Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

The Pale Horse by Agatha Christie

(163 Posts)
Fiachna50 Sat 25-Jan-20 12:53:24

Hi everyone, if like me you are an Agatha Christie fan. The above-named drama begins Sunday 9th February BBC1 at 9pm.

NanKate Wed 12-Feb-20 14:28:21

Thank you Cherrytree I will record it.

oldgimmer1 Wed 12-Feb-20 17:49:06

I liked it. Not a clue what's going on, though.

And Much Deeping very Costswolds-looking.

Can someone please tell me what Mark does for a living? He seems to have a lot of time on his hands...

Callistemon Wed 12-Feb-20 18:25:09

It seems to have passed me by, oldgimmer!!

MerylStreep Wed 12-Feb-20 18:37:59

For some reason I think he's an antique dealer.

Callistemon Wed 12-Feb-20 18:40:35

Yes, I think he is.

lemongrove Wed 12-Feb-20 19:32:26

He owns an upmarket antique shop in London ( one which doesn’t seem to have any customers.)
His main job is to look enigmatic and change his suits a lot.

Deedaa Wed 12-Feb-20 21:26:33

In the book he was a writer.

Grandma2213 Thu 13-Feb-20 00:42:45

Well I enjoyed it especially the spookiness. I didn't really know who Rufus Sewell was but he kept reminding me of Profumo in Christine Keeler (Ben somebody). Something about the strange eyes. I have read some Agatha Christie books but instantly forgot them. She always seemed to be the grown ups' Enid Blyton to me. Maybe I'll be shot down in flames for that! I've always loved Rita Tushingham too - those eyes!

M0nica Thu 13-Feb-20 08:28:31

The Pale Horse seems to be a very successful and enjoyable tv drama, well plotted and well played.

It is just that it shares little in common with a book with the same name written by Agatha Christie, so the title is a bit misleading.

Fiachna50 Thu 13-Feb-20 10:36:37

Witzend, I too absolutely love Joan Hickson and think she was definitely the best Miss Marple. I have just taped the whole Joan Hickson (Miss Marple) series from the Alibi channel to watch at my leisure. I also love Margaret Rutherford and have the boxed set of her films. The one I couldn't take to was Julia McKenzie in the role, just wasn't for me.

M0nica Thu 13-Feb-20 16:30:32

I must say I found JuliaMcKenzie one off putting. I do not watch much television and it was the first time I had come across the dramatisation of a book, where the script-writer had actually changed the plot, changing the killer and introducing a lesbian storyline, presumably to make it more 'woke'?

Plot changes are necessary when transferring from printed media to broadcast, and that is acceptable, but intrducing major changes in plot or characters just because you can, shows a sad lack of enterprise and originality.

suziewoozie Thu 13-Feb-20 17:17:11

I loved Joan Hickson too as Miss Marple. I can’t put it into words but I found her perfect

Calendargirl Sat 15-Feb-20 07:37:00

Watched this last night. Have never read the book, but have watched a previous tv version where I think Miss Marple was involved, can’t remember if it was Julia McKenzie or Geraldine McKewan, either way it seemed pretty rubbishy.
I rather enjoyed this version, but pleased if it’s only two episodes as otherwise I think it would drag on a bit.

M0nica Sat 15-Feb-20 07:42:20

Calendargirl Pale Horse is not a Miss Marple book. Joan Hickson did not appear in it, at least not in the official series she did.

A lot of people have enjoyed this drama, a shame the author is so unsure of herself, that she had to hide her work behind another author's name and title.

Curlywhirly Sat 15-Feb-20 07:52:23

Another fan of Joan Hickson here. Loved the way she portrayed herself as a benign doddery old lady, but really was razor sharp, she captured Miss Marple perfectly. Also loved Margaret Rutherford. Somehow, Julia McKenzie and Geraldine McKewan just didn't get it right.

Calendargirl Sat 15-Feb-20 07:53:19

MOnica

No, I realise that it is not a Miss Marple book, this did not stop ITV making a MM version, with Julia McKenzie in the role. Nicholas Parsons played the murdered priest.
I have just googled this info.

grumppa Sat 15-Feb-20 16:26:01

A rather odd thing happened towards the end of part one as Mark was walking across the fields to Much Deeping (why didn't he drive?). In one shot the image was reversed so that his shirt buttoned the wrong way and his breast pocket was on the right side of his jacket. Continuity cock-up or the influence of the witches? I think we should be told!

Callistemon Sat 15-Feb-20 16:29:56

It's a conspiracy!

I'm going to have another look, somehow I missed that. Perhaps I'd nodded off at that point.

sarahellenwhitney Sat 15-Feb-20 16:33:45

Didn't like the book although an AC fan. I will watch for no other reason wink than Rufus Sewell.

BlueBelle Sun 16-Feb-20 22:01:47

What a load of tripe

grumppa Sun 16-Feb-20 22:04:26

An excellent summary, BlueBelle.

supernannyjane Sun 16-Feb-20 22:06:12

Thought Rufus was looking slightly less florid tonight, bless him. Lovely neat ears too.

Pittcity Sun 16-Feb-20 22:07:57

I hope we weren't supposed to understand what was going on.

NfkDumpling Sun 16-Feb-20 22:08:19

Since I’ve never read the book, I just enjoyed it for what it was. And I did quite enjoy it. Good ending.

rubysong Sun 16-Feb-20 22:10:08

Was it set in the 1960s? I think it was. The witch with the green cord trousers was wearing a rather nice fairisle cardigan at one point and it had dropped shoulder sleeves. I'm just not sure that was a thing in the sixties. I would have expected raglan or set in sleeves at that date. I also think I spotted a field with big round bales and I don't think they were around then. Just me being picky!