Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Manhunt with Martin Clunes

(41 Posts)
paddyann Mon 07-Jan-19 15:44:27

I felt so sorry for James ' mum on TV today but I do think we all forgot these were children who committed the crime.I think their parents should have been in the dock alongside them....what kind of "parenting" gives you children that behave like this.They must have been badly abused/neglected at the very least. I dont think it will do us any harm to look differently at these boys and to see how they became what they did .

EllanVannin Mon 07-Jan-19 15:35:22

Not half as bad as the insult towards little Jamie Bulger's mum, Denise who now has to face a film about the toddler's killers. " Detainment " a short film comprising of verbatim quotes from interview transcripts.

What's the matter with these producers that they have to bring up such hurt in the name of entertainment ?

Although " Manhunt " is interesting it will still feel raw re. Millie's family seeing something like this.

Gagagran Mon 07-Jan-19 15:02:46

I thought it was very sensitively done and Martin Clunes was excellent. What a versatile actor he is. His wife was the director.

I like anything involving detective work and how the police set about these awful cases. I have police in my family and I am very proud to think that they are there to bring these perpetrators to justice.

Look forward to part 2 tonight.

KatyK Mon 07-Jan-19 13:59:54

I have just been reading that someone has made a film about the James Bulger murder, without consulting his family. I can only imagine the distress this has caused them.

Grannyben Mon 07-Jan-19 13:54:30

I did watch the first part last night and, like KatyK, I saw Martin Clunes talking about it this morning. He did say that his wife had been in contact with the victims family, I think he may have said she was the Director.
Originally, I thought it was a drama about the murders but he said it is actually the story of the police investigation and how the team worked to solve the case

oldbatty Mon 07-Jan-19 13:54:24

Probably not for me.couldnt cope with Luther.

KatyK Mon 07-Jan-19 13:44:49

Martin Clunes and the policeman he played were on TV this morning. They both said it was done with great respect to the victims' families and that the families were fully consulted.

J52 Mon 07-Jan-19 11:36:45

Ah, now I know that the restaurant is in Richmond it helps! I’ve watched the scene again, it’s at 41 mins into the programme. The detective, Jones, is looking at the CTV stills and says, ‘once I knew that she walked back from the bus garage’.
It’s fitting into place, still a long walk!

Jane10 Mon 07-Jan-19 10:54:01

Gosh. I hadn't thought of that. Stupid of me. Of course it's presenting an awful painful crime as entertainment. I've recorded it as I like Martin Clunes. I feel a bit ashamed now and probably won't watch it.

FlexibleFriend Mon 07-Jan-19 10:41:37

They didn't say she got on the wrong bus or that she got off at the depot, they said she went past her stop and had to walk back which was why she crossed the common. I don't know the area but know what was said.

TerriBull Mon 07-Jan-19 10:38:05

J52 Amelie was working at a French patisserie in Richmond, I can't remember the name, but I know where it was, because I have met a friend there once or twice.

J52 Mon 07-Jan-19 10:29:37

As a teenager and in my early twenties I went past that spot twice a day. I remember being alarmed at the time of the real murder and it’s link to Marsha’s, as it used to (and probably still is) such a safe area.
I’m a bit confused about the bus though, they said she got on the wrong bus and walked back from the depot. I presume the depot was Fulwell Bus Garage quite a long walk. Where was the French restaurant? I thought it was in Twickenham, so why was she catching a bus?

KatyK Mon 07-Jan-19 10:22:24

I have recorded it and will watch it by myself. DH won't watch anything like this. I like most things with Martin Clunes.

henetha Mon 07-Jan-19 10:16:18

I agree that this sort of programme must be very difficult to bear for the relatives of those girls so tragically murdered, but I hope and believe that they are approached and asked for permission. If not, then that is reprehensible.
However, I have to admit that I found last night's episode fascinating, and other similar series in the past. Maybe I have a warped mind, but I do like knowing how the detectives work and gradually build up a case and find the evidence they need to bring about a conviction. I enjoy watching Martin Clunes in anything, and thought the whole thing was realistically done. I look forward to tonight's episode, while still bearing in mind the suffering of those victims and their families.

TerriBull Mon 07-Jan-19 10:06:39

I've recorded it, was watching Les Mis. yesterday. It's an awful story, played out a couple of miles from where I live. I remember being horrified by the murder of the two girls, Amelie and Marsha who were attacked walking home and everyone was very jittery at the time as it became apparent this was the work of a serial killer. Of course we didn't know then that he was also responsible for murdering Millie Dowler. Will probably watch it early evening. Awful man angry

seacliff Mon 07-Jan-19 09:57:16

I saw this last night, the first of 3 parts. I didn't realise at first, it is all based on truth, about the murders committed by Levi Bellfield. Last night they found a young French girl Amélie Delagrange, and already were investigating the murder of Millie Dowler.

I feel uncomfortable about watching this sort of programme, It is almost being shown as entertainment, not a documentary. It isn't so long since it actually happened. I feel for all the relatives and friends whose lives were shattered by this man.

It was very well done, and I thought Martin Clunes was good. However, if it were my relative, I would be terribly upset to think a tv drama had been made about them.