Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

RIP David Crosby

(70 Posts)
NotAGran55 Fri 20-Jan-23 14:01:04

A part of my formative teens gone.

Hellogirl1 Fri 20-Jan-23 17:37:33

I`d never heard of David Crosby, but I HAVE heard of Crosby, Stills and Nash, but that wasn`t made clear at the beginning of the post.

Shinamae Fri 20-Jan-23 17:45:48

Grandma70s

Oreo

I Keep reading RIP’s about people I’ve barely heard of and even never heard of lately.What songs did he do?

I’ve never heard of him either.

Or me!!

Oldbat1 Fri 20-Jan-23 17:48:39

Love his music but he is/was a troubled man. He had a very distinctive voice. Fell out with all his bands over the years. Roger McGuinn of Byrds fame still comes on occasion to play solo in uk amazing musician. Wild Horses I love.

OxfordGran Fri 20-Jan-23 17:50:26

Oreo

I am calling you out for an unwarranted unpleasant post OxfordGran we’re not all interested in the same music and we aren’t all the same ages either.

Oreo, sigh, I was not around, when Mozart was making music but I sure appreciate his efforts -your comment is blatantlyageist, why so combative,

Visgir1 Fri 20-Jan-23 18:00:46

Ex boyfriend got me into C, S, N & Y.
So pleased he did wasn't my normal music. Loved the gentle style, Our House is a classic, thought Dave Crosby had serious troubles, surprise too he lasted so long. Phil Collins apparently paid for his Liver transplant.

Looking back, few old ex boyfriends introduced me to artists I and my girl friends didn't know.

Georgesgran Fri 20-Jan-23 18:29:25

When I saw David Crosby, CSNY came to mind (unless Bing had a famous son!) but I googled it, read his personal bit which was ‘interesting’ to say the least and posted how, surprisingly, he’d lived until 81.
A recent post about Mrmenno had me googling, but was of little interest to me, so I didn’t respond.
This isn’t a personal criticism of any GN, however, I cannot see the point in just saying ‘never heard of him/her/they/them/it, when the subject could be googled, possibly in less time.
Perhaps I’ve got too much time on my hands?

Dickens Fri 20-Jan-23 18:34:22

OxfordGran

Oreo

I Keep reading RIP’s about people I’ve barely heard of and even never heard of lately.What songs did he do?

Good Lord Oreo, isn’t this “revelling in your own ignorance” as in, better to keep silent and…

Yeah, but, no... but

... it's not an academic subject we're compelled to study, so "ignorance" of names in popular music is not really ignorance is it?

I'm sure a lot of intelligent, high achievers will get thro' life without ever knowing who this person was grin.

Riverwalk Fri 20-Jan-23 18:38:26

Yes, but it's rather odd to post on an RIP thread and say you haven't heard of him!

Why not just move onto something else which is what I do if I see a name I don't recognise.

Georgesgran Fri 20-Jan-23 18:39:38

On Sky Arts - Ch 130 now.

Riverwalk Fri 20-Jan-23 18:44:48

smile

Shinamae Fri 20-Jan-23 18:57:46

Riverwalk

Yes, but it's rather odd to post on an RIP thread and say you haven't heard of him!

Why not just move onto something else which is what I do if I see a name I don't recognise.

Not odd at all,I was interested, but I haven’t a clue who he was until reading the thread,certainly does not make me ignorant and I can read any thread I like .. without someone jumping in and telling me l shouldn’t be reading it…

Chardy Fri 20-Jan-23 22:10:29

Thanks Georgesgran, I'll try and find that on SkyGo tomorrow.
I was really sad when I heard (probably remembering the kid I was with all those hopes and aspirations in the late 60s/early 70s). As has already been said, soundtrack to my formative years. But his singing meant a lot to me, for whatever reason.
I came onto this thread hoping to have a bit of a reminisce, favourite songs, memories (anyone else remember their bit in the 'Woodstock' film? Lol) and find a philosophical debate about the meaning of ignorance - bit of a shame.
As someone who knows next to no-one in new films or current alternative comedians or Prem footballers, I ask long-suffering DD "Should I know.." or "When would I have seen X?". Or I google them.
When someone has died, maybe choosing words carefully is what we normally do, as people are sad.

Callistemon21 Fri 20-Jan-23 22:32:16

Oreo

I am calling you out for an unwarranted unpleasant post OxfordGran we’re not all interested in the same music and we aren’t all the same ages either.

Not sure why you would post on a thread about someone you've never heard of and weren't interested in anyway.
🤔

Oreo Fri 20-Jan-23 22:39:01

You know what Callistemon? I had hoped that somebody would say who he was and about his songs, that’s all angry
Ye Gods what’s the matter with some people!

Callistemon21 Fri 20-Jan-23 22:41:55

I remember spending a summer going out with someone who loved playing cricket and also loved The Byrds.
Mr Tambourine Man was preferable to the cricket!

And, of course, then CSN+Y

RIP David Crosby

Callistemon21 Fri 20-Jan-23 22:42:38

Oreo

You know what Callistemon? I had hoped that somebody would say who he was and about his songs, that’s all angry
Ye Gods what’s the matter with some people!

Google, Oreo it is really useful.
😄

Callistemon21 Fri 20-Jan-23 22:43:24

Ye Gods what’s the matter with some people!

Well, that's what I thought to but was too polite to post it.

Callistemon21 Fri 20-Jan-23 22:46:17

Oreo

DP used to have a Bob Dylan CD with Mr Tambourine man on which us why I know that song, it’s really catchy and now it’s my ear worm for the day.

It still drives me mad as an earworm sometimes but brings back memories of that endless summer of cricket ....

Oreo Fri 20-Jan-23 22:52:55

Well, I shall just say Charming! Once again.
What a sin not to have heard of David Crosby ( other posters hadn’t either) and to ask about his songs.

Glorianny Fri 20-Jan-23 23:23:49

The soundtrack of my student days.
The Byrds Mr Tambourine Man & Eight Miles High
Crosby Stills & Nash (&Young)-Love the one you're with. Teach your children well.
Well worth a listen Oreo www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkaKwXddT_I

Shinamae Fri 20-Jan-23 23:29:21

Oreo

Well, I shall just say Charming! Once again.
What a sin not to have heard of David Crosby ( other posters hadn’t either) and to ask about his songs.

Yes Oreo,you are a very naughty girl,very naughty indeed,how dare you come on this thread?!!! 😁😂😂😂😂😂😂

Kalu Fri 20-Jan-23 23:33:56

So sad, the end of another era. Loved the Byrds, CS&N, Neil Young and the Steve Miller band etc..so many good artists that were all part of my youth.

Can’t believe Neil Young’s Harvest was 50:yrs ago SueD. I bought it when it came out….I was 22!

Oreo Fri 20-Jan-23 23:34:30

Shinamae 😂yeah I know, what a crime hey?
Thanks Glorianna will have a listen to it tomorrow, off to bed now to read until I fall asleep.smile

Doodledog Fri 20-Jan-23 23:47:44

Glorianny

The soundtrack of my student days.
The Byrds Mr Tambourine Man & Eight Miles High
Crosby Stills & Nash (&Young)-Love the one you're with. Teach your children well.
Well worth a listen Oreo www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkaKwXddT_I

That’s the track I always think of when CSN&Y come to mind. That and Love The One You’re With.

CallmeEsme Sat 21-Jan-23 00:24:34

Loved this music in the 70s along with Carol King and all the other great artists of the era.
Named my eldest son after Graham Nash and my second son after Neil Young.
Still enjoy listening to their music