Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Channel 4 tonight 9pm NZ drama that sounds right up my street!

(70 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Wed 20-Nov-24 16:13:02

“Every now and then, New Zealand produces a corking television drama – Top of the Lake, say, or (with caveats) Outrageous Fortune and The Luminaries. After the Party could just be the best one yet, pivoting on a beautifully nuanced he said/she said scenario and a very fine central performance. It concerns Wellington teacher Penny Wilding (Robyn Malcolm), who is respected, unorthodox and straight-talking, without falling into the usual clichéd traps of those traits. Her description of online pornography before a classroom of teenagers could be essential viewing for concerned parents everywhere. She is as stunned as her daughter Tara Canton) is thrilled by the unexpected return of her ex-husband Philip (Peter Mullan, typically jovial and dangerous), five years after he left in the wake of a transgression at the titular drunken, multi-generational party which gradually comes into focus. Provocative and exasperating, Malcolm’s layered, complex performance is reminiscent of Kate Winslet’s in Mare of Easttown, currying no favour with the audience yet commanding our attention throughout. Continuing tomorrow and boxsetted online, this is TV made for bingeing.”

Sparklefizz Sun 24-Nov-24 11:32:42

Allira

I've just checked and it's six episodes.
Now, if it was three or even four, I might persevere with it, but it's one of those dramas that leaves you feeling anxious and quite depressed.

I need something quirky and uplifting, not dismal.

If you've got Netflix watch "Joy" about the invention of IVF and the women who desperately wanted a baby. It's a dramatisation with a great cast.

pascal30 Sun 24-Nov-24 11:16:06

Allira

BlueBelle

I haven’t t liked it so far. Don’t like her one bit I’ll carry on
I ve been wrong before but so far not into it at all

Well, I'm exhausted just watching her.

She reminds me of someone I knew, can't quite remember who 🤔

I find her very unappealing too.. very abrasive and I wish she'd brush her hair..

However her sex talk was genius.. I hope we have real life teachers over here that replicate it..

Calendargirl Sun 24-Nov-24 11:04:25

It was the name of the GS that alerted me to the fact he was a boy- ‘Walt’ or ‘Walty’.

Having said that, could well be either now, the way names are used.

Poppyred Sun 24-Nov-24 11:00:47

Will give it a go, thanks.

Allira Sun 24-Nov-24 10:58:07

I've just checked and it's six episodes.
Now, if it was three or even four, I might persevere with it, but it's one of those dramas that leaves you feeling anxious and quite depressed.

I need something quirky and uplifting, not dismal.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 24-Nov-24 10:43:08

Ah.

Sparklefizz Sun 24-Nov-24 10:20:24

I don't think she was turning a blind eye .... I think all those previous red flags fell into place, Calendargirl when she thought back on them.

The red flags fell into place for me regarding my ex husband once I knew for sure he was having an affair ... all that "being called into work", "forgetting" to fill up with petrol and popping out for it, etc etc It all made sense.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 24-Nov-24 08:50:10

The 3 year old with long hair past their shoulder blades confused me. Boy or girl? At least the pronoun ‘boy’ was used not ‘them/they’ so my confusion was short lived!

Calendargirl Sat 23-Nov-24 21:14:56

I haven’t binge watched it, so no idea of the outcome.

It seems that even before this incident, she picked up on lots of ‘red flags’ re her husband’s behaviour around young boys.

Did she just turn a blind eye, and it all came to a head at this party?

Is she now concerned for the safety of the grandson with him?

What do all their colleagues and friends make of it all?

Divided loyalties, it appears.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sat 23-Nov-24 21:08:17

I think so Calendargirl. She’s a ‘no topic off limits’ woman. Confident. Outspoken. And (I think) just plain wrong. I think something else is lurking beneath the waters here.

Sparklefizz Sat 23-Nov-24 20:41:59

Yes, I wondered that too Calendargirl

Calendargirl Sat 23-Nov-24 20:38:59

Why do we see her modelling in the nude for art classes?

What has that got to do with anything?

Is it to show what a liberal and free thinking spirit she is?

confused

Allira Sat 23-Nov-24 20:07:13

J52

Allira

BlueBelle

I haven’t t liked it so far. Don’t like her one bit I’ll carry on
I ve been wrong before but so far not into it at all

Well, I'm exhausted just watching her.

She reminds me of someone I knew, can't quite remember who 🤔

Dreadful, acting and script. I predict she’ll be proved wrong in the end.
Glad I didn’t teach in NZ if this is the standard,

It is fiction.

Calendargirl Sat 23-Nov-24 20:06:53

I don’t like her either.

In fact, don’t take to any of the characters.

Find the whole thing rather creepy actually.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sat 23-Nov-24 20:03:49

I’m loving it.
The tension is building nicely. I’m also really enjoying seeing Wellington. It’s very hilly! The houses look so different to ours in the UK. A lot of dark wood inside. Like a step back 30 years. No contemporary greys here! And the coastline, the beach, the birds and the dolphins are delightful.

J52 Fri 22-Nov-24 20:23:00

Allira

BlueBelle

I haven’t t liked it so far. Don’t like her one bit I’ll carry on
I ve been wrong before but so far not into it at all

Well, I'm exhausted just watching her.

She reminds me of someone I knew, can't quite remember who 🤔

Dreadful, acting and script. I predict she’ll be proved wrong in the end.
Glad I didn’t teach in NZ if this is the standard,

ferry23 Fri 22-Nov-24 20:20:03

I struggled through Episode 1, I quite liked her as a character but everything else left me a bit cold.

But on the strength of all the positives on here I'll keep going - something to watch while we all batten down the hatches over the weekend!

Allira Fri 22-Nov-24 20:03:22

BlueBelle

I haven’t t liked it so far. Don’t like her one bit I’ll carry on
I ve been wrong before but so far not into it at all

Well, I'm exhausted just watching her.

She reminds me of someone I knew, can't quite remember who 🤔

BlueBelle Fri 22-Nov-24 20:00:27

I haven’t t liked it so far. Don’t like her one bit I’ll carry on
I ve been wrong before but so far not into it at all

Aldom Fri 22-Nov-24 19:09:11

I binge watched this drama.
Keeps you guessing to the end.
Excellent viewing.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 22-Nov-24 18:24:38

😊😊

Allegretto Fri 22-Nov-24 18:04:13

Sorry - I’ve just spotted the title! Silly me!

Allegretto Fri 22-Nov-24 18:03:37

What channel is this on, please?

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 22-Nov-24 17:37:10

It’s really good drama isn’t it?

The Spinoff reviewer Duncan Greive called the show "queasy, morally complex and NZ's best TV drama in years... a dark, tense and highly provocative drama which will rattle uneasily around your mind for days".

The Guardian reviewer Luke Buckmaster called it "one of the greatest performances in any TV show in years".

Kylie Northover of The Sydney Morning Herald gave the series five stars, calling it "what might be the best New Zealand drama ever produced".

Housecraftandcommunitystudies Thu 21-Nov-24 22:19:28

I loved Top of the Lake