Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

The Salt Path (The Film)

(333 Posts)
TerriBull Tue 03-Jun-25 19:21:49

I think there have been quite a few discussions on GN about the book since its publication. We went to see the film this afternoon, mixed reviews, not an overwhelming 5 stars from some critics. I loved it, found it very affecting in the portrayal of the depth of Ray and Moth's relationship, a rock solid marriage facing insurmountable problems, losing their home, subsequently made homeless, related in flashbacks. Practically penniless bar the meagre weekly benefit they received drawn along the way, whilst they set off on what would seem an insane challenge given Moth's serious and rare illness. Set backs en route, not least of all the elements wreaking havoc on their flimsy tent whilst they undertake the daunting, but beautiful south west coastal walk, I love that part of the world one of the reasons that drew me to the book in the first place.. Fantastic acting particularly from Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs ultimately uplifting.

meddijess Mon 07-Jul-25 16:06:12

Just thought you might be interested in this article in the Observer on Sunday:

'Only last week, I was having lunch when The Salt Path came up in conversation. ‘That’s the one about the woman with the terminally ill husband who went off round Cornwall, wasn’t it?’ said one friend. I responded, perhaps a little heartlessly: ‘Yeah, and then the husband weirdly failed to die and she got a couple of sequels out of it.’

There’s nothing we Brits love more than a story about an underdog battling adversity and the inextinguishable resilience of the human spirit

The twinge of self-reproach I felt then has evaporated. The Observer yesterday carried a report into the background of that book’s author, Raynor Winn, and her husband Moth (real names Sally and Tim Walker), and discovered that many details in her memoir were, to put it delicately, not quite as she claimed.

The inciting incident for The Salt Path was the couple finding themselves homeless and destitute after their ‘forever home’ was taken from them, Wynn wrote, when they invested in a friend’s company which failed – and that faithless friend somehow won a court case assigning their house to him.

The Observer’s reporter Chloe Hadjimatheou, however, discovered evidence that the real reason the Walkers lost their house is that while working as a book-keeper Sally had defrauded the small company she worked for out of £64,000; and that the house became collateral on a loan she took out to reimburse her victims in order to prevent criminal charges being preferred against her. And it appears that even while – according to The Salt Path – the couple were left after the loss of their house with no option but to wild camp in the UK, they owned a property in rural France.

Since then public records have shown five county court judgments against the Walkers between 2011 and 2014, at least one of which came four years before the publication of that bestselling book. A local garage owner who says they still owe him nearly £800 asked the paper’s reporter plaintively: ‘If you see them, can you tell them to pay me? I think they can afford it now.’

As for Tim Walker’s ‘miraculous’ recovery from the degenerative brain disease his wife claimed he had – corticobasal degeneration, or CBD, a particularly savage neurological affliction in the same family as Parkinson’s – the Observer spoke to no fewer than nine specialists in CBD and they are reported as being unanimously ‘sceptical about the length of time he has had it, his lack of acute symptoms and his apparent ability to reverse them’. One said simply that the story ‘does not pass the sniff test’.'

Interesting!

icanhandthemback Mon 07-Jul-25 16:07:58

Kayteetay1

Not sure if you’ve read the book judging by your comments and suspect you are not speaking from experience regarding homelessness. Believe me you cannot present yourself to the local council and be given a home - those days are long gone. My niece - a single parent was evicted from her private rented property because her landlord could get a higher rent from a new tenant. There is no safeguarding against rogue landlord behaviour such as this. My niece and great niece are now homeless and relying on family and friends to safeguard their belongings and provide somewhere to stay. 1000s are finding themselves homeless through no fault of their own. The welfare state cannot cope with demand. The cinder path is a heartwarming story of love and adventure and I found Ray and Moth to be strong and inspirational characters who overcame the dire circumstances they found themselves in. Highly recommend reading Landlines which is the follow on from the Salt Path.

You need to read the Newspaper articles about this couple. They are not as they seem. The Observer was absolutely categorically sure they were fraudsters and would not have published without verification because they could be sued uphill and down dale for the allegations they make. The couple, the publishers and the film maker would have the money to proceed with litigation so The Observer would have been more careful than they would be with the lowly Jo Public.

62Granny Mon 07-Jul-25 16:10:03

There was an interesting article in yesterday's Observer with regard to the back story to this film and it is not very complimentary about the Author. It is called " The Real Salt Path - how the couple behind a bestseller left a trail of debt and deceit"
Sorry I can share the link as my DD sent it to me on Whatsapp.
I probably will watch it when it comes on Netflix or one of the other streaming channels as I like Gillian Anderson too.

eddiecat78 Mon 07-Jul-25 16:10:33

Does nobody read previous posts in a thread?
The Observer article has been referred to many many times now

Fosha Mon 07-Jul-25 16:12:15

I saw the film (didn’t read the book) — SO much puffing and panting, after a while my son and I just couldn’t stop giggling —- apologies to other cinema goers! We both thought that Gillian Isaacs’ performance came across as characterless — we found we felt no warmth towards the character, which seemed unusual and curious. Also the story was bizarre — their attitude to the children, the fact that they apparently only had one — ONE — person in the world who was willing to offer to house them temporarily (why on earth didn’t they have any friends?? Family??)… Also, the Moth character clearly had some impressive skills, as shown by his performance as ‘travelling storyteller’ — so why was he not employed or self-employed? I sent my son a link to the Observer scoop yesterday and he was fascinated — he said “we KNEW there was something fishy going on!!’

MayBee70 Mon 07-Jul-25 16:12:38

eddiecat78

Does nobody read previous posts in a thread?
The Observer article has been referred to many many times now

I don’t think they do. Having said that medijess’s post is a very good précis of the article for people who don’t like to click on links.

Cardriver Mon 07-Jul-25 16:17:36

Reputable investigations published today (BBC amongst others) have now found that the story is untrue - and specialists have questioned the medical diagnosis.
The names are false and the woman stole money from her employer amongst others. People in Wales are still waiting to be paid

LucyAnna5 Mon 07-Jul-25 16:22:00

eddiecat78

Does nobody read previous posts in a thread?
The Observer article has been referred to many many times now

Glad you said that! Thought I was going mad! So many people starting their post with “Well, there was an article in……” RTT! as they say on MN!

ACDC Mon 07-Jul-25 16:28:03

There have been reports in The Observer which have now appeared on bbc.news.co.uk see attached screenshots. I had intended to see the film but having read these news reports I will definitely not see it.

Barbadosbelle Mon 07-Jul-25 16:36:17

.

Glad you saw a film you enjoyed but please don't believe it - or the book.

In real life they are a couple of grifters who have lied, stolen and cheated leading to horrendous problems for others. His illness (CBD) is also contrived as no-one with his supposed illness could have survived as long as he claims.

Do a little research. Read the articles about them. The Times. The Guardian. The Observer. Many others.

Enjoy the book and film as a work of fiction - but do understand that that is all it is.
.

fancythat Mon 07-Jul-25 16:39:04

LucyAnna5

eddiecat78

Does nobody read previous posts in a thread?
The Observer article has been referred to many many times now

Glad you said that! Thought I was going mad! So many people starting their post with “Well, there was an article in……” RTT! as they say on MN!

I am amazed about how bad it is on GN as well.
Sometimes even on sensitive threads.

Barbadosbelle Mon 07-Jul-25 16:45:26

Terribull

It really is rather easy to do some research! Google is your friend.

The main newspapers have also exposed them as liars, thieves and grifters - including The Times, The Observer and The Guardian.
.

Juliecymru Mon 07-Jul-25 16:59:44

observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-real-salt-path-how-the-couple-behind-a-bestseller-left-a-trail-of-debt-and-deceit
Oh dear.

mokryna Mon 07-Jul-25 17:01:17

There is a huge discussion on MS, so much so a 2nd thread had to be created.

Glenfinnan Mon 07-Jul-25 17:10:04

I enjoyed the book .. but recently their story has been discredited! Not sure who to believe.. perhaps just enjoy the entertainment of the film!

Zumba369 Mon 07-Jul-25 17:18:24

I revised my positive opinion of the book after reading this article in The Observer yesterday observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-salt-path-whats-in-the-book-and-what-the-observer-has-found

Primrose53 Mon 07-Jul-25 17:22:23

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE read the thread.
We all know these fake adventurers have been exposed by The Observer investigative journalists. A GNetter told us this early yesterday morning.

There are now countless links to it on this thread as well as to a YouTube Video and other sources.

As someone said on another forum, wouldn’t it be great if the two actors involved starred in another film about Raynor and Moth (or whatever names they are currently using.) How they duped the public, publishers, film makers, TV chat shows, etc and how they were not exposed much earlier. That really would be worth watching! 🤣

MollyNew Mon 07-Jul-25 17:41:15

I saw Raynor on the One Show and the story didn't interest me at the time but it does now! How can someone make up a story like this, generate loads of publicity, make a film and not expect to get found out? My son says she probably doesn't care as she's made plenty of money out of it, which I suppose was the object of the exercise. Apparently, they own a property in France too. Truth is often stranger than fiction.

PamQS Mon 07-Jul-25 17:52:47

I'll tell you what absolutely gets on my nerves, it's TV programmes with names like 'Help! We bought a village!' Making out that watching people struggling against their circumstances is entertaining. I've never seen that particular programme, but anything set in a chateau seems to come into the same category!

Carolmed1950 Mon 07-Jul-25 18:10:50

If you read the Observer acticle from yesterday, it tells a totally different story, sadly. I was disappointed and felt so let down although did think it remarkable that Moth was still around. Presumably they have paid all their debts now.

observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-real-salt-path-how-the-couple-behind-a-bestseller-left-a-trail-of-debt-and-deceit

merlotgran Mon 07-Jul-25 18:17:26

Carolmed1950

If you read the Observer acticle from yesterday, it tells a totally different story, sadly. I was disappointed and felt so let down although did think it remarkable that Moth was still around. Presumably they have paid all their debts now.

observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-real-salt-path-how-the-couple-behind-a-bestseller-left-a-trail-of-debt-and-deceit

Dear God!

As they say on Mumsnet,
RTFT!!

MayBee70 Mon 07-Jul-25 18:27:01

Finding Hildasay is probably a much better and more truthful book and I must buy it. At least I know that Christian and Jet did do the walk because they actually walked past me one day but I didn’t realise who they were!

Robin202 Mon 07-Jul-25 18:31:11

Has anyone not seen what has subsequently been written about the Salt Path, that it was based on lies? Here’s the article from the Observer. observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-real-salt-path-how-the-couple-behind-a-bestseller-left-a-trail-of-debt-and-deceit

merlotgran Mon 07-Jul-25 18:32:22

Robin202

Has anyone not seen what has subsequently been written about the Salt Path, that it was based on lies? Here’s the article from the Observer. observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-real-salt-path-how-the-couple-behind-a-bestseller-left-a-trail-of-debt-and-deceit

😩😩😩

Iam64 Mon 07-Jul-25 18:39:45

Robin202

Has anyone not seen what has subsequently been written about the Salt Path, that it was based on lies? Here’s the article from the Observer. observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-real-salt-path-how-the-couple-behind-a-bestseller-left-a-trail-of-debt-and-deceit

As merlotgran said at 18.17 today —+- as they say on mumsnet RTFT

Primrose at 17.22 spelled it out and (maybe a first for both of us) I agree with you Primrose. The Observer’s investigative journalism exposed these two yesterday. Keep up at the back