Gransnet forums

Books/book club

Long books

(90 Posts)
Wheniwasyourage Tue 24-Nov-20 17:43:55

Why are books so long these days? I have just re-read (for the umpteenth time) Miss Pym Disposes by Josephine Tey, which has 192 pages in paperback. I have also just finished Troubled Blood, the latest Robert Galbraith novel, which has 927 (!!) pages in hardback. Both good stories, but by the time I had finished Troubled Blood I had forgotten quite a lot of what had happened earlier in the book. What do you think - are books sometimes just too long?

Wheniwasyourage Thu 26-Nov-20 15:48:11

Well done Applegran. War and Peace is on my shelf and I must get on with reading it rather than feeling that I should be dusting it.

Naesodaft Thu 26-Nov-20 15:41:58

I bought the latest Robert Galbraith book when it came out, pre-ordered on Amazon actually because I enjoyed the previous books so much. It has sat on my coffee table since it arrived. Can only think I’ve not started it yet simply because it is too big. I blame my kindle!

Conni7 Thu 26-Nov-20 14:20:44

Thanks for all the interesting suggestions. My daughter bought me a small bean bag to rest heavy books on in bed. It takes the weight.

Applegran Thu 26-Nov-20 13:53:52

Have just finished War and Peace - decided finally to read it beginning in the first lock down! Of course it is great and certainly kept me enthralled - though I didn't enjoy the long essays on the nature of history and causes of war. In the end I skipped these - but the story, notoriously long, is great. I read it on my Kindle - I prefer a paper book, but a Kindle is easy to hold. It didn't matter that its a long book once I began it - though in advance I'd been daunted.

Soozikinzi Thu 26-Nov-20 13:17:48

I agree that some books are overlong . I use the borrowbox app on my phone to listen to library books when I’m out walking the dog . All free ! It’s brilliant!

Craftycat Thu 26-Nov-20 13:15:48

I've just finished Troubled Blood too.
It was good but I wish they would get together soon. We can't wait much longer.
Now reading the new Rebus which has started well.
I can lose myself in a book for hours. On holiday I am on the beach all day reading & meet up with DH for lunch by pool & then go back until it is time to shower & get ready for evening. Missed it this year but read in the garden every day instead.
I have always been mad about books.
My Kindle has made them so much easier to read & carry around too!

Severnsider Thu 26-Nov-20 12:23:52

I've been re-reading Thomas Hardy - comfortable reading - Wessex in the 19th century. And I enjoyed re-reading 'Rogue Herries' set in the Lake District. In Hardy the Mayor of Casterbridge sells his wife - Rogue Herries sells his mistress! Those were the days.

harrysgran Thu 26-Nov-20 12:22:06

I must admit I prefer a shorter read I'm reading Maeve Binchy Chestnut street its a Christmas themed book with about 40 short stories it's a heavy book but great to just pick up and read for ten fifteen minutes. I love audio at night I'm listening to The Switch read by Alison Steadman it's funny and an insight into how you are never too old for change

leeds22 Thu 26-Nov-20 12:17:18

I often give up on huge tomes and download to Kindle. It's not necessarily a new thing, as one of my more cerebral aims for lockdown I decided to read Middlemarch by George Eliot but its 889 pages long, so just sits there together with Donna Tartt's Goldfinch.

sodapop Thu 26-Nov-20 12:15:52

Thanks Jaxie I'll look for them.

Jaxie Thu 26-Nov-20 12:12:40

Soda pop: try Jane Gardam’s short stories, you may change your mind. The fact that they remain in my mind might be that I taught them at A level many years ago, so got to know them inside out. The themes are very pertinent to the things that trouble Gransnetters.

LancsLass Thu 26-Nov-20 11:58:01

Reading this with interest, for suggestions on authors I haven't read yet. Not reading books at the moment - can't concentrate on anything for long enough! But wanted to mention something that may be useful to those of you who've mentioned you have problems with holding books. I was thinking of getting one for when I'm back to reading. JML do a Pill-o-Pad, a very lightweight triangular-section foam-type thingy that will prop up tablets or books at different angles. I frequently have painful fingers, wrists and neck these days, and find myself watching far too much telly instead of reading, like I used to. I'm loving Granset, it's helping to keep me sane at the moment! It's my first ever message, so hope I'm not breaking any rules here.

lulusmf Thu 26-Nov-20 11:57:45

I love a long book!!!

grandtanteJE65 Thu 26-Nov-20 11:46:33

As far as I am concerned, a good book just cannot be too long.

Moggycuddler Thu 26-Nov-20 11:22:06

Some books are long, some are short. Some are even middling length . . . If they're really good, doesn't matter if they're long, does it??

nipsmum Thu 26-Nov-20 11:19:31

Long or short if I'm enjoying it, it is never long enough

SueEH Thu 26-Nov-20 11:16:13

I’m just starting on a 1,300 pager! I like something to get my teeth into smile

Annaram1 Thu 26-Nov-20 11:15:32

I love Charles Dickens and even with the lengthy descriptions I have never been bored for a moment. I have written a book, just finished it, and it is less than 75000 words long. Just can't increase it! The other one I am writing, set in the first WW, demands so much research that I can't see myself finishing it. It could be a long book... if ever...The only recent books I have read are the Fifty Shades by E L James. Could do with a complete rewrite and edit. But hey! - she sells!

Bazza Thu 26-Nov-20 11:12:37

Spot on Chaitriona, if you’re really enjoying a book, whatever the length, it’s almost a shame to finish it.

I can’t say the same about films though (remember the cinema?) I find no matter how much I’ve enjoyed it, it always seems at least 20 minutes too long. I’ve love to be a film editor!

Chaitriona Thu 26-Nov-20 10:31:12

A book that bores you is always too long. A book that you love is never too long. In fact you can regret coming to the end of it.

Quilty Thu 26-Nov-20 10:24:07

I love the story of Les Misersbles. The dramatisation excellent, the abridged book excellent......but oh the unabridged book-how hard it is to read. 1400 pages of small print. I've got to page 200 or so 3 times and then given up. Think I'll try again!!!

GrammarGrandma Thu 26-Nov-20 10:19:56

sayse I think you have married Georgette Heyer to Thor Heyerdahl!

Growing0ldDisgracefully Thu 26-Nov-20 10:16:09

I was given the complete set of 8 Outlander books by Diana Gabaldon. Just hoping the books will hold my attention the way the series has. Just starting to turn the corner from a nasty dose of covid so hopefully will be up to concentrating soon.

Chardy Wed 25-Nov-20 21:52:32

A few years ago, a friend complained she couldn't read a lengthy hardback she'd been given as she couldn't physically hold it for long. I saw the book as a 2nd hand paperback for £1.50, bought it, and told her to cut it in half. We did both laugh when I asked her if she was enjoying it, as after 100 pages, she decided she didn't like it. The hardback was sent to the charity shop.

etheltbags1 Wed 25-Nov-20 20:17:24

My spellchecker will not allow me to type Donna T A R R T as a word. Sorry.