Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Would I lie to you

(22 Posts)
overthehill Wed 25-Mar-20 19:12:32

DH and I roll up over this show. David Mitchell and Lee Mack are so cutting especially towards each other with their quick fire quips.

This got me thinking that I couldn't imagine women taking over the show and being as funny.

My reasoning for this is, I don't think women can be as insulting to each other in the way men can. Women of course can have insulting thoughts but would be hard pressed to use them even in a comedy setting. For instance could you imagine a women saying to another, "no wonder you're single with a face like yours" whereas Lee or David would have no qualms

MissAdventure Wed 25-Mar-20 19:23:59

They absolutely make the show, those two.

They're both so funny, but in such different ways. smile

DanniRae Wed 25-Mar-20 19:29:16

Mr R and I really love this show. Even if we have seen it before we are quite happy to watch the episode again grin

eazybee Wed 25-Mar-20 19:54:18

I enjoy seeing the other contestants, who are not quite so quick-witted, frequently helpless with laughter, and I think it is genuine.

Franbern Wed 25-Mar-20 20:24:34

One of my favourite tv programmes. I keep the ones on Dave recorded, and usually watch one for the last half an hour prior to going to bed. They cheer me up so much.

Hetty58 Wed 25-Mar-20 20:29:28

I love it - we really need a good laugh now!

Oopsadaisy3 Wed 25-Mar-20 20:30:03

They have some very funny ‘out takes ‘ on YouTube, especially the ones with Rob Bryson doing impersonations, cracks us up.

quizqueen Wed 25-Mar-20 20:38:00

I don't think women can do comedy, to be honest. I can't think of one comedienne who makes me laugh. What do you know, we aren't equal in everything but the BBC has to have its PC quota of non funny women on panel shows.

Coolgran65 Wed 25-Mar-20 20:57:29

quizqueen says she doesn't think women can do comedy and as I read this I agreed with her.

Then Marti Caine came to mind. I can recall that she was very funny. A long time ago.

Grannybags Wed 25-Mar-20 21:00:37

Love this show!

Have to admit I don't usually find women funny either

Ginny42 Wed 25-Mar-20 21:07:34

I love this programme. If I need cheering up I watch Mitchell's rants on you tube. Love the way Lee Mack ribs Mitchell as having no idea of how the other half live. They're both so sharp, few contestants can compete.

MissAdventure Wed 25-Mar-20 22:07:33

Funny, I was just thinking about Marti Caine a few weeks back.
I think she was perhaps the first woman to do a proper 'stand up' comedy act. (I'm probably wrong, but she is the first I can remember)

Her death seemed to pass without much of the fuss and endless interviews a lot of people have today.

fatgran57 Thu 26-Mar-20 04:41:46

I think women can do comedy very well.

Live at the Apollo has had some very good women stand-up comediennes.

Are you talking about women like French and Saunders, Victoria Wood. Tracey Ullman, Catherine Tate type women or just a Would I Lie to You sort of programme?

Ohmother Thu 26-Mar-20 05:20:54

I think that German guy Henning is hilarious when he’s on it.

The Unbelievable Truth on Radio 4 Sounds catch up is another favourite of mine.

Ginny42 Thu 26-Mar-20 06:00:00

Victoria Wood had a very appealing sense of humour. Such a wonderful talent lost too soon.

pensionpat Thu 26-Mar-20 08:51:18

The film Funny Cow is based on Marti Caine. Very good.

overthehill Fri 27-Mar-20 16:49:52

Fatgran57 I know there are good comedians who are women I like Sarah Milligan. I don't think women could carry off this show for the reasons I have stated above

Jane10 Fri 27-Mar-20 16:54:34

Sandi Toksvig and Aisling Bea are very funny. Susan Calman too.
There's no one like Victoria Wood sadly but I think women could easily head up these panel shows. Sandi effortlessly keeps control on QI and is often funnier than anyone else on the show.

SalsaQueen Fri 27-Mar-20 18:43:02

I like those two, in small doses. I see Lee Mack has tested positive for Covid-19 then.

Daisymae Fri 27-Mar-20 19:11:08

Women can't do comedy???

Victorian Wood
Dawn French
Jennifer Saunders
Sarah Milligan
Jo Brand etc.

I do find it odd that women put other women down so readily. Maybe they need the chance to show that they can be just as funny (funnier) than their male counterparts?

DanniRae Sat 28-Mar-20 13:01:24

I think that Victoria Wood is funnier than any male comic. She once wrote a sketch about her and Julie Walters in a shoe shop. She was a customer and Julie a really dotty shop assistant. My family and I have watched it many times and it still makes us laugh like mad. Some of the dialogue from it has passed into our family life.
As has already been said on here - it's a tragedy that she died so young sad

lovebeigecardigans1955 Sat 28-Mar-20 13:27:37

Perhaps women have a different sense of humour to some men which may not lend itself to the one-liners which appeal to you OP.
I can think of a few male comedians who aren't that funny.
Victoria Wood was great.
I think the late, great Joyce Grenfell said that she found it harder to be funny as she got older as she became kinder and perhaps less cutting. I loved her material, "George, don't do that." It was left to your imagination to think what he was doing - just a finger up his nose to prise a bogey out or something much worse.