyson is caught during the marriage service and can be arrested for attempted bigamy, I'm not sure he's committed any crime either.

What do others think?

nigglynellie Sun 21-Feb-16 11:18:58

Not sure!!!! But I think we all want justice for Jip!!!!!!!

Badenkate Sun 21-Feb-16 11:28:41

Absolutely right niggly. I had forgotten poor Jip!! sad. That man deserves everyghing he gets!

Gagagran Sun 21-Feb-16 12:45:13

I think the implication was that Arthur is gay, which was illegal (well pursuing it was) at the time and Compeyson implied he'd tell Amelia. Of course Arthur has colluded with the villain too and Amelia doesn't know that yet. It's got to end tonight so we shall see how the loose ends are tied together. Hopefully for series 2!

Man of the match for me has been Inspector Bucket!

nigglynellie Sun 21-Feb-16 17:08:08

I think he has been for a lot of us, he certainly was for the Cratchits!!!

POGS Sun 21-Feb-16 17:18:23

She would be better off marrying Fagan!

Imperfect27 Sun 21-Feb-16 18:00:28

Gagagran that was my understanding too and I thought that was the reason Arthur's father hadn't left the company to him.

Whatever the outcomes tonight (50 minutes worth - yay!) I cannot see any good ending for Amelia Havisham. Great expectations has been playing on the Drama channel this afternoon ... I wonder if the closing shot tonight will be the poor, devastated lady in her wedding gown ... or maybe the Artful Dodger meeting Oliver ... so much anticipation!!