Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Amandaland.

(97 Posts)
Calendargirl Wed 05-Feb-25 21:31:37

Just watched this, a spin off from ‘Motherland’.

Oh dear, not funny.

Better left in the past, I think.

Eloethan Wed 12-Feb-25 23:20:29

I looked for the Cockfields and realised I had actually seen the first series, which I had really enjoyed.

So I started to watch the second series. I couldn't adjust to the change of two of the characters- the girlfriend, initially played by Diane Morgan, and the father/step father, originally played by Bobbie Ball (sadly, now deceased). I didn't like the two replacement actors, particularly the father. That put me off, but I will persevere for a bit longer.

Churchview Tue 11-Feb-25 21:02:05

I really couldn't adjust from Motherland and almost gave up after the first episode. The lack of anything else worth watching drove me to continue with episode two and I was hooked. I loved the camping episode. Can't wait for series two now. Joanna Lumley really is very funny.

Neilspurgeon0 Tue 11-Feb-25 15:09:33

I lasted less than five minutes, which I normally give any new thing, but this was SO dreadful and SO unfunny I just couldn’t take any more - and I Loved Motherland

Rainbow1235 Tue 11-Feb-25 14:34:15

Merlotgran grin

merlotgran Tue 11-Feb-25 13:34:00

Rainbow1235

Plus Samuel Anderson is extremely easy on the eye wink

Oh yes.
Did I forget to mention that??
🤗🤭

keepingquiet Tue 11-Feb-25 13:31:15

Watched the first episode- Joanna Lumley is a great addition so I may watch more.

It made me laugh- which is something these days!

surfsup Tue 11-Feb-25 13:23:48

I finished it last night and it does get better but I can tell Graham Lineham’s comic genius hasn’t had a hand in it.

MayBee70 Tue 11-Feb-25 13:16:02

NonGrannyMoll

I haven't yet managed to watch an entire episode. I didn't think it would be funny and it isn't. Or, rather, it isn't my cup of tea. Pratfalls, slapstick and grown people pretending to be gormless never were my thing.

There’s a poignancy about the new characters as you start to know their back stories. Which, to me,is the secret of a good comedy.

NonGrannyMoll Tue 11-Feb-25 12:07:44

I haven't yet managed to watch an entire episode. I didn't think it would be funny and it isn't. Or, rather, it isn't my cup of tea. Pratfalls, slapstick and grown people pretending to be gormless never were my thing.

Rainbow1235 Tue 11-Feb-25 11:58:24

Plus Samuel Anderson is extremely easy on the eye wink

ViceVersa Tue 11-Feb-25 11:24:35

I've now binged the whole of Amandaland and I enjoyed it. No, it's not the same as Motherland and I do miss the likes of Liz and Kevin, but I liked it and I also like some of the new characters too. It's easy watching - sometimes you just need a bit of light relief, something you don't need to think too hard about.

merlotgran Tue 11-Feb-25 10:27:16

I’ve watched three episodes of Amandaland and I think it’s better than Motherland.

Probably because Joanna Lumley is now a main character and Samuel Anderson who plays the downstairs neighbour is very funny.

Sara1954 Tue 11-Feb-25 10:06:49

MayBee, I don’t think I’m going to really understand it, the characters are horrible, and I don’t get what’s going on, I might have to give up again

MayBee70 Tue 11-Feb-25 08:25:57

I had to watch Am I Being Unreasonable series one twice as I couldn’t work out what was going on. ( but then that’s not unusual for me). It’s a bit of a shock after watching much gentler things like The Cockfields.

Sara1954 Tue 11-Feb-25 05:56:44

I am currently trying to watch, Am I Being Unreasonable? again, I tried before when my daughter was raving about it, but gave up after a couple of episodes, got a bit further this time, but definitely not enjoying it, just waiting to see if it eventually clicks with me.
On the other hand, I think the Cockfields is very cleverly written

vegansrock Tue 11-Feb-25 04:48:07

I’m loving this series and also looking forward to watching Am I being Unreasonable series 2 and Boarders. Plus there’s Hacks new series on Now and a new White Lotus coming up. Lots of TV to watch in cold miserable February.

MayBee70 Tue 11-Feb-25 00:28:45

I’ve been rather taken with Ben Rufus Greens character in The Cockfields and have found out that he has is on utube in something called The Washing Up Club. The Cockcrofts reminds me a it of Detectorists with it’s folky soundtrack. I’m just watching an episode in which they have a power cut and Ray’s got a LED head light like mine. I’m beginning to worry if I really get on my kids nerves on the rare occasion that they stay with me.

LaCrepescule Mon 10-Feb-25 08:49:47

I thought I’d watch it for Joanna Lumley but have switched off after one and a half episodes. It’s just cringe…and not in a good way.
I found it obvious and deeply unfunny, cliche after cliche.

Eloethan Mon 10-Feb-25 00:26:37

Thanks MayBee.

Rainbow Thank you. I watched the remaining episodes today and enjoyed them. I wonder if there will be another series.

MayBee70 Sat 08-Feb-25 15:05:51

Calendargirl

I thought the Cockfields was similar to that ‘Here We Go’ so called comedy with Alison Steadman and her family.

I realise it’s not, as she isn’t in it.

So the Cockfields is better than that one, I take it?

I’m loving The Cockfields, although the different actors in series two were a bit of a shock. I think it’s a much nicer, gentler version of Here We Go, which I never took to, even though it has a lot of my favourite actors in.

westendgirl Fri 07-Feb-25 14:56:18

Loved it.

Calendargirl Fri 07-Feb-25 14:50:30

I thought the Cockfields was similar to that ‘Here We Go’ so called comedy with Alison Steadman and her family.

I realise it’s not, as she isn’t in it.

So the Cockfields is better than that one, I take it?

MayBee70 Fri 07-Feb-25 14:29:28

It’s on BBC catchup! I’ve never heard of it. That’s tonight’s viewing sorted. Thanks Usedtobeblonde! Got some of my favourite actors in it.

Eloethan Fri 07-Feb-25 13:55:42

What channel is the Cockfields on?

Eloethan Fri 07-Feb-25 13:50:27

I was so looking forward to this because I loved Motherland. I have seen the first two episodes and didn't find them at all funny. Maybe because there was an antidote to Amanda's horrible behaviour, in the shape of Liz's fabulous put downs and Kevin's niceness. Seeing Amanda's self-absorption and treatment of her friend leaves a very nasty taste (though it's hardly surprising she is not very loyal and kind, given her ghastly mother - yes, I know it's not real!).

|I thought I wouldn't bother any more but as Rainbow says it gets better, I'll give it another try.