Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Strictly's Back

(430 Posts)
adaunas Sat 09-Sept-17 09:32:09

I've just looked at the Strictly line up and wonder if I don't watch enough TV. Who ARE these 'celebrities'? On the picture grid I recognised 3 faces and one extra with a nudge from my OH. I could name only one off the top of my head, but another one because I'd just read about them in an article about Strictly where they were arguing about whether a gay woman should dance with a woman. (She didn't want to; she said she was there to learn to dance, not to make a point about her sexuality, but felt there was pressure on her from the LBTG group.)

Charleygirl Sun 05-Nov-17 17:11:52

I love watching Susan dance but to me her outfits are horrendous.

Alima Sun 05-Nov-17 17:20:21

You saying that Charley has made me realise what little notice I take of the dancers’ outfits. The only one I can remember with any clarity was the one Anton wore a few weeks ago for his Samba. The pink glitzy trousers and the fou fou shirt sleeves, inspired.

merlotgran Sun 05-Nov-17 19:57:33

What a travesty!! angry

DanniRae Sun 05-Nov-17 20:13:25

I can't believe that Anton has gone - I felt sure he was heading for the final! shock

MawBroon Sun 05-Nov-17 20:17:20

Anton hasn’t gone!
It was Aston.

Swanny Sun 05-Nov-17 21:43:11

merlotgran I totally agree with you. IMO Aston is a far better dancer than Mollie, and Janette a much more skillful choreographer/instructor than AJ, who is too full of himself to share anything.

ninathenana Mon 06-Nov-17 01:15:07

I think it may have been a bit of a fix. Aston said in the press he was worried he might have to do a runner from the set if his baby arrived early. Maybe they gave him a way out.

DanniRae Mon 06-Nov-17 08:19:25

Oops Sorry I meant Aston MawBroon!!

Anya Mon 06-Nov-17 08:25:35

I agree that Aston is the better dancer, but everything was wrong about his routine on Saturday night which is why he ended up in the dance off.

Firstly the costumes seemed odd and not fitting for a Viennese Walze, the ‘look’ was just all wrong. Then he performed in a jerky manner, small steps, none of the grace and style associated with this dance. It did nothing for me, nor obviously the public as they didn’t give him their vote.

Yes, he performed better in the dance off and I’m not sure that the decision to keep Mollie in was correct, but it’s both his and Janette’s fault they were in that position in the first place.

cornergran Mon 06-Nov-17 09:07:19

Agree, anya. The look certainly didn’t help and he really seemed awkward. Overall he may be the better dancer, I didn’t think so on Saturday. Oh well, onwards to next week.

eazybee Mon 06-Nov-17 09:19:30

Aston is unquestionably the better dancer, and I am sorry that he has gone; I hope the vapid Mollie will depart soon. The choreography was at fault, far too stiff and jerky, lacking fluidity, for which I blame Janette, rather too aggressive. But it was the judges 'decision, and I bow to their informed opinion.

felice Mon 06-Nov-17 10:08:55

I had not realised it was supposed to be a Viennese Waltz, a very odd one I must say. On the news this morning a comment was passed that perhaps voters thought he was safe so voted for not so strong dancers. Perhaps his mind was not on the dance with a baby due.
I tend to turn the sound of except for the actual dances and read in between.

petra Mon 06-Nov-17 12:29:56

I'm afraid Shirley has made her opinions very clear in that: you will not deviate from the 'proper' way to do a dance.
I knew from the moment Aston was called he was finished, she made her feelings very clear when marking him.

grannyactivist Mon 06-Nov-17 12:57:28

I liked Aston, but the ruination of one of my favourite dances didn't sit well with me. Janette's choreography was not up to her usual standard and Aston's movements were jerky and he looked unco-ordinated - the costumes were terrible too. On the basis of this particular dance I think they deserved to go. However, I think the public have decided they don't like Mollie and she seems to be aware of that, so she needs to show some passion and personality if she's not going to be in the dance off again next week.

AyjayF Mon 06-Nov-17 18:10:49

I'm pretty new to Strictly + I didn't know people got so passionate about it.
I have 2 questions. Why are the celebrities criticised for the content of the dance i.e the choreography + sticking to the rules of the foxtrot, waltz etc. How are they supposed to know?
What does ' going to Blackpool' mean?

callgirl1 Mon 06-Nov-17 18:16:20

The show comes from Blackpool in a couple of weeks, and they`re all keen to dance in the Tower ballroom, which is a most beautiful place.

Luckylegs Mon 06-Nov-17 18:25:20

I think that Alexandra is a good dancer but she is far too fixed on winning, she's not popular for over reacting when she gets good marks etc, didn't she fall to the floor this week in shock? She's very disapproving of her partner's romance with Gemma as it might take his 100% attention away from her.

I thought Mollie should have gone instead of Aston, that was completely contrary, he got two votes against one to stay, then Shirley completely overturned that!

I think Anton has decided to go for the comedy vote as he realises Ruth can't really cut the mustard. It's a shame I like her but she is a bit wooden!

Going to Blackpool means the week after next, the show is transferred to Blackpool for one week which competitors aspire to be on as its a different venue and even more fun and excitement, apparently!

POGS Mon 06-Nov-17 18:53:50

I still enjoy Susan for the reasons I mentioned way back but boy can't Debbie dance!

Alima Mon 06-Nov-17 19:09:18

How I agree with you POGS. Susan and Kevin are a joy to watch. Debbie is amazing, out of the shadows with a bang. (I was never comfortable with that Mrs Merton so-called funny (but sneering) when she asked “what attracts you to millionaire Paul Daniels?” No one ever bothers to quote Debbie’s answer, “he wasn’t a millionaire when I met him”).

paddyann Mon 06-Nov-17 20:06:40

I cant warm to Debbie ,she might be technically good but she has no soul on the other hand Susan and Joe in particular have worked really hard and have a great rapport with the viewer

callgirl1 Mon 06-Nov-17 21:26:40

The celebs should be judged on how much they`ve improved over the weeks. Alexandra and Debbie haven`t improved, they`ve been good from the get go, so shouldn`t be in the running. Susan, Jonny, Joe and Davood on the other hand, are getting better as the weeks go on.

Anya Mon 06-Nov-17 22:27:52

Of course Alexander and Debbie have improved. What on odd thing to say ???

callgirl1 Tue 07-Nov-17 00:26:45

What I meant was that they haven`t improved as such in the same way as the non dancers who started from scratch.

Teetime Tue 07-Nov-17 09:11:54

I'm pleased Mollie won she looked delightful and it is a shame about Aston but that's they voting system for you. What I don't like is the way the judges particular Craig is reviled on social media- Craig can be harsh but I often agree with his analysis.

TerriBull Tue 07-Nov-17 10:07:12

I was very disappointed in Aston's departure, I know he mucked up last week, but he is far better than some of the clunky competitors still there. I thought it was odds on that he would reach the final 3 and he was my favourite. I'm not terribly interested in watching it to it's conclusion now. Sour grapes I know. I think Debbie may be the first older person to be overall winner.