Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

All Creatures Great & Small

(106 Posts)
grannyrebel7 Wed 02-Sept-20 10:17:53

Watched the first episode of this remake last night. I wasn't expecting it to be as good as the original one back in the 70s, but it was fantastic. I absolutely loved it. The characters were perfect, the animals, the beautiful scenes of the Yorkshire Dales everything! I would recommend it to anyone even if you don't like animals. There's a scene at the end where a calf is born after a very difficult birth and that reduced me to tears though. It's on channel 5 9pm on Tuesdays. My only complaint it should be Sunday night viewing.

CarolynSpartan Thu 10-Sept-20 18:54:09

Totally agree loved it first time around . I think this is a brilliant remake . I said to my husband should be on a Sunday night x

Ellianne Thu 10-Sept-20 19:30:28

^Diana Rigg plays Tricky Woo's mummy.*
I didn't know that Alexa until I read the other thread. Sad, but nice that she was working until recently.

Franbern Sun 13-Sept-20 13:40:34

I missed the first episode as I thought it was just repeats. Then recorded the second episode, and watched the first on Catch-up.
Absolutely, excellent, light entertanment at its best - just what we all need at this time.,

SueDonim Sun 13-Sept-20 22:25:53

I didn’t see the first series but I’ve just watched the first two episodes with my dd. We both loved it and will be watching the rest.

Is that beautiful dog a Golden Retriever? It’s huge!

Jaberwok Mon 14-Sept-20 13:01:58

No.not for me! Mrs Hall is far too young and behaves too much like a member of the family, Tristan is so dull and slightly morose, James? Siegfried okish, but not a patch on Robert Hardy. As for Mrs pompfrey? Oh no! Not a patch on the original.

Wheniwasyourage Mon 14-Sept-20 13:17:20

Watched it on catch-up after reading the good reviews and loved it! That's Tuesday evenings sorted then.

Ellianne Mon 14-Sept-20 13:24:19

Is that beautiful dog a Golden Retriever? It’s huge.
Ha ha, yes Sue, but they are so gentle. I've had five now, the first one used to carry our kids on his back and another one was called The Lion Dog by friends.
Not much room on the sofa though of an evening!

SueDonim Mon 14-Sept-20 14:09:47

I could see the sofa problem even on the TV, Elianne! grin They are gorgeous dogs. Our neighbour has one, he’s about five years old now, and a friend has another. They do seem to think they are eternal puppies though and need to sit on your lap!

MawB2 Wed 30-Sept-20 19:27:37

I am really enjoying this - the acting, the scenery, the dialogue and the situations.
It feels very authentic to me and in a way not unlike The Durrells (and not just because of the actor who plays Tristan))

phoenix Wed 30-Sept-20 19:39:30

MawB2 same here!

Why it's hidden away on Channel 5 on a Tuesday is a mystery.

aggie Wed 30-Sept-20 19:46:24

I just found that my Sky Planner hasn’t taped the last two episodes ?

Blinko Wed 30-Sept-20 20:05:41

I hope it's more than six episodes...

MayBee70 Wed 30-Sept-20 20:11:39

I’m loving it, too. It was very brave of them to remake an iconic series like ACGAS but they went for it and they’ve nailed it. Didn’t one channel make a series about James Herriottsstudent days that wasn’t all that good.

Grandma70s Wed 30-Sept-20 20:30:59

I was following Samuel West on Twitter while they were making this series. They had a lot of with endless rain when they were trying to film outdoor scenes.

I feel quite upset to think that next week is the final episode. I’m sure there will be another series, but when?

phoenix Wed 30-Sept-20 20:35:50

Does any one remember the Two Ronnies, where they once did a sign off along the lines of "And next week we will be featuring the memoirs of a disillusioned vet, entitled "All Creatures Grunt and Smell"?

Callistemon Wed 30-Sept-20 21:25:37

Still finding Tristan irritating rather than endearing. He doesn't have Peter Davison's charm.

Otherwise it's thoroughly enjoyable.

TwiceAsNice Wed 30-Sept-20 22:25:09

I have really enjoyed it all except I do find the actor playing Tristan irritating . He’s so lazy he really annoys me

SueDonim Thu 01-Oct-20 00:04:31

Grandma70 I noticed that in this week’s episode the show took place in rather wet surroundings. Still, it is Yorkshire.

In other news, my neighbours have acquired a gorgeous 12wk old Retriever puppy! She is absolutely beautiful and I need to come up with a Covid-rules-compliant reason to go and cuddle her. ?

DanniRae Thu 01-Oct-20 12:53:35

I get irritated by the (very young) housekeeper - she acts as if she owns the place and throws her weight about -"I will not put up with that kind of behaviour under my roof" she said to Tristan. Her roof? I don't think so!
And I agree Tristan is so annoying - but then he was as Lesley in "The Durrells"
So I am not sorry it is coming to an end - my enjoyment of it has come to an end too!!

Atqui Thu 01-Oct-20 14:30:36

What a refreshing change to have such a delightful programme to watch.Love it! I’m not too keen on the new Tristan , but apart from that Imthinkmthe casting is excellent. Remember the second Poldark series? Who knew that Aidan what’s his name could be as good as Robin Ellis?

Daddima Thu 01-Oct-20 14:33:39

Well, I have ‘ hung on in there’, but it’s still not for me. I don’t feel the changes made to the stories in the book ( and in the original TV series) served any purpose, like the inclusion of Mrs Hall’s son, and I agree she is much too prominent!
I can’t really take to any of the characters, but, again, this might be because I felt the previous actors captured them perfectly.

Furret Thu 01-Oct-20 14:35:26

As someone who used to be involved in the horse world, I had to laugh at James and the measuring stick. It’s straight out of real life, even today!

Callistemon Thu 01-Oct-20 14:39:07

DanniRae

I get irritated by the (very young) housekeeper - she acts as if she owns the place and throws her weight about -"I will not put up with that kind of behaviour under my roof" she said to Tristan. Her roof? I don't think so!
And I agree Tristan is so annoying - but then he was as Lesley in "The Durrells"
So I am not sorry it is coming to an end - my enjoyment of it has come to an end too!!

Oh, I really like Mrs Hall. She needs to keep them in order. I don't know how she finds time to do everything though, they neerclift a finger.

And she's not as young as she looks, the actress is mid-forties, believe it or not.

lemongrove Thu 01-Oct-20 14:39:49

Callistemon

Still finding Tristan irritating rather than endearing. He doesn't have Peter Davison's charm.

Otherwise it's thoroughly enjoyable.

That’s exactly what I think.Davison gave the character charm and self doubt as well as optimism.The new actor plays him as a hooray henry.
I don’t particularly like the new James Herriot either tbh but Sam West is wonderful as Siegfried.
The housekeeper has more prominence as a character in this new reworking, for some unknown reason.
All other actors are very good, and the scenery is the same?

Callistemon Thu 01-Oct-20 14:41:01

Why does autocorrect change things to weird words?
I noticed that it changed mid-forties to mid-thirties but I changed that back again.

Never lift a finger