Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

The Salt Path (The Film)

(333 Posts)
TerriBull Tue 03-Jun-25 19:21:49

I think there have been quite a few discussions on GN about the book since its publication. We went to see the film this afternoon, mixed reviews, not an overwhelming 5 stars from some critics. I loved it, found it very affecting in the portrayal of the depth of Ray and Moth's relationship, a rock solid marriage facing insurmountable problems, losing their home, subsequently made homeless, related in flashbacks. Practically penniless bar the meagre weekly benefit they received drawn along the way, whilst they set off on what would seem an insane challenge given Moth's serious and rare illness. Set backs en route, not least of all the elements wreaking havoc on their flimsy tent whilst they undertake the daunting, but beautiful south west coastal walk, I love that part of the world one of the reasons that drew me to the book in the first place.. Fantastic acting particularly from Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs ultimately uplifting.

Sago Mon 07-Jul-25 10:54:22

I read the two books by Chris Lewis who walked 19,000 miles around the coast of Britain.
He raised £500,000 for SSAFA.

He didn’t write as eloquently as Walker/Winn but he was brutally honest, I would highly recommend his two books.

25Avalon Mon 07-Jul-25 10:33:30

Most gransnetters seem to have sussed this out. Must admit I was a bit shocked that this couple aren’t what I first thought.

Iam64 Mon 07-Jul-25 10:27:57

This couple will be subjected to having every aspect of their lives investigated. There may be books and movies made about them.
I found the comments from neurologists about short life expectancy for people with the diagnosis Moth had. About six years, he’s alive and seems well 18 years post diagnosis.
I read they have adult children. I expect journalists to knock their doors
What an unedifying mess

Boz Mon 07-Jul-25 09:55:43

The name Moth irritated me; not credible.They probably did not even do the walk and she stitched together a fantasy tale to make money.
Did anyone ever wonder why she came across as 'shy' when interviewed - now revealed as sly deceitful mendacity.

J52 Mon 07-Jul-25 09:51:24

eazybee

Very frosty comment in the DT, via their lawyers:

" Today's Observer article is highly misleading. We are taking legal advice and won't be making any further comment at this time."
Umm.
Look out for all the book copies in charity shops any time soon.

I suppose it was the only thing they can say under the circumstances.

eazybee Mon 07-Jul-25 09:25:30

Very frosty comment in the DT, via their lawyers:

" Today's Observer article is highly misleading. We are taking legal advice and won't be making any further comment at this time."
Umm.
Look out for all the book copies in charity shops any time soon.

merlotgran Mon 07-Jul-25 09:18:03

I’m supposed to be going to see the film on Thursday but I’m now having second thoughts.
Having read online news articles and this thread I don’t think I’ll enjoy it.
As somebody said upthread, it has similarities with Capt. Sir Tom Moore’s daughter.

Retread Mon 07-Jul-25 08:23:54

*nom-de-plume

Retread Mon 07-Jul-25 08:08:04

I was musing on how one would choose the name Raynor Winn if you wanted a non-de-plume … rain or wind?

And the more I think about it, how odd to embrace so much publicity. I’d have kept my head well down!

dragonfly46 Sun 06-Jul-25 22:12:21

I read about them in The Observer. I always thought the story was far fetched but didn’t really they were con artists.

Allira Sun 06-Jul-25 22:01:15

MayBee70

She could have written the book as a work of fiction and stayed anonymous. It would still have sold well. But maybe she needed the back story to get a publisher and then got caught up in the lie. And then, as I said earlier, started to believe it herself? It's all very odd. I often wonder about all the people that get let down when famous people declare themselves bankrupt and then bounce back again leaving a trail of financial carnage behind them.

But maybe she needed the back story to get a publisher and then got caught up in the lie.

No, she was due to be arrested and disappeared. Changed names and scarpered.

glammagran Sun 06-Jul-25 21:49:21

Today, The Sunday Times has published an article about this couple. It seems they are not quite who they say they are. I myself have no comment myself as I’ve neither read the book or seen the film.

MayBee70 Sun 06-Jul-25 21:35:12

She could have written the book as a work of fiction and stayed anonymous. It would still have sold well. But maybe she needed the back story to get a publisher and then got caught up in the lie. And then, as I said earlier, started to believe it herself? It's all very odd. I often wonder about all the people that get let down when famous people declare themselves bankrupt and then bounce back again leaving a trail of financial carnage behind them.

Allira Sun 06-Jul-25 21:11:22

Primrose53

Throughout the first book she (Raynor/Sally) made such a lot of how they had been badly let down, how life was so unfair etc. she sounded pretty convincing too. It niggled at me though because if your husband is genuinely very ill would you drag him off on a massive walk with a flimsy tent and thin sleeping bags and, of course, hardly any money?

Can anybody actually prove they did this walk?

Perhaps the people they stole from or who gave them freebies on the way?

Primrose53 Sun 06-Jul-25 21:08:25

Throughout the first book she (Raynor/Sally) made such a lot of how they had been badly let down, how life was so unfair etc. she sounded pretty convincing too. It niggled at me though because if your husband is genuinely very ill would you drag him off on a massive walk with a flimsy tent and thin sleeping bags and, of course, hardly any money?

Can anybody actually prove they did this walk?

Tess46 Sun 06-Jul-25 19:39:57

I agree with Monica, cheating is their normal so they won’t get what the fuss is about. They will have been scamming all their lives and not had a conscience about it so making amends isn’t something they are likely to do. What they have done should be a criminal offence so when found guilty they will have plenty of time to write their next book from HMP Wherever!

M0nica Sun 06-Jul-25 19:09:11

Sago

It will be interesting to see what comes out of the woodwork.

Apparently all this came about because Raynor stole from an employer.

However even if they are fraudulent many thousands of us have enjoyed the book and now the film!

I’m sure they will find a way to make amends.

You are very trusting Sago people like this will find every reason in the world not to repay people. They will dodge and duck and if all else fails, go and live somewhere else, on their plot in France for example or a nice new flat on the Algarve.

Nelli123 Sun 06-Jul-25 19:04:55

I read the first book and ever since I have not quite bought the story. It was their attitude towards those better off, also sneaking out of the camp site and not paying, stealing food, etc. Also the claim that Moth's health gradually improved just because of walking. We happened to spot them at Par railway station a couple of years ago and you would not think there was anything wrong with him at all, a very strapping, healthy-looking man.

Franski Sun 06-Jul-25 18:55:55

It's extraordinarily audacious of them to put themselves out there - on breakfast TV, interviews, red carpet- and not think any of the people from the past who knew the truth would speak up. What did they think was going to happen??

Allira Sun 06-Jul-25 18:49:39

Sago

It will be interesting to see what comes out of the woodwork.

Apparently all this came about because Raynor stole from an employer.

However even if they are fraudulent many thousands of us have enjoyed the book and now the film!

I’m sure they will find a way to make amends.

I’m sure they will find a way to make amends.

Not everyone is as good-natured, Sago!

Anyway, too late for Martin Hemmings, he died in 2012 although his widow is still alive.

Ros Hemmings remembers how deeply her husband was affected by the episode. “It absolutely destroyed him because he was a very trusting, kind person,” she says.

Former staff described Martin, who died in 2012, as a cheerful, warm and generous character.

observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-real-salt-path-how-the-couple-behind-a-bestseller-left-a-trail-of-debt-and-deceit

fancythat Sun 06-Jul-25 18:45:21

I’m sure they will find a way to make amends.

Do theives make amends?

Washerwoman Sun 06-Jul-25 18:45:15

There was something about the first book that made me not warm to Raynor Win - or is it now Sally Wslker - so whilst I enjoyed it for the elements of the journey and the South West and the idea of an epic walk I have hung back from going to see the film.Now I'm glad.And if its all true about the theft and the real reason they lost their house I think it leaves a nasty taste that the books have made them do much money.They are basically dishonest.

Tess46 Sun 06-Jul-25 18:40:55

When the book first came out a friend bought it, read it and passed it to me saying how wonderful this couple were etc etc. Within the first few chapters I thought theres so much here that doesn’t add up and this couple are clever con merchants I felt sure. But no one else thought so and they rose higher and higher in their fame and tv interviews. But still I did not believe them but as it didn’t matter a jot to me I never gave them another thought. But it seems my distrust of them and their well crafted story was well founded and I’m not just a cynical old dear who begrudges others fame and fortune!

MayBee70 Sun 06-Jul-25 18:40:01

I wonder how Gigspanner and, to a lesser degree Angela Harding will react to this revelation?

Sago Sun 06-Jul-25 17:51:22

It will be interesting to see what comes out of the woodwork.

Apparently all this came about because Raynor stole from an employer.

However even if they are fraudulent many thousands of us have enjoyed the book and now the film!

I’m sure they will find a way to make amends.